Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tim Knight

GET UPDATES FROM Tim Knight
 

Watching the Watchdog: Save CBC, Kill The National

Posted: 04/11/2012 4:37 pm

Veteran broadcast newsman Tim Knight writes a regular column for HuffPost, analyzing and rating broadcast and online journalistic programs.

CBC News is killing the wrong programs.

Of all the programs in all the CBC world, the supposed-to-be-public service broadcaster is dumping two of its very best -- Connect With Mark Kelley on TV and Dispatches with Rick Rick MacInnes-Rae on radio.

It boggles the mind.

It just doesn't make sense.

For weeks now I've been meaning to write about the manifold and manifest virtues of Connect. But for weeks, other topics got in the way. Mainly other CBC topics. Like the little matter of a $115-milion budget cut.

So I kept pushing the Connect column back down my list of priorities.

Mea maxima culpa.

And now it's likely too late.

But I was never famous for doing what CBC management told me when I worked there for lo, those 15 years.

So I see no reason to simply accept CBC management's decision now.

Note to Hubert Lacroix (CBC President and CEO):

Do the honourable thing, Sir. Change your mind. Admit you're wrong.

Connect and Dispatches are exactly the sort of programming public service broadcasters like CBC are supposed to do. Which is why we taxpayers send the CBC big money every year.

Not incidentally, we also pay you big money, Mr. President, to make the right decisions in our name.

In this case you made the wrong decisions.

But it's not too late for you to change your mind. To screw your courage to the sticking place.

And kill The National.

And replace it with a more generously-funded Connect with Mark Kelley.

Mark Kelley and Connect are young, while Peter Mansbridge and The National are old.

Kelley and Connect are energetic, while Mansbridge and The National are tired.

Kelley and Connect are the future, while Mansbridge and The National are the past.

Connect is already consistently better TV and a whole lot cheaper to produce than The National.

Once you've put The National out of its misery, you'll easily have enough cash to restore Connect and Dispatches. With a lot left over to finance foreign bureaux and vital interactive Internet technology.

Most important of all though, taking such a drastic step -- killing the CBC's once-revered flagship program -- will signal to the world, the country and CBC employees in all departments that there's a new day, a new public broadcaster in Canada.

A public broadcaster born out of the ashes of the past, honouring its mandate, "to inform, enlighten and entertain" in a new, interactive, 21st-century way.

In this new world, all CBC programming will be re-thought, revised, renewed.

In the news, anchors and reporters will think aloud, share information with viewers, using normal voices and normal, everyday language, like Kelley on Connect. Instead of the strange, pushed, loud, announcer-reading voices favoured by Mansbridge and crew on The National.

Stories will no longer be assigned and designed with the outdated idea that passive viewers flock to the program every evening grateful to be fed the facts of the day. Instead, stories will focus on meaning, on bringing understanding of the world we live in.

The idiotic concept that crime, disasters and weather, and "if it bleeds, it leads" make for great news programs will be consigned to the garbage bin of history.

And a new CBC, a new public broadcaster for a new century will be born.

 

Follow Tim Knight on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TimKnight6

Veteran broadcast newsman Tim Knight writes a regular column for HuffPost, analyzing and rating broadcast and online journalistic programs. CBC News is killing the wrong programs. Of all the program...
Veteran broadcast newsman Tim Knight writes a regular column for HuffPost, analyzing and rating broadcast and online journalistic programs. CBC News is killing the wrong programs. Of all the program...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
11:52 AM on 04/18/2012
Thanks for saying what I have been saying for several years.. being abroad and returning for months at a time to enjoy many (most) of the uniqueness of the CBC and what it has done to bring Canadians together. Sadly, I see nothing of this characteristic in The National... and I've long felt it is past time for Peter to go somewhere and retire.. or become an ambassador somewhere.. work in an Embassy .. others have done it.. and he'd be good at that.. not so good at 'news' delivery anymore.. all of our good ones went somewhere else.
10:32 AM on 04/18/2012
Now that is one powerful post. Simple and to the point. No second reading on that blog entry. You get the point without any extra fluff. I guess when all is said and done, I cannot help but agree with Mr. Knight. His comments are seemingly spot-on. If you can't somehow slowly do away with the old, than cut it and allow some new growth to live. CBC is our flagship "go to" for information. If we reduce it to cuts in keeping with "mainstream" news, than what are we saying that we value as a country. I agree, those in positions of power are paid to make decisions. Hard decisions. These decisions however, can be changed. Perhaps it is a simple issue of male pride.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigLittle
08:45 PM on 04/14/2012
Fire Peter, Rex, and the brains trust political panel. The "anchor" is a vastly overpaid "news reader".
The CBC can hire nine reporters for the price of the one "anchor" on The National, and getting rid of Rex and the rest will free up some expense money so the reporters can actually track down some stories..
12:23 AM on 04/13/2012
I thought CBC did a good job with Wayne and Shuster and Pierre Burton to get Canadian TV off the ground.
12:21 AM on 04/13/2012
Geez, CBC is cutting the shortwave broadcasts in Russian, how will we survive
photo
Ryan L Painter
Activist, friend to labour, blogger, progressive
05:03 PM on 04/12/2012
If we lost the National we'd likely lose the single best journalist the CBC has. No, not Peter Mansbridge. I'm talking about Terry Milewski. The subjects he's covered and the in depth nature of his coverage, given the time allotment he has, has always impressed me. I also appreciate the At Issue panel, though I do wish it would have a more diverse representation of political opinions. Nothing against Andrew Coyne and others, but they all fall mostly in the same political spectrum (with Hebert being the most centrist of the three).
What the CBC does need to do is abandon TV all together. Search Youtube for Reimagine CBC: Dump TV and hear Kai Nagata give a good alternative to CBC TV. You won't be disappointed!
Cheers

Ryan
photo
Add In Canadia
Egotism is a weakness
01:49 PM on 04/12/2012
The National is iconic, not something that should be tossed aside willy nilly. That said, it could stand to use a facelift. Yet at the same time I suspect the Fifth Estate, Market Place, and Doc Zone replaced the National's stronger points of deeper investigation. Which is a bit understandable I suppose, better to have 30-60 minutes to delve into a topic than just 5-10.

The main reason why the National has become rather redundant is because the Internet is a faster and easier way to get the news, and Canadians rank somewhere on the top of the world for people who use the internet. Still, the National is something that should be reworked, not tossed out; why? Because the reality is that the National still has a lot of draw and respect among Canadians. It makes more sense to improve upon it, not chuck it out like failed reality TV series.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Keith E
Earth Warrior
12:01 PM on 04/12/2012
I'd like to see Kevin O'leary and Don Cherry removed from the payroll.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
09:38 AM on 04/12/2012
This is one of the worst suggestions I've seen in decades. Kill The National? The one and only sound source of journalism with a public conscience available to the country as a whole? Never mind those of us who live in rural, Northern, and/or isolated communities with little to no access to other Canadian sources. The National is one of the things that continues to make me proud to be Canadian, and we need much more of it, not less, and much more in-depth coverage of issues. Mark Kelly as an alternative? Surely you jest. He was a charming morning man, donkey's years ago, and should have been left there, or moved into something that took advantage of his capabilities. He is so far from being a serious journalist that your suggestion is beyond laughable--he's a complete light-weight.Yeah he's young--he has lots to learn. Yes Mansbridge is older--every hear that age can bring experience and wisdom? Your suggestion is unmitigated nonsense.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:37 AM on 04/12/2012
The only thing I know for certain Tim is I am glad to not be in the shoes of Mr. Lacroix right now. All of the programs mentioned have merit, and I hate to see any of them go. Having said that, I agree with your choices and justification for picking them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:02 AM on 04/12/2012
I am no fan of the National for what it has become, mimicking CTV, Conservative Televison, lately worried about the rich having to pay more taxes. Somehow thinking that ratings matter, especially presenting pundits echoing dawn of the dead news. Hey CBC guys, be heroes, be yourselves every day. I am a fan of the National for what it always can be, pure journalists unfettered by Corporate propaganda brain washing points. A democracy works best when journalism is strong, free and fiercely independent. Somehow this journalist thinks freedom is for commercial entities, at the end of the day always seeking a raise, a tax cut for their mega owners, being free and dedicated to pursue their Canadian dream, a polite version of 1984, with Canadian journalists bent on serving their masters, not the ideal of serving the country, what money can you make doing that?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Eileen Warren
01:52 AM on 04/12/2012
Dispatches was one of the best programmes that CBC ever had;and yes,so was Connect.I very rarely watched the National as it became more of a job for pontificators and arguing ones point of view does nothing to solve problems.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SeanMartin
Everything in moderation.
10:26 PM on 04/11/2012
>> "Kelley and Connect are the future, while Mansbridge and The National are the past"

As much I enjoy Connect, I really dont see it as the future, sorry. Not unless your concept of the future is "Dude! Here's, like, the news! And stuff!" — which is pretty much the logical progression.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JBSCanada
They paved Paradise and put up a parking lot!
09:56 PM on 04/11/2012
I trust The National as an unbiased news source, it's world-wide network of journalists and reporters are world class.

I wouldn't trade the entire enterprise for anything.

When I want to hear some deeper discussion, interviews and get further context over and above what I see on The National, I tune into Power & Politics with Evan Solomon or Connect with Mark Kelley.

CBC management are messing with one of their bread and butter programs and that of itself will drive advert revenues downwards - at the worst possible time for it.

Time for a re-think.

Cheers, JBS