Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Tamara Levitt

GET UPDATES FROM Tamara Levitt
 

Yoda Had One Thing Wrong: It's OK to Try

Posted: 10/10/2012 1:06 pm

So I know Yoda is a Jedi Master and all that, but he's got something wrong. One of his most favourite claims -- "Do, or do not. There is no 'try,'" -- has a big hole in it.

I get his point: Words have power and the word try carries a defeatist attitude. But he's suggesting that if you make enough of an effort to achieve a goal, you should be able to reach that goal. And that if you fail, your effort or conviction was lacking.

That certainly hasn't been my reality. Sometimes I try my best, yet I still experience failure. There are often external factors that are part of the 'success' equation. To conclude we are to be blamed for our failures is to be denying ourselves of the acceptance and self-compassion we all deserve. It's difficult enough for adults to grapple with these issues. Imagine how difficult it is for children.

I want my nieces and nephews to know that if they try to reach a goal, but can't achieve it, that's OK. Regardless of whether they win or lose, they are still amazing; their self-worth is not determined by achievement. By learning to simply enjoy the game as they're playing it, they've already won.

We need to offer children not only the room to fail, but also the support and education to accept and grow from it. I believe that so much, I decided to write a book about it. Happiness Doesn't Come from Headstands is a modern day story about the search for happiness, and one girl's discovery that even in the face of failure, peace can be found.


The messages we learn as children are ones that become core beliefs as adults. Growing up, I learned that "try" was a bad word -- there was either success or failure. I developed a fear of failure that was so strong, at times, I simply wouldn't try. Because of this, "regret" is a word I'm all too familiar with.

Today, I do my best to approach "trying" with enthusiasm even when faced with fear. And if I fail, I strive to congratulate myself on my efforts -- a difficult thing to do in a world that rewards us for our victories alone.

I'd like children to grow up in a kinder world, one in which we celebrate their efforts, not just the outcome. I believe children (and adults) should be praised and congratulated when we try irrespective of the outcome and even when we do succeed.

As parents and educators, we have the power to nurture children's growth. We can start by teaching kids that it's okay to fail -- that just because they have a failure, it doesn't mean that they are a failure. By learning how to accept and learn from failure, they'll be better equipped to achieve the happiness and success we so want for them in the first place.

My sense has always been that if I had known some of what I know now, at a younger age, life could have been easier. Perhaps I would have been a little less afraid to fail, and a little more resilient when I did. Our thought patterns strengthen as we age, so let's support children to create a healthy framework from the start. This was my goal in creating Happiness Doesn't Come from Headstands.

Listen we all love Yoda. He's cute, green, and 900 years old -- what's not to like? But wise as he may be, Yoda was wrong on this one. There is a try. And whether it results in a victory or defeat, each act of trying should be celebrated.

That children will be loved regardless of what they can or cannot do is a message I want my nieces and nephews to know, one that I want your kids and your friends' kids to know. My hope is to inspire you as you inspire the children in your life.

To support (or view) the Happiness Doesn't Come from Headstands campaign please click here! "

 
FOLLOW CANADA IMPACT
So I know Yoda is a Jedi Master and all that, but he's got something wrong. One of his most favourite claims -- "Do, or do not. There is no 'try,'" -- has a big hole in it. I get his point: Words ha...
So I know Yoda is a Jedi Master and all that, but he's got something wrong. One of his most favourite claims -- "Do, or do not. There is no 'try,'" -- has a big hole in it. I get his point: Words ha...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
TT Esty1
Where did the 7 Dwarfs work?
07:49 PM on 10/10/2012
I am not one who messes with the wisdom of Yoda and far be it for me to act as a Yoda interpreter. Thus, with deference to the sage, allow me to address this kind teacher's representation with a minor grammar lesson. First, 'try' is a verb. Secondly, 'do' is a verb. Thirdly, 'succeed' is a verb. Fourthly, 'fail' is a verb. Let us construct sentences with these verbs. 'Try to write a book'; Write a book'' Succeed at writing a book; Fail at writing a book'. Which of these sentences is the most succinct, direct and nonjudgemental?

Can one 'try' to write a book without actually writing a book? Can one succeed or fail at writing a book withour actually writing a book? If one answers yes to these two questions then one does not really understand the difference between 'do' and 'thinking of do'.

Moreover, what does 'try' mean? Does buying a pencil to write a book count for 'trying'? Is writing half a book count for 'trying'? There seems to be a tenuousness about 'try'; an uncertainty; a hedge my bet sort of thing. I take Yoda to say that if your going to use verbs, use strong ones. Oh, and by the way, success or failure are subordinates to 'do'. If you 'do', the two are not applicable.
06:52 PM on 10/10/2012
I agree with markhahn, the Yoda saying isn't about attempting and failing. It is about getting your butt up and doing whatever you are talking about. It's like when people say, I'll try to go to the gym, or I'll try to eat better; you don't try, you either do it or you don't. I don't think the author of the article grasped that meaning. Every day people try in an affirmative way; it's when try is used passively that's the problem. Trying new things is great and I hope everyone understands that trying can be doing.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
05:58 PM on 10/10/2012
Yoda was right because you have to go into something with the idea of succeeding, not merely trying. A positive attitude will carry you far, but hedging your bets puts into your head that it is ok to fail. While I do believe that it is ok to fail, I NEVER go into a situation with any view other than that I will succeed.
markhahn
rational progressive
12:20 PM on 10/10/2012
Has the author actually watched the movie? Yoda is being zen - pointing out that a tentative engagement is to live in fear of failure. Yoda is _not_ saying you should be able to do something, but to "go big or go home".

I can't believe I just put those words into the mouth of a 900 year old Jedi Master...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
05:58 PM on 10/10/2012
And with a French accent, very troubling.