Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sandra Charron

GET UPDATES FROM Sandra Charron
 

Why Women Judge Other Women More Than Men

Posted: 02/26/2013 12:20 pm

For years I have heard the term "Working Parent's Guilt." My stay-at-home friends and I, always ready to slay the reputation of our fellow women in the quintessential ploy to be the superior mothers, would belittle those who left their little darlings with babysitters or in daycare in order to work outside the home and pursue careers.

"I would never do that," we would say, sipping our coffee on our front porches as our children ran in circles in our fenced backyards. "Imagine if our children were away from us every single day, being watched by strangers." We'd nod in agreement as our little darlings who, by the third hour, were now tear-stained and snotty from the in-fighting occurring among the three-year-olds vying for the same plastic pail.

From my working friends, I would hear the counter argument: that having their children in daycare made the kids more sociable, intellectually advanced, and more receptive to kindergarten. "Kids that stay at home all day don't get the same kind of stimulation," they would say, and they would back it up with examples of their friend's two-year-old who sat in front of the TV all day while the mother surfed the Internet.

This is not an essay about working versus stay-at-home mothers. That topic has been beaten over the head with an anvil, and according to both camps still huffing and puffing as each one tries to shot-put the anvil at the other, ample examples of why they are the winners have been presented. This topic, however, demonstrates the slandering that goes on in the world in which women live.

Watching the various post-Oscar shows, one thing was made very evident: women looooove to put down other women. Oh sure, some female talk show hosts were kinder in their analysis of who had the prettiest dress and why, but most were quick to point out who should have been wearing a bra, who needed a seam sewn into her skirt, and who needed to redo her up-do.

Although all who spoke of Jennifer Lawrence's fall up the stairs were sympathetic in their play-by-play, that actress will go down in history, not for the award she won, but for tripping in a dress...Because apparently, tripping in a dress has never happened before?

Men don't vie with each other over parenting styles. Coach your kid in hockey, don't coach your kid; men don't even engage in conversations which categorizes one man as better than another related to issues which pertain to their children.

As for the Academy Awards, I don't even know what the men were wearing because the various women critiquing the Red Carpet, after gushing briefly over Bradley Cooper's blue eyes, quickly returned to the careful analysis of the thread count on each actress' gown, and wisecracked about Helena Bonham Carter's hairstyle (apparently her stylist neglected to actually style it).

In nursing, a profession dominated mostly by women, many nurses could name off several examples of occurrences when kindness and compassion were prevalent in their practice but not always exhibited between colleagues.

Research has shown not only that jobs held disproportionately by women report lower wages and pension funds than jobs held disproportionately by men, but that bullying in the workplace is not gender biased within male workers. Seventy per cent of the time, women will chose a target of the same sex. Why is it that in a male-dominated world, women are so quick to cut each other down, rather than speak up in defense of one another?

As someone who stayed at home with my four children for 13 years before going back to school, and now is slowly entering the work force, I can attest to the fact that my parenting technique has not changed. "Working Parent's Guilt" is squashed by my exhaustion. Last night, after completing my third 12-hour shift, when my 13-year-old daughter asked me for help with her geometry homework, rather than drag my weary body to the kitchen table, I offered my 17-year-old cold hard cash to be my substitute.

And just as Jennifer Lawrence flipped off the press later in the evening, after tripping up those stairs in that now infamous dress, I would do the same to anyone who dared criticize me. As a stay-at-home mother, I did what kept me sane then. And as a working mother, I pay my kids to do what keeps me sane now. Judge that ladies.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Jessica Chastain In Armani Privé

    The rose-colored gown shows off her figure, while the beading keeps the eye moving. Though simple, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/11/30/best-red-lipstick-2012_n_2205820.html">her bold red lips</a> add a punch of color.

  • Samantha Barks In Valentino

    The "<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/20/les-miserables-extended-trailer-anne-hathaway-russell-crowe-hugh-jackman_n_1900640.html">Les Miserables</a>" actress had our attention at hello. While black is certainly basic, that plunging neckline and stunning necklace certainly got our attention.

  • Octavia Spencer In Tadashi Shoji

    The award-winning actress <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/christina-anderson/the-help-octavia-spencer-2012-photos_b_2125289.html">always chooses the perfect shape to show off her body</a>. The off-the-shoulder neckline frames her face, while the fitted bodice adds a va-va-voom element that we are loving.

  • Naomi Watts In Armani Privé

    "<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/21/naomi-watts-impossible_n_2346016.html">The Impossible</a>" actress does high drama right! Silver sequins and cutouts make the perfect statement for a nominee -- sexy, eye-catching and sophisticated.

  • Helen Hunt In H&M

    "The Sessions" <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/09/helen-hunt-the-sessions-photos_n_2427036.html">star</a> is wearing H&M on the red carpet. That's amazing in and of itself, but additionally, the navy hue shines against her tanned skin tone, and her statement necklace pops off her column gown.

  • Jennifer Lawrence In Christian Dior Couture

    The "<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/23/indie-spirit-awards-2013-silver-linings-playbook_n_2751423.html">Silver Linings Playbook</a>" actress goes for high drama, and it works. The strapless neckline and fitted bodice are simple enough to contrast the voluminous skirt. Her upswept 'do and diamonds (the backward necklace!) add just a little necessary sparkle.

  • Nicole Kidman In L'Wren Scott

    The <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/16/nicole-kidman-hollywood-reporter-cover-photo_n_2488879.html">Australian actress</a> is stunning in liquid sequins. We love that she went a different route than usual with a dramatic train.

  • Charlize Theron In Christian Dior Couture

    The details in this sleek, gorgeous gown have us looking twice. The V at the neckline, the<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/02/polka-dots-2012-fashion-trends_n_2388891.html#slide=1934249"> beaded peplum </a>and the train only add to an already elegant look. And that pixie! We love it.

  • Kerry Washington In Miu Miu

    We tip our hats to the "<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bob-cesca/django-unchained-movie-of-year_b_2458521.html">Django Unchained</a>" actress for taking a risk on the red carpet. Her beaded, coral dress was an oasis in a desert of pale hues. The red clutch played up all the berry tones in her look, and her easy hair and makeup let that dress steal the show.

  • Renee Zellweger In Carolina Herrera

    Liquid sequins are a trend on this <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/17/oscars-2013-red-carpet-photos_n_2707963.html?1361744443#slide=2145163">Oscars red carpet</a>, and for good reason. They add shine without going over the top. The "Bridget Jones Diary" star chose a simple tank-style dress and added interest with a ruby-colored clutch and bracelets for a perfect ensemble.

  • Queen Latifah In Badgley Mischka

    The <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/06/04/queen-latifah-did-not-come-out-pride_n_1529566.html">actress </a>is stunning in this white gown. The V neckline highlights her décolletage while also framing her face, and the train is just enough drama to make waves. Her pink lips and slicked-back ponytail are the right details for such a sleek look. Brava.

  • Jennifer Aniston In Valentino

    We are thrilled that the star eschewed her usual black for such a vibrant color. The simple, strapless top and loose hair were casual, while the princess skirt was just dramatic enough for <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/news/oscars/">the Oscars</a>.

  • Zoe Saldana In Alexis Mabille Couture

    It's rare to see a gown with this much detail on the best-dressed list, but the actress really pulls it off. Her simple hairdo and minimal makeup let the floral embroidery take the spotlight, while the ombré detail at the hem keeps the eye moving.

  • Sally Field In Valentino

    Graceful and elegant, the "Lincoln" actress stuns in red.

  • Halle Berry In Versace

    The Oscar-winning actress works bold shoulder pads like an expert. The vertical stripes keep the eye moving to her lovely décolletage and trim waistline.

  • Emanuelle Riva In Lanvin

    The "Amour" star wore one of our favorite looks of the night. The turquoise gown and cape are far and away one of the most elegant Oscar looks ever. Completely timeless, and reminiscent of <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/22/gwyneth-paltrow-oscar-2012-_n_1373886.html" target="_hplink">Gwyneth Paltrow 's look</a> last year.

  • Giuliana Rancic In Rafael Cennamo

    The TV personality's hair is a nice change. The black gown is elegant, yet understated and all the couture-like detail adds curves.

 

Follow Sandra Charron on Twitter: www.twitter.com/SandraSheWrites

FOLLOW CANADA LIVING
 
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Leslie Botchar
05:04 PM on 03/13/2013
sharp tongues and bitter bile has been sprouting from lips since...well, forever. obviously there is just something within our human spirit that seeks out a weakness, difference or perceived abnormality in another, and then picks at it until it becomes an open wound. then we pour salt on it. But it's especially sad to me that it not only occurs with such venom between women; but that is usually superficially based. And really, it's so amazing to me, that it is not clear to such woman that in behaving in such a shallow manner, they are actually saying a lot more regarding how they feel about themselves. Really, can't see that?
11:42 AM on 02/27/2013
Ever witnessed a pack of women watching the Bachelor? It's always the biggest hate fest I've ever seen, judging every last thing every woman on the show says or wears. Same goes for the Oscars and other awards shows, women are always putting other women down for fun it's quite rediculous (only behind their back or a TV screen).
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:44 AM on 02/27/2013
Sadly its true, people tend to run each other down. Its not to make the world a better place through constructive criticism.
09:48 AM on 02/27/2013
There's a saying that goes "Don't try to get to know women better. Women know women and they hate each other." It was funny at first and then it became somewhat fascinating. I repeated the saying to my wife and a few others and heard nervous laughter and general agreement. Is it trending different than before or has it been this way for generations? Another mystery about them :-)
09:05 AM on 02/27/2013
my girl knows im watching other girls. it makes her so happy inside, when i criticise the dress of another
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pondering panda
08:23 AM on 02/27/2013
I'm not sure about all the other undertone on opinions n this article, but I do wholly agree that most women are ready sink their teeth into another woman at first sign of weakness or even confidence. This is the reason that I don't have many girlfriends. I'll admit that the lure of juicy gossip can be attractive, but the repercussions are awful. I'd rather just avoid the whole scenario altogether.
07:32 AM on 02/27/2013
Its not a women's problem, its a people problem. People who need to mature beyond a high school age mentality. I think we see it more in women because we are looking for women to confirm a stereotype, but I've definitely seen that behaviour in men as well. My partner describes similar 'cattyness' among his male co-workers.
05:35 AM on 02/27/2013
As a male working among many women in an elementary school, I find the amount of gossip and backstabbing between women teachers deplorable. There is constant whispering and finger pointing amid the phoney smiles and false gestures. As a male, I'm entirely grateful for only hearing tiny snippets of the venomous trash talking many females engage in constantly.

Gossips have a disease which may not make them feel ill, but it definitely sounds sick.
photo
jf12
When I saw her I marveled greatly.
05:29 PM on 02/26/2013
Just pointing out that women's harshing each other also happens (e.g. nursing) where men don't dominate.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Copernicus TheWinner
05:25 PM on 02/26/2013
Internet showed me that this isn't true and men are just as judgmental. Only women are more vocal with their judgement
photo
dongarb
Give Up The Ground and Embrace The Void
03:42 PM on 02/26/2013
The writer looks back in nostalgia to that golden time when all women were best of friends, loyal to each other every day, in every way. When exactly was that again?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:27 PM on 02/26/2013
I love how women bullying other women still ends up being men's fault in this woman's mind. The answer lies in the title beneath the authors name. Being a mother and a wife isn't an accomplishment like being a nurse is. Modern women's constant need for approval and admiration over the most trivial of things (look at me I can breed) leads to them shitting on one another to increase their personal share of attention.
01:09 AM on 02/27/2013
"Being a mother and a wife isn't an accomplishment like being a nurse is."

This is such nonsense. The only reason you don't see it as an accomplishment is because having a child is something only a woman can do. And anything women do has no value in a man's world. Which is why women do the vast majority of unpaid labour.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:20 PM on 02/27/2013
It isn't. Raising successful children is an accomplishment merely being able to breed is the same thing an other animal can do. Of course it has value but nobody forces you to have kids, if you choose to than you shouldn't be applauded for simply doing your duty to raise them. If your husband doesn't help out around the house that's your problem, you choose him. 
10:44 PM on 02/27/2013
my son is my greatest accomplishment... and i know my husband would say the same!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:12 AM on 02/28/2013
It's not an accomplishment. Raising a successful child is an accomplishment. Simply being able to procreate isn't. There is a distinct difference.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:23 PM on 02/26/2013
There is truth to the statement that one should "walk a mile in my shoes." Your comment about nursing is very insightful. Healthcare professionals may be good at looking after patients while failing dismally at looking after a struggling colleague or sometimes even themselves.