Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Supriya Dwivedi

GET UPDATES FROM Supriya Dwivedi
 

In Quebec You Might Soon be Forced to Trade Your Hijab for a Crucifix

Posted: 08/15/2012 2:38 pm

Pauline Marois and the Parti Québécois (PQ), the current front-runner in a three-way race to form Quebec's next government, have unveiled some disconcerting aspects of their would-be mandate: all overt religious symbols would be banned from public institutions... except for Catholic religious symbols.

In what the PQ is calling a Charter of Secularism, Muslim headscarves known as the hijab would be banned, whereas crucifixes worn as necklaces and Christmas trees would be allowed. Moreover, the crucifix that hangs on the wall of the National Assembly would be permitted to stay, because according to Marois, the crucifix is an important aspect of Québécois heritage.

I suppose Marois did not do too well in her grade 10 history class, otherwise she would be well aware of the fact that the crucifix only became a part of the National Assembly in 1936 under Maurice Duplessis. Hardly making the cross an entrenched part of Québécois heritage.

Of course, in true PQ fashion, this ban on religious symbols would also find its way to other symbols they arbitrarily deem inappropriate, such as some references to the British monarchy. While not overtly religious, references to the British Crown still happen to stick in the PQ's craw, and that's apparently enough to erratically start disallowing certain symbols while keeping others.

This should come as no surprise, considering the province's pride and joy is a repressive and Draconian language law, which the PQ is consistently trying to strengthen in one way or another. Additionally, the PQ is known for sayings such as: "Religious freedom exists but there are other values. For instance, multiculturalism is not a Quebec value. It may be a Canadian one but it is not a Quebec one." Never mind the fact that the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms officially recognizes Canada's multicultural heritage under section 27; ardent supporters of Quebec sovereignty choose to ignore this detail.

Anglophones and Allophones are often criticized for unfairly categorizing separatists in Quebec in general, and the Parti Québécois base in particular, as overtly bigoted and prejudiced towards other ethnic, religious or linguistic groups. In fact, at the start of this election campaign, a member of the Coalition Avenir du Québec (CAQ), Kamal Lutfi, was dropped as a candidate for insinuating exactly that over Twitter. Lutfi accused the separatist movement in the province of trying to eradicate multiculturalism, as he cited the broad-spectrum contempt that is felt for other cultures and religions as evidence.

The CAQ's leader, François Legault, was in no mood for calling out spades as spades, as his camp was quick to publicly denounce Lutfi's comments as unwelcome within the CAQ. Surely, if past comments by prominent PQ members are not enough to substantiate this claim of intolerance amongst the PQ base, then the current climate of the PQ campaign should be sufficient to now validate Lutfi's allegations.

As an atheist, I welcome separating religion and government; a secular government is a hallmark of a civilized society. But that is not what the PQ is doing here. Rather, they are once again marginalizing a segment of the Quebec population because they are not seen as being an important fabric of Quebec's so-called distinct society. They are in essence employing a selective secularism, in that all religious symbols that are not Catholic are not welcome, which is analogous to the policies of many authoritarian Islamic nations.

The xenophobic and francosupremacist rhetoric that has plagued the PQ base for years is now ever more unambiguous, which is frightening in and of itself. What I find truly alarming, however, is that the PQ is poised to form the next government, which can only mean that in addition to lengthy and costly constitutional battles with Ottawa, certain Quebecers can now be expected to have their basic civil liberties trampled on in order to appease an increasingly intolerant voting population. Vive le Québec libre indeed.

 

Follow Supriya Dwivedi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/supriyadwivedi

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
Pauline Marois and the Parti Québécois (PQ), the current front-runner in a three-way race to form Quebec's next government, have unveiled some disconcerting aspects of their would-be mandate: all ov...
Pauline Marois and the Parti Québécois (PQ), the current front-runner in a three-way race to form Quebec's next government, have unveiled some disconcerting aspects of their would-be mandate: all ov...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 151
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Postmodern Anger
12:09 PM on 08/19/2012
Not going to bother reading an article with an headline so wrong.

So I'll just correct things. PQ are not going to force anyone to wear anything. They want to prevent people from wearing things, that much is true.

They are not religious. Her move is one against religion. Not one promoting christianity. Simply not doing so while destroying our historical legacies in the process.
Said legacy is debatable, but that's certainly not something to be debated by people who doesn't understand a single thing about Quebec politics.

Seriously, I'd be ashamed to have written an headline like that. This is outright a lie.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
07:43 PM on 08/20/2012
That post is plain ol lies and racism against the majority population and the next governement.

But its always ok to hate the real Canadiens in anglo-canada.
photo
TonyOnly
Truth matters.
11:09 AM on 08/17/2012
The PQ manipulated the students to force a premature election. Omce Marois has a majority, all she'll have to do is fabricate a language / identity crisis by attacking Anglos and Allos. Then tempers will be inflamed enough for the PQ to hold a separation referendum within 2yrs of winning the election.

Inflaming passions is how the PQ is getting les Québecois to ignore the Charest Liberals record of economic stability. The unemployment rate is now down to 7.6%. The PQ have never gotten it below 10%. Historically under the PQ, the Quebec population becomes more dependant on the government and less economically independant. But nobody's thinking about that because the PQ attacks on Charest are working.

Manipulating the Quebec population in order to hold a referendum while Harper is still Canadian PM, has been the PQ strategy right from the start of the student protests. They're masters at it, and it's working for them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
07:47 PM on 08/20/2012
Delirium.
photo
TonyOnly
Truth matters.
09:30 PM on 08/20/2012
Can't see yourself as others see you?
Or just never been on the receiving end of the xenophobia? 
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:10 AM on 08/17/2012
Even if that is the party platform, it will never pass constitutional muster. I just don't get it. I live in Montreal, I see women wearing their hijab every day. What is there to be offended by it? Nothing. It all comes down to small minded, ignorant, xenophobia. At least now I can scratch the PQ off my list of who to vote for.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
07:50 PM on 08/20/2012
The title is completely misleading but If only you read the text, you would have seen that : ''religious symbols would be banned from public institutions''.

So, would you apology for your bad words or is it that you just needed an excuse to express your hatred for my people ?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LuckyTron
07:19 AM on 08/17/2012
I am a non-Christian immigrant from India. When we came to Canada we knew it was a country founded by Christians, as such mostly a Christian country. I was shocked to find out that, it is not politically correct to say "Merry Christmas". Seriously, WHY??? I was told people from other faiths would mind it ... my response WHO GIVES A FRACK!!!! If they don't like it, then bloody invite them to leave! I still wish everyone "Merry Christmas", even after being told by HR to do otherwise.

We have a few women in our company that walk around in a NIQAB -- Yes a full blown Black Niqab (head to toe veil -- which is lovingly called a Letterbox in UK). So yes, I can see how protecting a country/province's cultural heritage/identity is crucial. Although, I belong to a visible minority and a religious minority, I firmly believe that European countries really need to check themselves and draw a line as to what truly is RELIGIOUS FREEDOM? Why is it ok to wish Muslims, Happy Eid, Hindus Happy Diwali, Sikhs Happy Visakhi, Jews Happy Hanuka, ok yet wishing Merry Christmas to Christians a big taboo????

On a side note -- Hijaf is not an ISLAMIC head gear -- Mary, mother of Jesus is depicted wearing the same head gear and so do the Nuns even to this day. So banning a veil, I do understand, but banning a headgear like turbans or hijaf or yamaka is absolutely absurd!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AlwaysCanadian
Lifelong Pacifist
11:04 AM on 08/17/2012
My workplace has no such restrictions. We can wish any of our friends whatever we want, Merry Christmas, Happy Diwali etc. Once a year we hold a "multi-cultural" event, in which every staff member is encouraged to participate and show his or her ancestral roots. We have stall representing over a dozen countries, from Ireland to Nigeria, from Columbia to China.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LuckyTron
10:38 PM on 08/18/2012
Thats pretty amazing!!! See I love diversity, cultural, intellectual and physical, however, we all need to draw a line when it becomes overbearingly politically correct.
08:26 PM on 08/16/2012
Non-catholics in Quebec should start political movement to separate from Quebec. It will be fairly surprising and surprisingly fair.
photo
mehnar
economist,, spiritualist
02:30 PM on 08/16/2012
the way to advanced technology and communication, transportation, social humanity will go back, what does this bigotry.
01:13 PM on 08/16/2012
I would guess that more Francophones are as appalled by the PQ's stance then we think!! I have met and known in my lifetime many Francophones who have lived in Quebec who don't agree with the Language laws, who don't hate anglophones and don't see the rest of Canada as the Enemy. The unfortunate part is the PQ get the headlines and make sure that Quebec law never allows the loosening of Bill 101. And for the most part English Canada doesn't hate Francophones, heck we are a billingual Country. What we hate is the hypocracy the PQ Governments have endorsed, Canadians outside Quebec must learn French. However inside Quebec English is the forbidden language. If you want the respect of the rest of Canada, how about showing the Anglophones families living in Quebec a little respect. Francophones and Anglophones in Quebec are what has made that province the beauty that it is.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
07:58 PM on 08/20/2012
English is not forbidden in Québec. Anglos have access to kindergarten, pre-schools, schools, colleges, universities, clinics, hospitals, and all government services in their languages.
08:07 PM on 08/21/2012
I happen to know several Anglophones who live in Quebec who have had issues especially in Emergency Rooms at Hospitals getting service in English...having to wait excessively long periods of time before the Hospital staff have found an English speaking Doctor or nurse. And they love living in Quebec, but when you are seeking treatment in an ER having to wait over an hour for the staff to find someone who speaks English is deplorable!! And the PQ is campaigning on limiting further how much English is allowed in the province including in schools at any level. My point was the PQ seems to want to erase Anglophones from the Province. And when you have a very prominent Francophone, Celine Dion, tell the story of her life and that she knew no English until her manager informed her she would have to learn English to conquer the world, it shows that there is an inequity in the Province of Quebec!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TRMS
Rally round the family, pocket full of shells
12:46 PM on 08/16/2012
If they ban Muslim symbols, it's only fair to ban Christian symbols as well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
07:58 PM on 08/20/2012
Muslim symbol are not part of the historic heritage.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TRMS
Rally round the family, pocket full of shells
02:23 PM on 08/21/2012
They are very similar religions, with a shared origin and history, that worship the same deity and the same prophet, Jesus. If you ban one symbol, you have to ban the other. Otherwise it becomes racist and divisive. The "historic heritage" is just a silly term made up by Christians to justify their hypocrisy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TRMS
Rally round the family, pocket full of shells
11:33 AM on 08/23/2012
French Catholicism is not part of Anglo historic heritage, therefore the crucifix at the Assemblé Nationale du Québec would have to be removed and destroyed. I doubt it would be personal. It's just not part of the Anglo historic heritage.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Colin Speth
A Claymore for your thoughts
10:53 AM on 08/16/2012
The only thing more disturbing than Marois Le Pen impersonation is the other parties cowardice in failing to call her out on it. Remaining silent implies some kind of tacit support for this crazy ladies ideas and certainly does nothing to counteract the impression that Quebec is full of anti-English, xenophobic bigots. Disgusting.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
08:02 PM on 08/20/2012
That could be caused by a misconception which makes you believe things that are untrue. Or just plain bigotry against the real Canadiens on your part, maybe.
photo
Do The Math
In dog years I'm dead...
10:45 AM on 08/16/2012
This is a low point, even for Quebec politics. And that says a lot.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
08:03 PM on 08/20/2012
Québec never went so low as barring blacks and jews from public beaches.
10:12 AM on 08/16/2012
"...because according to Marois, the crucifix is an important aspect of Québécois heritage."

Anglos are also an important part of Quebec's heritage but Marois would like to get wrid of them too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
08:04 PM on 08/20/2012
She never said or done anything like that.
07:32 AM on 08/21/2012
Your would-be queen, when in power, has made constant cuts to all english services offered in Quebec. It started with limiting access to english schools and then once enrollment declined, they "HAD" to close them due to low enrollment. This is all thanks to the PQ's fearmongering of the evil anglo.
09:00 AM on 08/16/2012
A little historical context: this society has been built in great part by Catholic institutions. The people of Québec are mostly of Catholic faith, even though a growing number declare themselves atheist or convert to other religions. That is why the schools, the hospitals, the city halls and the National Assembly adorn the crucifix. This reality should not shock anyone. These religious symbols have no meaning to most people, they became part of the buildings themselves. The government and the Catholic church have long been separated in our province and country. Therefore, the policy proposal of the PQ makes sense, but I would add: no new public building should bear crucifix or any other religious symbol. On a side note, I am very sad to see so many expressions of hatred and misinformed opinion in this forum.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
08:06 PM on 08/20/2012
''I am very sad to see so many expressions of hatred and misinformed opinion in this forum. ''

Thanks.
Hafingnetonne
A few words
08:45 AM on 08/16/2012
You would be surprised hey how much what Quebecers think is shared widely in Ontario. The intolerance of the minorities walking streets wrapped in jihabd and burkas is not liked a bit. If immigrants would learn to love their country and conform to its dominant majoritary cultural fixtures these outbursts of frustration expressed by one political provincial party would not occur. It is high time that the immigrants agree that they are no more in their country and that they live in a country they love in practiviizng respect for their fellow citizens. Multiculturalism was invented by Trudeau to confront anglo nationalism and divided it in many components. It creates confusion in the mind of all. It is high time that contraption born from eutopia be dismantled.
11:17 AM on 08/16/2012
Based on your logic, everyone ought to be speaking English in Quebec, a "dominant majority cultural fixture" in Canada. Quebecois are, after all, no more in France.
Hafingnetonne
A few words
02:24 PM on 08/16/2012
Évidemment I meant that Québec majority speaks French, hence seak French if you live in Quebec; ROC majority speaks Englsih hence speak English and we can tolerate bilingual districts like Ottawa and New Brunswick and whomever wants to seakthe secnd offial language. All other languages could be spoken privately at touristy spots, folklore associations and clubs. That way you insure linguistic assimilation in 25 to 50 years. This is going on all over ROC.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canada Libre
Le Canada c’est le Québec. Vive le Canada libre
08:12 PM on 08/20/2012
Canada was a French state for over a century before anglish could sail up the St-Laurent and walk passed the Appalachians. The english invaders granted Canadiens the right to keep their language, religion, territory and code of law in order to get their support against American rebels. And it worked for the anglos. Canadians sided with them and defeated the american twice (1777 and 1812).

There are still anglos in Canada because we - the real Canadiens - saved their butts from rebel boots. Remember that before you say there should be no francos in Canada.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AlwaysCanadian
Lifelong Pacifist
11:28 AM on 08/16/2012
Why this obsession for what a woman puts on her own body of her own free choice? Speaking for myself, I have no objection to any woman with a headscarf on her head walking freely on the street, as long as no one tries to forces my wife and kids to wear one.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Imma Okay
05:12 PM on 08/16/2012
I don't think they WANT to wear that stuff. They just think they have to.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
08:43 AM on 08/16/2012
THIS is why the NDP needs to reform the provincial party. There are plenty of English, Immigrants, and moderate French (who want nothing to do with separation) that have no one representing them. We get stuck with Charest and the corruption machine, or the Fascism of the PQ. Wonderful. C'mon NDP, don't you know a good thing when you see it? There are plenty of voters looking for a party like the NDP.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:20 AM on 08/16/2012
This is such a boring campaign. Nothing to talk about. If only there was an important issue to talk about like: Gang wars, politicians taking payoffs, assets being sold to the lowest bidder then flipped for a handsome profit, ever increasing debt, the subsidizing of the sale of a cancerous product, construction industry corruption. Nope, this poster who introduced us to the awesome comedy styling of Daniel Tosh thinks wooden fixtures nailed on the wall of the National Assembly is a much more important subject.
photo
OuterBanx North12
Now with 33% MORE caffeine!
08:52 AM on 08/16/2012
"...wooden fixtures nailed on the wall of the National Assembly is a much more important subject."

Read the enitre article, dude.
09:10 AM on 08/16/2012
So you don't think trampling over people's rights is serious!

It's amazing how people can read an article on potential human rights abuse and cascade all of it's content down too 'wooden fixtures nailed on the wall of the National Assembly'.
09:52 AM on 08/16/2012
Yeah, it's not as if we have a crook as a premier, a federalist whose party is the political wing of the mafia...But not, let's just bash Quebec and francophones...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:23 PM on 08/16/2012
My bad, your right. The corrupt liberal party set a bad precedent when they decided to make protesting illegal and thus trampled on people's rights!