Harper and the Conservatives were elected to a majority government with next to no help from Quebec. As a result, the Tories have decided to rub it in Quebec's face. There is a long list of exemplifications of this, however, the most egregious of all the offences is the federal government's systematic disregard for the second official language of this country.
Since coming into power, the Tories have been stacking federal positions with Anglophones who can't speak French. First, there was Harper's communications director then there was the nomination of Michael Moldaver to the Supreme Court, and now there is the appointment of Michael Ferguson, a unilingual auditor general. Which is particularly odd, considering that Mr. Ferguson was the Deputy Finance Minister for New Brunswick, the country's only officially bilingual province, so one would have figured Mr. Ferguson would have needed to be bilingual for the provincial position he held.
All of the resolutely Anglophone speakers have vowed to learn French, but is that really enough? With a recession looming, and many people looking for jobs, shouldn't the government only be hiring truly qualified candidates? After all, the job description for the auditor general explicitly stated that proficiency in both languages was a requirement.
Moreover, on somewhat of a tangential aside, it is rather unfortunate that being a judge in the country's highest tribunal does not call for mandatory bilingualism. It only seems fair that someone getting paid over $300 000 until the age of 75 on the tax dollar of French-speaking Canadians should be able to understand those Canadians instead of wasting more of their tax dollars on further interpretation and translation services.
English-speaking Canada is often guilty of painting Quebec as a temper tantrum-throwing child, who must be appeased to keep the family peace. Now, I'm not one to deny that my province can be quite vocal and even unreasonable at times, but asking for important federal positions to be filled with bilingual candidates is not unreasonable.
It is imperative to note here that the Quebecers and French Canadians who find this kind of treatment from the federal government appalling should not be relegated to the usual Franco supremacist faction of the province, whose habitual pastimes include harassing English mom-and-pop shop owners, and trying to extend Bill 101 to CEGEPs and universities.
In reality, this is not the usual gratuitous paranoia that Quebec often harbours towards the federal government. Right now in Quebec our panties, or rather, our culottes, are in a bunch for good reason. Harper's appointment of all these people, who are incapable of communicating with over seven million Canadians, or roughly a little over 20 per cent of Canada's population, is a slap in the face to French Canadians.
It sends the already long-harboured message that Quebec is treated as an outsider; akin to that uncle nobody likes at Thanksgiving. (You know, your family invites him because he married your dad's sister, but nobody really wants to talk him, so everyone tries avoiding him instead.)
Undoubtedly, it is a sad reality that the relationship between French and English Canada has been a fragile one since 1763. I guess I just figured that in 2011, the federal government wouldn't be trying to make it worse.
Follow Supriya Dwivedi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/supriyadwivedi
Jon Ossoff: Do as Quebecers Do: Read a Book
Nataly Kelly: Who Are the People in Your Neighborhood? And What Languages Do They Speak?
Admit the best, not most fluent
Bienvenue a Ottawa: AG candidate faces committee amid criticism over lack of ...
Cannes curtain raiser for reality show that is the G20 summit
French first, English second: NB town Dieppe issues $100 fines for breaking ...
there are plenty of "qualified" people to go around, and being bilingual only adds to it, not detracts from it.
it's not like this guy invented compound interest or anything, you mean to tell me there is not a single other person with the same qualifications, with the added bonus that they are bilingual?
I can't get served in English at my local Post Office - they don't even fly the Canadian flag there. I've had to, in the past, specifically request to be addressed in English at HRDC offices, as well as the Federal Passport office.
When the rest of Canada finally starts getting indignant about the way English-speaking Quebeckers are treated, I'll start pretending to care about a unilingual-English Federal appointment.
This is just another tempest in a pot of pea soup, which will be used to gain what little leverage it can give them. The re-emerging Anglo Rights movement in Quebec will get more mileage from whatever the francosupremacists come up with next, trust me.
but the rest of the article makes sense. how is he from new brunswick and unilingual anyway?
this should be an issue that the cons didn't even follow the job description requirements in hiring the AG.
How about Quebecers who sue Air Canada because the stewardess gives them 7-Up instead of Sprite?
I'll the the first to agree that the AG should be bilingual - a point I've made in another comment. But there are mandatory bilingual French positions in the government of Saskatchewan - and you'd get more mileage out of German, Ukranian or Polish. There are mandatory bilingual French positions in BC, and there you'd get more mileage out of Chinese, Japanese, or even Spanish. Hindi would be more useful pretty much anywhere west of Ottawa.
Yet, while French Canada will demand far-flung outposts of bilingual service just in case they are ever in BC and flatly refuse to speak English, there are plenty of places in the Quebec government where an Anglophone can't get service - bilingual English is *not required*. There are a fair number of instances when I've been trying to buy something in Montreal and I've been refused service because I couldn't pronounce the French word *correctly* - not for lack of trying (speaking of figurative slaps in the face). While my French may be thickly accented, my French teachers could understand it well enough.
That's not fair. If Francophones want to be treated equitably, are they not at least honor-bound to return the gesture? Thus the attitude of the West - they view themselves as responding in kind..
It's a two way relationship. And while you should be able to get service in English in Montreal... trying to do the same in Quebec city or Alma.
A relationship works when both party are willing to work with the other.
also, it's not like it takes 2 weeks to learn French...so their assertion that they will learn it is moot.
The Supreme Court should have a mandatory minimum number of chairs filled by French/English bilinguals, but not all. This will prevent the marginalization of legal representatives from places such as British Columbia, where French is a very limited part of the cultural milieu and a Mandarin/English judge would be more representative of the region.
It may be a more complex system, and it may require that we spend additional money on translation services, but I'm willing to accept that if it means no part of our country is marginalized.