As animal welfare groups around the world eagerly await India's Supreme Court verdict on the petition for captive elephants filed by Wildlife Rescue and Rehabilitation Center (WRRC), Ms. Suparna Baksi Ganguly, (SG) the Hon. President of WRRC weighs in on the future of India's heritage animal, and the precarious situation of Kerala's elephants. She is cautiously optimistic about the outcome, and calls on the government, animal welfare groups and the public to work collectively in order to provide adequate welfare for India's cultural icon.
SI: Please provide an overall status of the SC case as it stands now.
SG: As it stands now, the hearing on 21st September has been adjourned to Oct. 21, 2016. The Solicitor General requested that the matter be listed for final hearing. In the interim, the Court has directed no other Interlocutory Applications will be filed.
SI: What outcome do you expect?
SG: I expect that the Supreme Court will look into the prayers of the main petition which are wide ranging and focus on cruelties and abuse, ownership issues, rescue centers, employment of elephants in improper activities and stringent application of the Laws on all captive elephants in India as Schedule1 wildlife.
SI: Do you think evidence provided by Gods in Shackles documentary would have made any impact?
SG: Definitely. The film's impact has jarred the "cultural" sensibilities of the common public in Kerala. The visual shots from the film have also been submitted to the Court. Sadly, SC does not allow videos or film screenings but the volume of data submitted with large color photos of atrocities has made an impact, judging by the Interim Orders so far that have been directed by the Hon'ble Justice Dipak Mishra to all the States in India.
SI: If they ban use of elephants how long do you think it would take for states to implement?
SG: I cannot imagine that the States would rush to execute such an Order, so it may be conditional at one level and unconditional on another. We cannot really anticipate either the Final Order or the process of implementation but at least the states have formed the Captive Elephant Welfare Committees where there is scope for complaints to be redressed.
SI: If they ban use of elephants in circuses, or festivals, is there an alternate plan for the 4,000 captive elephants in India?
SG: We have made a prayer for the States to form Elephant Rescue Centers on Govt. land and with State and Central budget allocation. The detailing of that will be left to the individual Governments to take up. In my opinion, there will be certain amount of uncertainty faced by the custodians and users of such animals and the first generation of elephants post such an order, may face hardship. In the long run, it would have a very beneficial effect. The trade lines would be severed and the vast amounts of cash and black money and animal suffering that happen in procuring elephants for temples and private owners would have to be inevitably phased out. If demand drops and elephant displays have no value, then supply would also be affected in the true style of market economics!
SI: Who will take care of them, Government or animal welfare groups?
SG: The Government, since they have a permanency that an NGO would find it difficult to replicate. When we talk of elephants we talk easily of a commitment that can range up to 70 years. At the outer limit. It is good if the government collaborates with committed individuals and NGOs to share the burden of this massive, mammoth task.
SI: Where will they be released? Is there enough space for them?
SG: Rarely, can they be released! Most suffer from unique diseases, deformities, chronic infections and inability to adapt to the wild. In fact, they may also communicate diseases to the wild elephants. Hence their first entry should be to a space where there is proper sheltering and veterinary care and then reviewed periodically over the years. Also India's forest covers are shrinking and corridors and passages essential for elephants to survive are disappearing at an alarming rate. Wherever such elephants are released, they would be blamed for escalating human elephant conflicts and possibly be killed since they have no fear of humans and would readily approach villages for food, if hungry.
Gods in Shackles still shot used in the Supreme Court of India
SI: The problem is unique for Kerala as all of them are bull elephants and they are solitary animals. How can this be handled?
SG: It is a horrid, unnatural situation. In the wild, mature tuskers do not even occupy the same spaces... In Kerala, such elephants are tied and made to rub shoulders with each other! The deep invisible stress that they go through is probably unimaginable to humans because they have these animals under control through the most heinous methods.
One would need vast spaces to house them and that too would be a travesty because it would be a minuscule of what male elephants require to roam and forage and for their mental and physical health. That is why I feel that the first generation of such elephants would suffer in some ways but at least the future generations would be saved from such regressive practices.
SI: What do you think needs to be done?
SG: It really depends on the directions that the Supreme Court gives on this issue. There is no certainty that the prayers will be granted as we have envisioned. In such a case, we will need to rework strategies. The only important thing is to grant some critical relief for these suffering elephants all over the country.
SI: There are many animal welfare groups operating in silos, and yet knowledge and resource sharing is important, what's your take on this?
SG: It is extremely important that all animal welfare groups work in close harmony and if this does not happen, we would not be doing the right thing for the elephants. The problems are vast, the elephants needing help are many and people and organizations need to mature and develop to assist the Governments to take on this task.
Follow HuffPost Canada Blogs on Facebook
Also on HuffPost:
Baby elephant has a swim at Melbourne Zoo in the hot summer heat on March 31, 2015, in Melbourne, Australia.
Nandgopal, 8, and Lavindya, 4, asleep next to Giri, an orphaned elephant calf who was rescued from Javalagiri Range of Hosur Forest Division in southern India, on April 26, 2010, in Chennai, India. These adorable youngsters have found unlikely friends in orphaned elephant calves.
A five-day-old Asian elephant calf helps his aunty to raise her foot for the keeper at the Melbourne Zoo, on September 15, 2010.
Tourists visiting Kenya watch the baby elephants at the David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust elephant orphanage Feb. 12, 2008 in Nairobi, Kenya.
The three-day-old as yet unnamed baby elephant plays with his mother 'Pori' in their enclosure at the Zoological Garden (Tierpark) Berlin on May 23, 2007, in Berlin, Germany.
In this picture taken March 11, 2007, two baby elephants walk at the edge of a water hole at the Udawalawe National Park,some 200 kilometers (125 miles) south of Colombo.
An Indian mahout hands a half loaf of bread to a baby elephant at The Assam State Zoo in Guhawati, Oct. 4, 2006, during World Animal Day.
British tourist Nicki Kelk gets her hat taken off her head by a baby elephant at the Thai Elephant Conservation Center July 14, 2006 in Lampang, Thailand.
Orphan baby elephants play on June 22, 2015, at the David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust in Nairobi, a Kenyan wildlife conservation charity.
This picture taken on August 12, 2014, during World Elephant Day, shows orphaned baby elephants at the David Sheldrick Elephant Orphanage, at the Nairobi National Park.
Three-month-old baby pygmy elephant 'Joe' reacts inside a temporary holding cage at Lok Kawi Wildlife Park in Kota Kinabalu in Malaysia's Sabah state on Feb. 6, 2013.
Elephant with baby in Kenya.
An elephant looks on at the Pinnawela Elephant Orphanage in Pinnawela on June 10, 2012.
A handler washes an elephant in a river at the Pinnawela Elephant Orphanage in Pinnawela on June 10, 2012.
Asian elephants take a bath in a pool at the zoo in Hanover, northern Germany, on April 27, 2012.
The elephants all walk in a line as they return to their huts for the evening in Nairobi.
A mahout from the Pinnawela elephant orphanage wrangles a crowd of elephants as they take their afternoon bath in a river near the facility.
Young elephants playing in Kenya.
Elephant Nelly plays with a ball, as an "animal oracle" to predict results of the Germany vs Ukraine match at Euro 2016, in the "Safari Park" in Hodenhagen, Germany.
An elephant holds some leaves in his trunk on July 6, 2016, at the Tierpark Hagenbeck zoo in Hamburg, northern Germany.
Follow Sangita Iyer on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Sangi8