Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Shachi Kurl

GET UPDATES FROM Shachi Kurl
 

Kate Middleton Pregnancy: Happy Royal News Turns Into Macabre State Of Affairs

Posted: 12/07/2012 2:41 pm

Enough already. It's just a baby. It is not Rosemary's baby. It is not even the Virgin Mary's baby. Frankly, if you don't subscribe to the idea that life begins at conception (and not everyone does) you could argue that is isn't even a baby yet.

And under no circumstances, none, should the existence of this baby, or this fetus, have led to the unspeakably tragic circumstances under which a nurse at a London hospital apparently took her own life.

I am happy for the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge the way I am happy for any couple that is ready and excited to start a family. Even though they have courted the culture of celebrity in which they now live, I feel sorry for them: forced to divulge her condition weeks before most mothers-to-be — wary of the viability of a pregnancy in its first trimester — might blab the big news.

U.S. talk shows even speculated as to when the royal fetus might actually have been conceived. Eww.

Will and Kate will spend the next several months under even more intense scrutiny than usual, because we, the consuming public, are supposedly interested. But beyond celebrity interest, Middleton's pregnancy is wholly unconnected to me — and frankly, to most Canadians. We aren't going to be invited to her baby shower. I will not be cuddling, kissing and playing with this baby. I will not be asked to babysit.

The only tangible connection this unborn child has to Canada is its place in line to the throne. But given that recent polling suggests only one-third of Canadians surveyed say they'd like to see this country remain a monarchy, given that there are two more heirs set to reign first, and given that the Windsors live remarkably long lives, it may come to pass that by the time "Baby X" ascends the throne, we may no longer be a constitutional monarchy.

People here love their Queen. They will feel more ambivalent about her successors, both living and not-quite-yet of this realm.

Australia, with its fierce republican sentiment, ought to care even less. And yet that country produced the two imbeciles who thought it would be fun and "lighthearted" to breach one woman's privacy, and literally destroy the life of another.

Any broadcasting standards that exist in that country surely couldn't have been followed. Was there journalistic impetus to lie about who they were and then run tape, without anyone's consent, of a flustered nurse giving intimate details of the duchess' condition? No.

Was the story aimed at exposing lax security? No. It was two yahoo morning show DJs doing what yahoo morning show DJs do. They've since been yanked off the air. That should give them time to reflect on the fact that one of the two nurses involved in their stunt apparently killed herself after the fact.

What a mess. It was inevitable that Kate's pregnancy would have given birth to breathless media coverage and celebration whenever it was divulged. It should have been happy, frothy, celebrity news. Instead, a woman going through a very rough, early pregnancy goes to hospital and the whole world knows about it.

A nurse, fooled by broadcasters, mistakenly transfers a call that should have been hung up on, and is found dead days later. It is a sad, macabre state of affairs. The worst part of it is: we should be ready for more. Because in the long term, nothing is likely to change.

 

Follow Shachi Kurl on Twitter: www.twitter.com/shachikurl

FOLLOW CANADA LIVING
Enough already. It's just a baby. It is not Rosemary's baby. It is not even the Virgin Mary's baby. Frankly, if you don't subscribe to the idea that life begins at conception (and not everyone does) y...
Enough already. It's just a baby. It is not Rosemary's baby. It is not even the Virgin Mary's baby. Frankly, if you don't subscribe to the idea that life begins at conception (and not everyone does) y...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:26 PM on 12/12/2012
"But beyond celebrity interest, Middleton's pregnancy is wholly unconnected to me — and frankly, to most Canadians"

Most practical and sensible thing that I've read on the news lately. Kudoos to the author.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Parade Keegan
I Can Hear You
06:17 PM on 12/10/2012
As long as there are those in the public who put these royals (over-paid tourist attractions) on a pedestal there's going to be this drama. They're not god. PK was unaware of this prank and it didn't affect her or the royals. The nurse was upset about it (?) only because of the public perception that the royals are "more than" IMO. The hysteria and outrage about this prank is obscene. People should move on and the palace reaction is disturbing IMO.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gareth Price
12:38 AM on 12/10/2012
Yet another selfish, workshy, immigrant family producing babies which will have to be funded by the average British taxpayer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Parade Keegan
I Can Hear You
09:49 PM on 12/10/2012
Isn't the only immigrant Prince Philip?
10:11 PM on 12/08/2012
And yet the indignant writer continues to fan the flames of the story by publishing an article about it...
Probably the only useful discussion that should come from this is a discussion of mental health and suicide. No one should feel so personally shamed by what really was a trivial mistake in which no real harm was done, that they should feel the need to take their own lives. This is a tragedy that reveals just how fragile many of our friends and family members are.
10:35 AM on 12/08/2012
Let's hope Huff Post heeds this tragedy themselves, when they next post stupid comments and crass articles about accidents etc. Especially when they leave the comments open and people can write some nasty things about people they dont know, have very little knowledge of the event in question and a lot of the time, are downright ignorant and cruel.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]