Timing is everything in B.C. politics. And wouldn't you know, it's also the essence of thousands of Bollywood films.
A chance meeting that develops into forbidden love? Bollywood. The moment the evil uncle clunks granny on the head and makes off with the family fortune, leaving the heroine a pauper? Bollywood. But who thought Bollywood, India's prolific Hindi film industry, would be at the centre of a dramatic saga of its own, playing out on location over the next five months across British Columbia's political soundstage?
In an election year, the announcement of an $11 million investment from the B.C. government to host the first-ever Times of India Film Awards (TOIFA) was inevitably going to be high-profile — and contentious.
And so, cue the fight scene. The premier, her cabinet, and her party, against B.C.'s home-grown film industry, and the opposition B.C. New Democrats. Sitting in darkness, watching the tableau, popcorn in hand, are B.C. voters, especially those belonging to the South Asian diaspora.
Now this wouldn't be a true Bollywood saga unless there were three or four story lines running concurrent. So too is the case when arguing the value of bringing this awards show to Vancouver. Allow me to separate them out.
THE POLICY
There are those (including me) who say this is the exactly the type of thing all governments should be doing in the name of economic development. India is a huge market, with a 2011 estimated GDP of $4.4 trillion US.
The country boasts a booming middle class — more nouveau riche than even Dubai can entertain, and a healthy relationship with Canada, and particularly B.C. and Ontario, as a result of large émigré communities settled here.
In pursuing economic payoffs, previous governments have spent more. B.C. spent $925 million to host the 2010 Olympic Games. The Games broke even, according to VANOC. The full economic effects of having the world's eyes trained on us have yet to be tallied.
We spent about $800 million on Expo '86. It ran a $311-million deficit, but brought billions back into B.C. in the ensuing years.
The B.C. government is estimating a payoff of $13 million to $18 million in spending during the awards. TOIFA board member A.P. Parigi, speaking on the Bill Good Show, predicted an economic multiplier effect that will be seen in two to three years, when millions of moneyed Indians choose Vancouver as a tourism destination.
Could $11 million be spent on other more pressing needs? Yes. But if we agree that you sometimes have to spend money to make money, and as long as this is money being spent wisely, it's the responsibility of any government to pursue economic gain where and when it can. Indeed, the bid for the 2010 Olympics was a process started by then-NDP premier Glen Clark. His government opened a trade office in India too.
THE POLITICS
Having read all that, you think it would be case closed, roll credits, but for the horror-show optics surrounding this announcement. The politics of telling people you're spending a whack of cash to draw foreign filmmakers and crew to B.C. while 4,000 B.C.-based film industry employees gather to protest the decline of their trade doesn't make for happy endings. People who live in B.C. will vote in May's general election. People from Mumbai won't.
This billion-dollar industry claims it's dying. The Christy Clark government says it's put $285 million in tax credits and won't spend any more. Meantime, those incentives, originally offered to lure productions north of the border from Hollywood grow bigger in Ontario and Quebec as they seek to undercut B.C.'s offerings. It's never good when we fight amongst ourselves.
Whether B.C.'s film industry can sustain this as a wedge issue during the election campaign remains to be seen. And if the B.C. Liberals can't find a way to appease the industry, it may walk away and yield ground on this issue to the NDP, seeking other voters instead... which brings us back to Bollywood, and one hell of a photo-op.
No matter which side of the political divide you're on, pictures with India's biggest celluloid stars are valuable currency to politicians wooing votes in the South Asian community. Or at least that's the thinking. In an age of global celebrity, there are elements of truth to it. The premier smiling with a Shah Rukh Khan or Amitabh Bachan trumps the Opposition leader smiling with a local community do-gooder on the interest-o-meter every time.
But will it be enough? Liberal strategists following what they believe to be outgoing Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty's path to electoral victory may be disappointed. His government brought the International Indian Film Academy Awards to Toronto in 2011, and the Liberal leader mugged for every possible photo call he could. Did South Asian Bollywood fans cheer him like a matinee idol when he walked on stage? Would they have probably cheered if it had been Gary Bettman or Oscar the Grouch? Yes. It's the IIFAs! Everyone's in a good mood!
It's also worth pointing out that big moves were made on that campaign, notably, the cancellation of a controversial contract to build a power plant in Mississauga. The cost of that cancellation — $180 million — ended McGuinty's premiership. In other words, Bollywood ain't no magic bullet.
NDP insiders find themselves rather bemused by the whole thing. After all, they reason, New Democrats have a longer relationship with and deeper reach into the community. They have more South Asian candidates running in this election than the Liberals. Will it be enough to beat the star power a Priyanka Chopra might bring to the ballot box? We'll see.
THE PRICE CHECK
So put the politics aside, and let's go back to check the promised benefits of bringing TOIFA to B.C. against reality.
One of the carrots being dangled is bringing Hindi film production to B.C. Newsflash: that's been going on for years, under both NDP and Liberal governments. Consider 1997's "Pardes" — shot in Vancouver, along with "Koi Mil Gaya," released in 2003, and 2011's "Thank You." Chances are though B.C.'s economy will thank Bollywood if more decide to come.
The premier touts the Times of India Group's reach of 90 million people as people will be influenced by all the lovely things it will say about Vancouver. But a check of the Times of India main webpage the day after the announcement reveals no mention of the awards or our fair city. Maybe it will. Hopefully soon.
Finally, that $13 million to $18 million anticipated payoff? It's based on projections from Ontario hosting the IIFAs, a much more established awards show. Though the TOIFAs are being hailed in B.C. media as the "Bollywood Oscars," that honour actually belongs to the 58-year-old Filmfare awards, handed out just days ago. The IIFAs might be compared to the Golden Globes. The awards coming to Vancouver may be better described as the MTV Video Music Awards.
The good news is people love awards shows. As long as fans and stars turn up, it may not much matter. But in an industry where starlets and heroes exit stage left weekly, the pressure is on for TOIFA to deliver the biggest luminaries and headliners to ensure the Clark government achieves its projected return on investment.
THE PRONOUNCEMENT
Still with me? Emotionally spent? Worn out? Welcome to Bollywood. No flick ever lasts less than 2.5 hours. Ever. So how does this story conclude? If it's a happy ending for B.C. taxpayers, you'll hear about it. If it's a happy ending for the B.C. Liberals, you'll hear about it. And if it's not — well — you'll hear about that too. Because tragedy or comedy, there's always plenty of Dhoom! Dham! Dshoom! and Dhamaka! in Bollywood. And in B.C. politics too.
Follow Shachi Kurl on Twitter: www.twitter.com/shachikurl
She was told she was going to have to work hard like an Indian, not like a Canadian.
She was also told that the rate was $2500/MONTH flat. No overtime. As many hours per day and days per week as was required without question and she should expect 6-7 days per week and regularly up to 18-20 hours per day. And this is the kind of work that Christy wants to bring here? What a joke.
Since when? Whose numbers are those? Expo boosters/excuse-makers?? Vancouver was slow and kinda dead in the immediate years after. Concord Pacific left its huge acquisition of property for a song fallow, only to resell it to other developers years later; a huge loss to the public purse and highly questionable from day one.
What is the source for this claim? The GOVERNMENT??? Yeah, right......
Nice flowery spin but timing As you say is everything. I hope th community doesn't mind getting used.
to Clark's madness.
Who can afford to go to such an event. perhaps, the wealthy
South Asians, who lined Clark's campaign coffers, last election?