Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Senator Mobina Jaffer
 

Time to Apologize for Komagata Maru

Posted: 05/18/2012 5:03 pm

May 23, 1914 was a shameful day in Canadian history. May 23, 1914 was the day that the Komagata Maru, a ship carrying 376 people of South Asian decent, sailed from Japan to the shores of British Columbia. Unfortunately, after spending over a month at sea, the 12 Hindus, 24 Muslims and 340 Sikhs, all of whom were eager to start a new life, were denied entry into Canada.

NDP MP Jasbir Sandhu's motion today urged the Government of Canada to officially apologize in Parliament to the South Asian community and to the individuals impacted by the 1914 Komagata Maru incident in the House of Commons.

For two long months all 376 passengers were forced to stay on board the ship. Not only was it made clear that their presence in our country was unwelcome, Canadian officials also denied passengers very basic necessities such as food and water. For 63 days all of those on board the Komagatu Maru lived in extremely confined spaces fighting hunger and dehydration.

They waited patiently clinging to the hope that perhaps they would be granted entrance into Canada, a country which they believed would provide them with opportunity and a new beginning. Unfortunately, after spending over two months on Canadian waters, the Komagata Maru, and almost all of those on board were forced to depart and return to Asia.

The Komagata Maru incident occurred during a time in Canadian history where there was a deep-seated prejudice against minorities and immigrants, particularly those who were of South Asian descent. Unfortunately, these prejudices were supported by law for during this time there existed a Continuous Passage Act, which stated that South Asians were only allowed to enter into Canada if they had made a continuous voyage without any stopovers.

This particular clause was implemented in an attempt to stop South Asian immigrants from entering Canada for at this time it was not possible for a ship to travel continuously from India to Canada. Although those on board did abide by this law by departing directly from Japan to Canada without stopping over, the fact that they were still denied entry is a reflection of the racist and discriminatory attitudes that were prevalent at this time.

On August 3, 2008 Prime Minister Harper apologized to the South Asian community about the Komagata Maru incident. However the fact that this apology was not delivered in the House of Commons is unacceptable.

I commend Sandhu for introducing this motion and I applaud his commitment to this extremely important issue. Having worked closely with the South Asian community residing in my province of British Columbia, I am well aware of the hurt and pain that was perpetuated by the Komagata Maru incident.

This is why on June 21, 2011 I introduced the very same motion in the Senate of Canada, stating:

"Honourable senators, I give notice that, at the next sitting of the Senate, I will move that the Government of Canada officially apologize in Parliament to the South Asian community and to the individuals impacted in the 1914 Komagata Maru incident."

Historically, the government has extended official apologies in Parliament to acknowledge injustice and wrongdoing. For example, in June of 2010, Prime Minister Harper delivered an official apology to those Aboriginal people who were victims of the Canadian residential school system. Similarly, in 2006, Prime Minister Harper delivered an official apology to those Chinese-Canadian's who were unfairly taxed when immigrating to Canada.

Both of these apologies were extended in a very respectful manner. Both of these apologies recognized the pain, suffering and injustice that was inflicted upon these communities. The 376 passengers on board the Komagata Maru as well as all of those people who were negatively affected by the racist and discriminatory immigration policies that existed at this time also deserve an official apology.

The Canada I know is a country that embraces multiculturalism and welcomes people from all walks of life. The Canada I know prides itself on treating people of all races, religions and creeds with fairness, respect and dignity. Although the Komagata Maru incident happened almost a century ago, it represents a very sad time in our country's history.

I have heard from over 10,000 of my constituents in British Columbia, who have all expressed to me that they would like to be given the same respect that has been extended to other groups and receive an apology in Parliament. It is my sincere hope that we will continue debating this important issue both in the Senate and in the House of Commons, and urge our Government to do the right thing and deliver an apology to the South Asian community and to all of those affected by the 1914 Komagata Maru incident.

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
May 23, 1914 was a shameful day in Canadian history. May 23, 1914 was the day that the Komagata Maru, a ship carrying 376 people of South Asian decent, sailed from Japan to the shores of British Colum...
May 23, 1914 was a shameful day in Canadian history. May 23, 1914 was the day that the Komagata Maru, a ship carrying 376 people of South Asian decent, sailed from Japan to the shores of British Colum...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:47 PM on 05/22/2012
There is some considerable difficulty in applying modern morality to historical situations. Yes, the government's treatment of the people on the boat was horrible. But the government is under no obligation to accept anyone who manages to set foot on our shores. Even today, the government reserves and exercises the right to turn people away from our borders. In fact, a very similar situation occurred in 2010, when human traffickers attempted to bring almost 500 people illegally into British Columbia.

Reading the linked article, it's also fairly clear that the voyage was essentially a publicity stunt. The passengers were not immigrating to Canada through legitimate channels; they were arriving on our shores unannounced and were refused entry. While perhaps the government could have treated the passengers more humanely than they did, I think the government was probably well within its rights to refuse them in the first place.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
05:47 AM on 05/22/2012
This is satire, right?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
05:42 AM on 05/22/2012
Why?

We would likely deny them entry today as well?

Your revisionist history isn't even revisionist!

Cowardice.
10:18 PM on 05/21/2012
An apology is such a small gesture in acknowledging an injustice that it is difficult to understand such overblown and intolerant objections from some posters.
10:59 PM on 05/21/2012
OK Bronwyn, YOU dig up those who made the decisions and ask THEM to apologize.
01:16 PM on 05/21/2012
I suspect the incident was staged to prove a point.(rightfully so) To apologize for the acts of previous generations is meaningless and never ending for any culture. African Americans don't go to Africa and demand apologies from tribal elders who generations earlier sold them into slavery. The apology is in the acts of current society and it will never be perfect, but it is ongoing, how else do you think Mr Sandhu became a senator.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kenneth T Tellis
08:22 AM on 05/21/2012
Yes! Apologize for the SS Komagata Maru, but only after the Indian government apologizes for its occupation troops murdering 120,000 Kasmiri civilians consisting of men, women and children. If not, then tell those South Asians to go take a HIKE!
photo
lilkitten22
Be the change that you wish to see in the world
02:59 PM on 05/24/2012
that's a bit childish; you say sorry first, or we won't at all?
08:48 PM on 05/19/2012
It doesn't matter if the individuals in that boat are dead or not. There's an immense lively community living in the country who is still affected by tragedies such as the Komagata Maru incident. Apologizing at the very least addresses the prejudice minorities in general faced and are still continuing to face.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
04:40 PM on 05/19/2012
No apology necessary.

Canada belongs to Canadians, and we are under no obligation to allow anyone other than Canadian citizens into the country.......and we need not explain ourselves.

Personally, I find the idea that we might owe an apology quite offensive.
01:23 AM on 05/20/2012
Aaah yes your ancestors were part of the first nations - ergo were citizens of Canada. Else the idiotic and curiously illogical point of allowing only Canadian citizens into the country stupefies me.

And I suppose when you say "Canadians" you mean the ones with the paler skin tone. Nice...

And for the record - I don't think we should be going around apologizing for all the historical mistakes committed. We would all be better served by trying to not commit such acts going ahead.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
12:12 PM on 05/20/2012
Incorrect. 

My ancestors arrived here as refugees from the US War of Independence 230 years ago.

I don't care if you arrived here two years ago, nor do I care if your skin is black, yellow, red, or forest green with magenta stripes.  What I do care about is your citizenship......and if you are not Canadian, you have no right to be here.

And we owe you no apology for not allowing you to enter.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bcbailey64
01:17 PM on 05/23/2012
Personally, I find the idea that we don;t owe an apology quite offensive.
photo
Ian Llangan
Your Invisible Sky Friend Is Morally Abhorrent
02:13 PM on 05/19/2012
I would not suggest that past social injustices not be addressed, nor that they are not urgent, in spite of all of the many issues we face as a nation, particularly during a period when we have a very ideologically-driven government hell-bent on dismantling our most valued institutions and lying to us at every possible turn. However, the participants in this incident are mostly, if not all dead, and these ridiculously ritual "apologies" signify nothing and fool no one. If the Senator is sincere in her wish that such an incident be acknowleged and never repeated, she would do better to sit down with the publishers of textbooks on Canadian history and to re-focus her work on getting legislation passed that addresses both past and current social justice issues. The Kabuki theatre of public "apology" is hollow, time-worn and mostly goes by unnoticed. Essentially public apologies are wastes of time, money and energy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
09:15 AM on 05/19/2012
Didn't Captain Kirk figure out how to reprogram the simulator to beat this?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Phatbiker
Dentalfloss tycoon
02:11 PM on 05/20/2012
That,s what I thought, we will have to apologize to the Klingons. I think that was the Kobayashi Maru.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
10:16 PM on 05/20/2012
Apologize to the Klingons? Did WE blow up Praxis by overmining too close to the core? I think not!
02:28 AM on 05/19/2012
What a waste of time and money in the Senate, Parliment, House of Commons and any other taxpayer funded branch. Surely you must have far more important things to do, like Govern. 98 year old junk in a trunk ... good lord.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:13 PM on 05/18/2012
Do you really want Harper's hollow substance-less apology? do you think he cares?