Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tim Hudak

GET UPDATES FROM Tim Hudak
 

Message to McGuinty: Stop the Spending

Posted: 09/06/2012 1:53 pm

Ontario is a place of boundless potential -- and we can harness that potential again. But right now we're in a deep hole, and if we're going to climb out we need some straight talk about how we got into it in the first place.

The cause is nine years of reckless overspending. The effect is that we've run out of money, which puts everything we value at risk. Compounding the problem is a government that's adrift and out of gas. In the year since the last election, Dalton McGuinty has utterly failed to grasp the seriousness of our situation: not a nickel shaved off his $16 billion deficit, and no action to reduce the cost of our bloated public sector.

In fact, he made things worse -- with a budget that increased taxes and spending, more costly commitments like a home reno tax credit and a tuition grant, and doubling down on a failed green energy program that has pushed electricity costs through the roof. We just can't afford more of the same.

But this government has no plan to turn things around: nothing to rein in overspending, to boost our competiveness and attract investment, or to get our economic fundamentals right to create jobs. They spent years throwing money at their problems. But now, there's nothing left to throw.

In fact, all we have to show for the so-called "emergency session" of the Legislature is exactly one partial wage freeze for one group of government employees. There are 3,999 still to go. We just don't have time for an endless "bargaining-go-round" of the kind we've seen the past several weeks with teachers alone.

This may explain something disturbingly false about the Premier's recent statements: He wants you to forget the huge raises he gave the public sector unions over nine years, and believe what he is saying now. In the next breath, he wants public sector workers to forget what he is saying now, and remember the raises he gave them over nine years.

We need urgent action. So we've tabled a bold package of ideas called "Freeze, Fix, Review." We need an immediate, across-the board wage freeze for the entire public sector, and have a bill on the shelf that's ready to go. We first tabled this legislation last May, which the government promptly voted down. If they are truly serious, this time, about a broad-based wage freeze -- including an end to "performance" bonuses doled out recently to 98 per cent of public sector managers who simply showed up for work -- they'll run with it.

Other perks that have to go include unsustainable benefits the private sector got rid of years ago, like being able to store up sick days and turn them over for money on retirement. Sick days are for being sick, not for cashing out like so many poker chips.

Next, we'll push to halt planned spending increases in no fewer than 14 of 24 Ministries (representing over 80 per cent of total spending, incidentally), which will buy time to get down into fundamental, structural change to fix the way the government works and spends. And as a third step back toward fiscal sanity, we'll need a Fall Economic Statement that actually begins to reduce government spending on a permanent basis.

This is the kind of bold, conservative action I pledged to my party. And we're not stepping off the gas: The weeks to come will see a steady stream of provocative new "Paths to Prosperity" white papers on boosting our competitiveness to create jobs. We've already changed the debate with Affordable Energy and Flexible Labour Markets -- to bring down electricity costs for consumers and businesses alike and modernize our 1940s-era labour laws, respectively. And we're just getting started. Please check our progress for yourself.

Our immediate challenge, though, must be to send this his Premier a message: Stop the overspending and focus on job creation: It's time for straight talk -- and a real plan to get our economy moving. That's where we come in.

 
FOLLOW CANADA
Ontario is a place of boundless potential -- and we can harness that potential again. But right now we're in a deep hole, and if we're going to climb out we need some straight talk about how we got in...
Ontario is a place of boundless potential -- and we can harness that potential again. But right now we're in a deep hole, and if we're going to climb out we need some straight talk about how we got in...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 66
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:23 PM on 09/08/2012
Message to Hudak - quit now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wolf Braun
PURPOSE & PRINCIPLES
04:21 PM on 09/07/2012
Nothing will change until citizens begin discussing what they want the PURPOSE and PRINCIPLES of their Government to be.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Skepticat
Supporting skeptical felines everywhere
11:37 AM on 09/07/2012
Note to Mr Hudak. Last time we heard about your path to prosperity it sure sounded like removing over a century of labour rights so we could rival the prosperity of Honduras or Bangla Desh. Nope - your party has kept your mentor out of the public eye for good reason. Best be quiet lest folks remember why.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
valar84
09:51 AM on 09/07/2012
Is Tim Hudak betting that Ontarians only watch American TV and that they will thus be receptive to Republican-like messaging? Because he is just mimicking what Romney is saying to Obama.

"Boohoo, the deficit is too high, and it's JUST because of overspending, it surely has NOTHING to do with the huge crisis and tens of thousands of jobs lost in manufacturing because of the high dollar... We have to cut spending and it will get the economy back on track! How would reducing the deficit help the economy? Don't question my logic, you commie!"

BTW, Ontario, especially the provincial government, doesn't have a big public sector at all. Ontario has the smallest number of provincial civil servants in all of Canada per capita (by civil servant, I mean people who work in the provincial administration and not nurses, teachers and the like). It has almost the most people working in municipal administrations, but that's up to the cities to decide, not the province. If you had provincial and municipal administrations, Ontario's civil servants are still less than Alberta's per capita.

Overall, employment in the public sector in Ontario is the third smallest in Canada, just a bit higher than BC and almost equal to Alberta.

Facts never bother the right-wing, do they?
09:21 AM on 09/07/2012
If Ontario is in such a deep hole, why is Hudak so against asking Ontarians to help get out of the hole by digging a little bit into their pockets? To balance a budget you need both: control spending and raise revenue. Hudak only sees half the picture.
11:52 PM on 09/07/2012
Because Mr. Hudak thinks a deficit is only a bad thing when the Liberals are in power. When Conservatives are in power, it's a 'necessity'.
07:32 AM on 09/07/2012
As an Ontario Nurse, we ARE in the midst of a wage freeze, and will not be able to negotiate an increase until at least 2014. While not all public sector employees have had there wages frozen there are some that have. It may not be a hardship for everyone but for those living and working in the North the cost of living is much higher than the rest of the province...
07:42 AM on 09/07/2012
Good insight! Thanks!
11:12 AM on 09/07/2012
While I agree with your comment about wage freezes, the cost of living in the north is not higher than the rest of the province. Most northern communties advertize this fact prominently. The study I read had the avg costs about 20% lower than southern Ontario.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skbull44
Check out Olduvai the novel
07:22 AM on 09/07/2012
Mr. Hudak fails to mention a couple of interesting facts. First, he says nothing negative about the 50% pay increase the Liberals gave to all members of the provincial legislature just before 'freezing' legislative remuneration, including all the Conservatives. Second, he fails to raise the fact that after only eight years in the legislature, MPPs are provided a 'cash out' worth 150% of their salary.
Conservative, Liberal, or New Democrat, it makes no difference. Politicians will say what they think will get them the most votes. Once in office, they become beholden to themselves and their supportive interest groups--spending good money after bad to win votes; transferring taxes from the middle class to their wealthy friends and supporters; passing legislation to extend and solidify their power; expanding bureaucracy (despite assurances to the contrary); etc., etc.. Of course, all of this is nothing new; it is what politics has been about for centuries.
While Hudak's fundamental premise is correct--that we have a serious debt problem--I believe that it would be no better under his leadership. He may cut back or freeze compensation in the public sector but you can bet government would expand in other areas or savings would be funneled to supportive interest groups.
Not that I'm cynical (ha ha) but a pox on them all!
07:43 AM on 09/07/2012
They just took this away from the military- forced to pay out now, and not see severance pay for time in. Apparently retention of a politician is more important.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jesse Wright
06:58 AM on 09/07/2012
To understand a particular action, you must understand the reason which brought about the action. Teachers can bank their sick days for one simple reason - teachers get sick, a lot, so they have lots of sick days. Unions let them bank the days because it encourages them to NOT use those sick days during their employment. Taking away the ability to bank sick days will only encourage teachers to take more sick days per year causing the ministry to still pay out the equal amount of sick days. On top of that, it allows older teachers to retire earlier - the last thing Ontario schools need is MORE old teachers having a reason to stay longer.
08:26 AM on 09/07/2012
Everybody gets sick on occasion.. While I support unions and the wages and benefits they can provide to working people, banking sick days, is not reasonable for the tax payer and just a cash cow.. As far as getting sick, most contracts allow for both short term and long term sick benefits. Teachers already get 2 full months off in summer, 1week at spring break, 2weeks at Xmas as well as 1PA day a month and all statutory days off. Sometimes people do not recognize how good they have it. Work in the private sector for a while and see. In most work places you do not go to work you do NOT get paid, that it that's all. I respect the job teachers do and believe in decent wages and benefits but in these days of economic unstability...Banking sick days can and should go.
photo
Machine Head
I`d rather have a full bottle in front of me......
09:10 AM on 09/07/2012
Those 2 "full" months in the summer that you speak of are hardly "full" and hardly "off". Teachers are required to take courses in order to continue teaching and if you have a family, the best option is to take them during the summer months when they are offered. That takes care of 6 weeks "off", then you are required to set up your classroom and start to get the semester's learning materials together; that usually takes another week to 2 weeks to accomplish. That professional development day each month IS A WORKING DAY spent either marking papers, participating in workshops and in-services or staff meetings. It is NOT, I repeat NOT a day off. Couple those facts with the hours that the average teacher actually works (the day isn't over at 3:15) marking papers, homework and preparing the next day's lessons as well as parent interviews and mandatory extra-curricular activities and I say they deserve to be able to bank at least a portion of their unused sick days prior to retirement.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
valar84
09:59 AM on 09/07/2012
Banking sick days is just a different way to compensate workers. I know that in much of the private sector, benefits are small but pay is high. In the public sector, it's the opposite, benefits are high, but pay is lower than it would be otherwise. That's because those benefits are things the employees got in exchange for lower wages. Because they have those benefits like banking sick days, public employees like teachers agree to work for less.

This benefits teachers, but also the government, who has to pay employees less than they would otherwise. So, far from a cash cow, this is a way of saving a bit of money for the provincial government. If you strip away those benefits, expect the teachers and their union to fight hard as nail for higher wages to compensate for the loss of their benefits, which they would be in the right to do... and which will likely cost more to the taxpayers in the end.
09:21 AM on 09/07/2012
Are you a Teacher?? Seriously??
This is right out of the OSSTF PR Campaign.
It'll cost the Boards more to use Supply Teachers if every Teacher used their full allotment of sick days every year... It's actually more cost-effective to allow Teachers to bank their sick days now, and cash them out at the end...
Except Teachers shouldn't need financial incentives to actually show up for work. Beyond their Salary that is. This ridiculous Financial Carrot needs to be done away with. If a Teacher gets sick, by all means call in sick, but Banking days is asinine. So you're saying that would "encourage" Teachers to call in sick more?? How so?? Just not to lose their payout?? In that case I'd respond by making a Doctor's Note a requirement to be off sick with pay. Get back to the real world.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Parketkat
12:01 PM on 09/07/2012
I do find it sad that honor and integrity are gone. I get 10 sick days a year...I use maybe 5 of them for legitimate reason. The fact our society has turned sick days into unofficial vacation days is deplorable and a sign of degrading moral values and work ethic. Especially when you get a whole summer off. Teachers should be ashamed of this...along with the TTC and all the other people out there that take advantage of sick days.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jesse Wright
05:51 PM on 09/08/2012
I am a teacher - in the private sector...but I stand up for the teacher's union because they are standing up for their rights as a union. Apparently you don't know how many people can bank sick days in the public sector...just saying. And yes, I am saying that it would encourage teachers to call in sick more. Think of it. If you're given an allotment of sick days - say 10 per year. You're allowed to bank those sick days. On the days when you're kind of sick - not like, can't go to work sick - just kind of sick...would you be more encouraged to use that sick day if you knew that you could bank it, or would you be more encouraged to use the sick day if you knew that you would lose it if you didn't use it?...this isn't rocket science. Now with that said, I didn't say it was right or wrong...I'm just saying there's a reason for being able to bank sick days.
photo
hculliton
Match bearings and shoot!
06:46 AM on 09/07/2012
There's a problem with the Ontario PCs, and this is coming from a Tory: it's been destroyed by neo-conservatism. The Northern Republican message just doesn't sell any more and a party that's supported mostly by older, rural voters who remember the real pre-Harris Tories, looses relevance quickly.
06:34 AM on 09/07/2012
Tim, I like your platform but the left owned media is not on your side, your ideas are too radical for them the left and their reckless spending is driving Ontario into the red

More and more Businesses are leaving Ontario due to the high energy cost alone
07:28 AM on 09/07/2012
Businesses left Ontario due to NAFTA (Brian Mulroney) and GREED on the part of the corporations, Ontario has NEVER recovered from the exodus.
08:22 AM on 09/07/2012
Stop playing the blame game, Mc Guilty's Smart Meter fiasco has made is too costly for anyone to open shop not to mention his sneaky gas tax, want more ?

how about the healthcare fiasco ? billions lost
still more ? well how about the OPA

Mc Guilty' is now on his third term and things are not going to get any better for Ontario
in fact they are a mess

Lying comes easy for libs...
08:13 AM on 09/07/2012
Right, .....the left owned media.

You sound like Sarah Palin. Starting your comment like that demonstrates your inability to separate fact from fiction.

As for radical ideas, yes many conservative ideas are radical & further to the right than ever before. One need only to look to the federal tories for proof of that. To simplify businesses leaving Ontario into one cause, is to not understand the details or cause & effect.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:32 AM on 09/07/2012
Job creation? Tell that to the thousands of public servants being laid off while doctors steal millions in health care fraud and Ministers and their staff earn six-figure salaries.

We (the public service) aren't the problem here.
07:46 AM on 09/07/2012
Got some facts to back up the doctors comment? Cause I know of no other career where working 14 hour days, 6 days a week with $500 000 in loans to start is expected. So if they're stealing, vs you think you should be getting paid that much without the same sacrifices, you better have some good evidence.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:20 AM on 09/07/2012
From "Fraud Against the Public Purse by Health Care Professionals" by Joan Brockman, May 2005:

"The Ontario government has estimated that health care fraud runs between $60 and $300 million a year."

There are other estimates that range from $650 million to $1 billion being siphoned out of the system by corrupt doctors and patients.

No, I don't believe I need to make anything close to what an honest physician earns in a year. But I'm tired of being the scapegoat every time the government needs to save money. Contrary to public sentiment, we are not all lazy arrogant do-nothings. 99% of us care greatly about the service we provide to the people of Ontario, and take our jobs very seriously.

Do I support an across the board wage freeze? Yes. Do I support taking away bankable sick days? Certainly. Do I support mass layoffs and forced pay cuts while MPs get pay raises and crooks bleed the system dry? Absolutely not.
03:14 AM on 09/07/2012
Tim are you still in politics? Take the silver spoon and wait to be appointed on a bunch of panels and boards for a living, politics isn't your thing. Step down and maybe your party can get a new face to tell more convincing stories to the public.
07:29 AM on 09/07/2012
It would be nice to see GENUINE real Progressive Conservatives reclaim the party, then I would consider voting for them again! The last PC I voted for provincially was Bill Davis.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
canobserv
09:00 AM on 09/07/2012
there aren't any more Progressive Conservatives.....except maybe Redford in Alberta....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stanschurman
12:01 AM on 09/07/2012
Hey Tim, after the results of 2 bi-elections today, shouldn't you be worrying about getting the boot from your party? You haven't exactly been stellar at the polls, or hadn't you noticed. maybe Stevie Blunder will appoint you to the Senate.
10:52 PM on 09/06/2012
Message to Hudak: Step down now. In the off chance you're elected Premier of Ontario -- I'm heading to Quebec...Yes, as an Anglophone who speaks next to no French, I'd rather live under the PQ's rule.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lw-Ctr
I’m an atheist and I thank God for it.
10:44 PM on 09/06/2012
Hudak wants cuts.
This from a guy who apparently had 1 real private sector job .... at Walmart.
Can't wait for him to use the "rollback" lingo.
Border Guard, Walmarter, Political Hack.