Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tianna Dowie-Chin

GET UPDATES FROM Tianna Dowie-Chin
 

How to Help Black Youth? Expect More of Them

Posted: 07/25/2012 11:49 am

Due to the recent surge in gun violence in Toronto there have been numerous discussions about how best to address this problem. Some support harsher punishments or stricter laws and others support more funding for community organizations. I support social programs, especially those that provide jobs and enhance the employability of youths.

However, I don't think any of that matters if we don't seriously address the languishing and low expectations we have for young black men and women growing up in our society. After all, how important is the number of community organizations we have or the amount of money we throw at these problems if our politicians, educators and general society maintain low expectations for these youths? It's of little to no importance. I use my own story to say why.

I grew up in a single parent home with a mother struggling to make ends meet. I even remember at one point having to sleep in my aunt's living room floor with my mother and brother when my family suddenly found itself homeless.

As a child I came to understand that my mother could not afford to get me everything I wanted. I was a little black girl whose family did not have much and I learned to accept that as my reality. However, it was not until I was in high school that I began to see how that reality influenced the expectations that other people held for me.

One day at the end of my tenth grade school year, I became eager to share a part of my life with one of my favourite teachers. I pulled a family picture out of my bag to show her. To my surprise, as my teacher looked at my proud family photo, tears began to well in her eyes. At first I did not understand her tears, and then she said something that I would never forget. "W-w-where's your Dad?" Seeing in my eyes the answer to her question, she looked back down at the photo and trailed off, asking, "So...how have you been so successful in school?"

What my teacher saw in that family photo was my mother, a young black single mother with three children -- three fatherless children. Now, this was a most kind, dedicated and hard-working teacher. Yet, she had difficulty squaring what she saw in the picture and the student that was standing before her.

I was an a student and received my school's highest mark in Grade 10 History that year. Because of that, my teacher did not expect me to come from a single parent home. How could I?

My experience is indicative of the expectations that most people have for black youths growing up in single-parent and/or economically disadvantaged homes. In fact, I firmly believe that low and negative expectations are at the heart of what leads many black youth down paths that are lined with little more than underachievement, impoverishment and predatory violence.

Having recently completed a Bachelor of Education at the Ontario Institute of Studies in Education (OISE) at the University of Toronto, I came to learn that as a teacher your students will only live up to the expectations that you have of them. My experience at OISE allowed me to be taught by passionate educators who convinced me that even though some students may come from single parent homes or low income households, teachers should still demand and expect the very best from them.

I saw the practical value of this during my placement in an inner-city school in Toronto where my associate teacher (AT) created an environment of high expectations and understanding. The students I worked with would barely pass in other classes. They complained of teachers disregarding them and failing to include them in their discussions, often leading them to choose to react by acting out in class.

But in our classroom it was a different story. Many of these same students excelled because my AT fostered the development of learning space with high expectations. In result, our students applied themselves and demonstrated an increased and active interest in their academic success. No, they didn't become angels once in our class, but once with us they definitely took themselves more seriously as students.

I recall all of this to say the following: whether it is the politician funding anti-gang strategies, the social- worker in a youth program, or a teacher within our schools, our expectations of young black men and women are in desperate need of fundamental change for the better.

It was American inventor Charles F. Kettinger who aptly stated, "High achievement always takes place in the framework of high expectation." In other words, to see better we need to expect better.

This is a lesson we all need to learn to restore and sustain our city, "Toronto the Good."

 
FOLLOW CANADA IMPACT
Due to the recent surge in gun violence in Toronto there have been numerous discussions about how best to address this problem. Some support harsher punishments or stricter laws and others support mor...
Due to the recent surge in gun violence in Toronto there have been numerous discussions about how best to address this problem. Some support harsher punishments or stricter laws and others support mor...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 30
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:03 PM on 07/26/2012
BRAVO! This HEADLINE and story could also work 100% if it was this : How to Help Indians? Expect More of Them.
photo
Nihilicious
Humanist>Realist>Atheist>Nihlist
03:02 PM on 07/26/2012
Listen to this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hRVOOwFNp5U

for starters.
Bianca S
You can't go trick-or-treating. Ever. For a week
05:10 PM on 07/26/2012
Wow, that's insane, in the best way possible.
10:40 AM on 07/26/2012
Being "truly dedicated" in the teaching profession is quickly snuffed out by the union. I've seen new teachers fired for being "truly dedicated", for refusing to pass a students who did not pass the class. Unions make the discussion about how much money teachers can sap out of taxpayers instead of about what they require to do a great job. Having seniority and conforming to what the union wants is how teachers succeed, not dedication.
07:57 PM on 07/25/2012
There are so many different levels to this issue, but Ike Awgu hit the nail on the head. Most of these solutions are designed to fix the symptoms but not the root of the problem. Any child growing up in a single-parent, low-income family is coming out of the gate at a disadvantage. Create a community like this and the chances of success for that kid just dropped exponentially. If this is a community issue, then community leaders need to tackle the root causes of the issues head on.

From the sounds of it, Tianna is going to make a great teacher and great role model. And while I agree kids maybe weren't getting their voices heard in all the classes, I'd venture to guess they weren't role model students either. The energy you put out is the energy you get in return. Tianna put out an energy of success and competence as a student and earned the respect of her teachers.

Someone (and it should be parents) needs to tell kids at some point: quit your whining, life is tough, stop blaming others for your problems, get your act together, and start making empowering choices in your life. Education is the route to opportunities which leads to leadership positions which leads to the power to affect change and inspire others to strive for only the best. Look up Dr. Ben Carson. Excellent example of success.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
MJinCanada
Safe from zombies until my 2nd cup of coffee
02:50 AM on 07/26/2012
Kids are kids. The ADULTS in their lives have to make the first move to be role models and inspirations and to expect results.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Ike Awgu
09:23 AM on 07/26/2012
Well said MJinCanada. What's been remarkable to me in all of these discussions about youth crime that have arisen since the shooting in Scarborough is how few of them criticize the single parent homes where a significant majority (virtually 100%) of these kids come from. It is always someone else's fault; the system, the teachers, racism, lack of social programs, the weather, anyone but the people who have a responsibility to raise their own children.
11:51 PM on 07/26/2012
Yup, I don't disagree. The first role models are parents. I think what seems to be missing right now are parents who are role models. Kids also need to be taught that the only way to change what they don't like is to become the change they want to see. Dr. Ben Carson is a great example. His mother was tough as nails. He made it out of the projects and went on to become a top surgeon at John Hopkins. We need more mothers like her kickin' some sense into their kids.
05:20 PM on 07/25/2012
The phrasing of the title illustrates the problem.
04:39 PM on 07/25/2012
Thank you. You're totally right and it doesn't just apply to minorities. Expect more and you'll get more.
Anyone can be handed a not so great hand of cards...it's up to the individual to succeed. They won't do that if no-one expects them to do so.
03:26 PM on 07/25/2012
Tough, and very complicated subject. Nice job on the article and kudos for tackling it.
I know there are many initiatives in the U.S. regarding the single parent/black youth issues. I wonder, do you know of any that are having success?
Perhaps a model could be adopted for Toronto rather than the same old arguements treating symtoms instead of the root social problems, which I suspect are myriad once you start digging.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Ike Awgu
01:49 PM on 07/25/2012
This is where she lost me:
"In fact, I firmly believe that low and negative expectations are at the heart of what leads many black youth down paths that are lined with little more than underachievement[...]."

There are 'low expectations' because expectations come from parents before they do teachers. The heart of the problem is that these young people are being failed by their single-parent homes long before the state has a chance to impose on them 'low expectations'. In fact, it is the very reason why the low expectations exist. Any solution that fails to address the real problem (the number of unwed single-parents) in these communities is just pleasant sounding noise that will slow but not stop the descent of countless young people.
Bianca S
You can't go trick-or-treating. Ever. For a week
02:24 PM on 07/25/2012
I agree with Tianna that teachers need to have high expectations but I also agree with you that the real heart of it begins in the household. Nowhere in that article did Tianna address the importance of being raised by educated, financially secure, attentive parent(s), but rather put the responsibility on the teacher, politician and social worker. We all know that the most crucial years in a child's life are from 1-5 as this is where cognitive development forms. If parents aren't here for these crucial years then it immediately puts them at a severe disadvantage that only snowballs as they age.

If we could focus on the social, cultural and financial aspects which contribute to black youth being raised in unstable households, then we can ensure that they are being raised with the same chance of success as their peers without having to rely on outsiders to raise them into success.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Ike Awgu
02:32 PM on 07/25/2012
Well said Bianca.
03:25 PM on 07/25/2012
I think you make a really important point, but I also think that the strategy that the author has set out has a major advantage over yours: it's concrete. Changing the way the province trains its teachers (both current and future) is something tangible. Strategies to address the issue of low-income, single-parent homes is much more complex. Such strategies also won't help the kids who are already in high school and have grown up in that environment. Conversely, a couple of years in a classroom with truly dedicated teachers can reinvigorate students into realizing their potential.
Bianca S
You can't go trick-or-treating. Ever. For a week
05:51 PM on 07/25/2012
The main problem with your proposal is that it suggests that the teachers we have today are unqualified and that by merely hiring and re-training teachers to make them "truly dedicated" would eradicate this. This is hugely insulting to our already existing teachers faced with this issue. There is a reason why teachers only last an average of 5 years before quitting and no, it's not because they aren't "dedicated" enough; it's largely due to lack of support from the home which force teachers to take on the unfair burden of not only educating students but raising them as well.
Did you know the average teacher in Canada spends spends almost $500 a school year of her/his own money on supplies and food to give to children who don't have the support from their homes? Why is this happening and why did this become normal? And why is it that teachers are always the fall guy/woman? I think you inadvertently answered it yourself: it's less "complex", meaning, it's easy. It's easy to use teachers as a scapegoat for problems that far exceed their duty. It's easy to question and criticize teachers' gumption, morals, qualifications and work ethic by saying if only they put in more effort and were better trained, they could single-handedly create change against a system that has all but taken away their power yet giving them all the responsibility.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
see-ellen2001
01:48 PM on 07/25/2012
Very well said. Kids are extremely good at living down to our expectations. You are going to be such a wonderful influence on your students.
01:39 PM on 07/25/2012
If this article was written by anyone else who was not black, it would receive condemnation. However, you are brave in speaking your mind and heart about this important issue of public safety. If one were to be objective of creating a formula to raise a gangster, it would be: raised by a single parent/mother, grow up in a project/Ontario housing, low socio-economic status, mother is working long hours or two jobs/ rarely at home, peers are other gangsters within the neighbourhood, mother is ignorant of what's happening in child's spare time, mother is weak in enforcing rules, no teaching of morality/ethics, lack of church attendance and an anger at the world for feeling entitled yet not receiving anything- no compelling need to excel in academics as one can not afford post-secondary education, thus no prospect in gaining a career. With that being said, the statistics on gun crime in Toronto is as follows: over 70% of shooters and victims are black, 14-24 yrs of age, over 90% are gang related/ drug dealer related, living in impoverished areas like Rexdale, Flemington pk, jane/finch, regent park, etc. The sense of imparting wisdom and love and ethical guidance are different... working and striving hard are not ideals that are enforced and graduating university is a pipe dream. The cycle of violence/hate from these communities will always exist as long as there is poverty. Give HOPE. Reduce FEAR. Give LOVE + EDUCATION + SPIRITUAL GUIDANCE.
01:23 PM on 07/25/2012
"Many of these same students excelled because my AT fostered the development of learning space with high expectations. In result, our students applied themselves and demonstrated an increased and active interest in their academic success. "

If we expect someone to fail, they most likely will. If we expect someone to succeed, they most likely will. Why should kids be any different?

I hope that this changes, for the sake of all those kids who will never reach their full potential.
04:43 PM on 07/25/2012
Totally true.