Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Samuel Getachew

GET UPDATES FROM Samuel Getachew
 

Ford's Tea Party-Like Solutions to Toronto Violence

Posted: 07/19/2012 4:51 pm

Earlier today, an identified man was discovered in a school playground and pronounced dead from gunshot wounds. This follows the killings of two young people in Scarborough on Monday and another man who was shot and killed in a soccer field on Tuesday.

The latest killing was Toronto's 30th homicide of the year.

In a desperate city that is looking for answers, its mayor, Rob Ford, and his colleague and member of the mayor's executive committee, Councillor Michael Thompson, offer unusual Tea Party-like simple solutions to a complex made in Canada problem.

Earlier this week, the mayor promised to have a sit down with the Prime Minister to motivate him to change immigration laws to deport convicted gang members from Toronto. According to media reports, he has not been able to connect the issues he sees the recent tragedies with immigrants and gang violence.

The fact is that most of these crimes are being alleged committed by Canadian born and raised young Canadians.

The mayor was the lone member of council to vote against $16 million in community grants earlier this month. His reason -- "social spending is not effective as a solution to youth violence." He also became the only member of city council to vote against accepting $350,000 from the federal government for a year-long gang intervention project from the National Crime Prevention Center.

In announcing a major funding in 2008, the conservative government of Stephen Harper via former Minister Stockwell Day announced how:

Our government is concerned with gang violence in Toronto neighborhoods and today's announcement is another concrete action this government is taking to prevent crime among youth...We have listened to the concerns of the police and the City of Toronto on this issue...This funding will go a long way to prevent at-risk youth from getting involved with gangs and will help them make better choices.

In his "urgent" meeting with Premier Dalton McGuinty this coming Monday, the mayor has promised to ask for funds to hire more police officers and call for lengthy prison terms for convicts. "Once they're charged and they go to jail the most important thing is when they get out of jail, I don't want them living in this city," he commented.

Legal scholars are at a loss for words how anyone can be prevented from living in a city of their choice.

Scarborough Councillor Michael Thompson is looking at revisiting one of a slew of ideas he has brought in his municipal career to help curb the violence. These past ideas have included giving the police the power to target and question black youth (racial profiling) and evicting Toronto Community Housing residents whenever they are convicted of drug and gun crimes without the right to appeal.

Evict them as in make them homeless? How about their family members? The mayor supports the idea and according to him, "if one gets caught with a gun you shouldn't be allowed to live ...not just in Toronto Community Housing but in the city."

It is shocking that these rhetoric and perspectives are coming for the most senior members of our municipal government. Their ideas are wrong and disturbing at best.

Coincidentally, the people whose perspectives are much needed are those that work with the young people in question. For instance, according to one youth activist, Kim Katrin Crosby:

[If we as a society] Affirm our young people and tell them that they are unique and special and then they are racially profiled and all grouped in a monolith, then the police are not accountable to the communities...If every time a Black person fires a gun, it gets automatically added to the rhetoric about us as savage and violent, but when white folks commit acts of violence we don't get fed racist rhetoric about the white crime rate and demands for Europeans to go back to their country then the media is not accountable to us.

If putting more people in prison and giving them an instant criminal record was a great solution -- Crobsy adds, then the United States would be the safest country in the world.

 

Follow Samuel Getachew on Twitter: www.twitter.com/GetachewS

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
djelimon17
what's this thing for?
11:44 AM on 07/22/2012
Wait, I'm responsible for people who look like me? What?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hal Wood
11:10 PM on 07/21/2012
What needs to be done is put the truth in the open, Put the numbers out there according to race religion, immigrant and refugee status. How long in Canada, how long family in Canada. Until a black person steps forward with some reallity it will never end . Too bad so many people make their money and fame by keeping facts secret. Put it out there and take responsability for your race if your going to use it so freely.
photo
Gnomish
ego doctus ignarus
06:38 PM on 07/20/2012
Get scared swing at the easy target...Puff up as big as you can. All common defensive techniques among the panic prone.
01:43 PM on 07/20/2012
For every problem there is a simple, obvious solution. Which is almost always wrong. We need to stop electing the people pushing the simple, obvious solutions.
12:35 PM on 07/20/2012
This is so typical of how Mr. Ford's been behaving as chief magistrate of this city. Despite all of the evidence which point towards the benefits of rehabilitating offenders and the communities affected by crime, Mr. Ford, foolishly, supports a very 'black and white' solution on the matter. As one of the most diverse and culturally unique cities on the planet, we need a crime prevention strategy that compliments these phenomenal aspects of our city.
10:27 AM on 07/20/2012
If caught with a hand gun, you should get to know Black Flies real well and be good at constructing housing, and digging wells in outlying Native communities. Send them straight to a healing circle. They'll know what to do with them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mr Lyons
views of an meat-eating socialist
09:37 AM on 07/20/2012
rob ford has no clue, but in his defense neither does anyone else. banning hand guns sounds good, but the guns killing these people are illegal so really they are banned. kicking people out of the city, well, lets just leave that turkey alone.
in my opinion, and i know probably less then most, there is never going to be a solution unless all parties, federal provincial, municipal and community leaders sit down and come up with concrete, sensible and socially forward thinking plans.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hal Wood
08:35 PM on 07/21/2012
That is the most common sense letter of the day. Just one question ,if smokers can be banned everywhere, why can't someone like a known gang member that could get involved in a shoot out at any time be banned from public places?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mr Lyons
views of an meat-eating socialist
09:42 AM on 07/25/2012
smokers are not banned from everywhere, we're just banned from smoking everywhere. kicking gang members out of the city is only shifting the problem to another jurisdiction.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AlexEm El
Not Unlike a Socialist
08:37 AM on 07/20/2012
The problem is that people are scared. And when people are scared, they make rash decisions without considering the repercussions. They simply think "Well, these people did something bad, so they must be bad." instead of asking "What drove them to this?" This is simply scape-goating, easy profiling that the right always turns to in hard times. For the Nazis, it was the Jews. For the Republicans, it's the Mexicans. For Rob Ford, it's young migrants, even though these people aren't actually migrants at all.

This is forgetting that these murderers, these youth offenders, are humans too. No human is driven to this out of some malevolent force they are born with, they are pushed to this through poverty, through hopelessness. It's like trying to curb the illegal drug trade by arresting young high school drop outs and putting them in prison: the gangs find younger members and those arrested come out worse than before.

If they really want to make a change, the change has to happen at the community level: An ounce of prevention is better than a pound of the cure.
photo
TonyOnly
Truth matters.
07:15 AM on 07/20/2012
Ford's clueless. This is beyond his ability to resolve.
09:53 AM on 07/20/2012
Resolving? His intellect can't even handle a conversation about the subject.
photo
TonyOnly
Truth matters.
10:58 AM on 07/20/2012
I feel bad picking on the guy. But as a non Torontonian, I can't help but wonder what were they thinking.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jrfunkenstein
'It's a sad and beautiful world'
06:09 AM on 07/20/2012
Ford continues to demonstrate his utter ignorance, incompetence and inability to deal with complex issues that require more than uber Conservative knee jerk reactions which have never rectified any urban problem since 1875.

He's a disgrace to the office and an embarrassment to the city.
05:35 AM on 07/20/2012
Rob Ford needs to understand that Toronto is a city in the province of Ontario in the country of Canada, not a country on it's own.

In Canada, all residents are permitted to live wherever they choose to live, as long as they can afford to live there.

How can he rationally suggest that anyone convicted of a gun crime should not be allowed to live in Toronto? Is he really that simple-minded? Really? People of Toronto, please remember this kind of nonsense when you head to the polls in the next municipal election. Is this the best on offer? Guys like Rob Ford embarrass you in front of the country and the world. How can you calim to be a world-class city when your mayor is spewing this kind of nonsensical stuff.
09:56 AM on 07/20/2012
In his mind, he's the little king of Toronto.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Skepticat
Supporting skeptical felines everywhere
11:26 AM on 07/20/2012
How about a person convicted of a gun crime living in jail for an extended period of time instead of Toronto or anywhere else ? Sort of works for me.
11:07 PM on 07/19/2012
The ignorant actions, views and words that come out of Rob Ford's mouth literally make my blood pressure rise. He is clearly incapable of acting as Mayor if council votes against him regularly. His agenda is clearly more cops, less service. He is a detriment to the city.
10:41 PM on 07/19/2012
I remember Tom Campbell's comments in Vancouver when he suggested taking hippies out to sea and drowning them. Tom "Terrific" had no real ideas but like Ford played demogogue. Maybe Ford should think about how he could get these kids off the streets and into jobs which can support them.
09:27 PM on 07/19/2012
So instead of identifying and addressing the root causes of the problem, he'd rather just hire more police officers and try to expel convicts from the city. Simpleton 'solutions' cause more harm in the long run.
05:58 PM on 07/19/2012
it comes as no surprize to anyone that the solutions which come from ford are simple .
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:05 PM on 07/19/2012
riddle me this. how is it politicians and cops could preemptively arrest activists six months before the G20 but can't find the bad guys with guns. jes sayin
12:15 AM on 07/20/2012
I like the way you think, pard!