Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tim Knight

GET UPDATES FROM Tim Knight
 

Watching the Watchdog: Don't Just Rely on Social Media

Posted: 12/14/2012 8:54 am


Tim Knight writes the regular media column, Watching the Watchdog, for HuffPost Canada.

There's a notion abroad in this fair and frozen land -- particularly among the young -- that we don't really need general interest news organizations (known condescendingly to many as "the mainstream media").

Somehow, many of us have been persuaded that social media alone can keep us up-to-date and fully informed.

Utter bullshit.

General Interest News Organizations (GINOs) like newspapers, broadcast networks and magazines are the cornerstones of our democracy. Without them, the nation to and on which the social media would report will no longer exist.

Because without democracy, Canada would have:

  • No free, fair and competitive elections.
  • No separation of powers into different branches of government.
  • No rule of law.
  • No open society.
  • No protection of our human rights and civil liberties.

It's that blindingly simple. Without GINOs we wouldn't be Canada.

Their journalism in our democratic society is a public service, defined and protected by centuries of struggle. Their journalists literally represent the people. They're the irreplaceable messengers serving and guarding the people's democratic right to know.

Too often, the cost is high. For at least the last decade, around one journalist a week is killed somewhere in the world while practicing the honourable craft.

It takes years of training and experience to produce a first-class journalist. Some kid living in his mother's basement who's mastered Facebook, Twitter, and blogging, simply doesn't qualify.

Most professional journalists work for GINOs which, whatever their faults, are information centres run, staffed and edited by experts who double-check facts and are trained not only to seek out information but also to explain its significance and put it in perspective.

Ideally, the job of journalists in these GINO information centres is to report on the world we live in with accuracy, honesty, fairness, impartiality and objectivity, producing disinterested, but not uninterested journalism, without bias, fear or favour.

Social media can't offer any of that.

Of course, GINOs aren't perfect. Nor are -- at least in my experience -- priests, politicians, doctors, lawyers, tax accountants, prostitutes or readers of this column.

Of course, GINOs screw up sometimes. Particularly now that newsrooms everywhere are cutting back on staff while desperately trying to find a place in this new, frightening, digital world.

All of which is creating its own crisis. Already, the proliferation of social media information websites encourages people -- not just the young -- to visit only those websites that agree with their already pre-existing biases. Websites with no pretext to impartiality or fairness. No pretense to public service.

When people do that, they can't hear the multitude of differing views and voices out there provided by the GINOs. Instead, they hear only one side of every story. Which means they live in a dangerously narrow, fantasy world in which there's only one truth and one answer to every question.

They become the equivalent of religious zealots. If that doesn't scare you, just look around the world today and check out the damage caused by those who serve their one true god with blind faith and utter contempt for non-believers.

As if all this isn't enough, there's another danger to democracy looming on the horizon. What The Economist calls "The four giants of the Internet age -- Google, Apple, Facebook and Amazon."

In just a few, short years, the four have become incredibly rich and powerful information monopolies. "Never before" reports the magazine, "has the world seen firms grow so fast or spread their tentacles so widely."

Its those tentacles we should fear.

Already, that other information giant Microsoft, the world's largest software corporation (assets $41-billion), has started its own news service. Now it controls content as well as software.

Can Google, Apple, Facebook and Amazon be far behind?

Unlike the GINOs, none of these companies has a culture of public service unless you count their overweening need to get everyone on earth to buy their products and services. They have no history of serving and protecting democracy, of honouring the people's right to know.

Yet if the GINOs die or are seriously wounded, these are the astoundingly rich and powerful organizations that will swiftly move in to take over their pubic information roles.

Yes, it's true our GINOs are far from perfect. But they're a helluva lot better and safer than any of the likely alternatives.

Let us never forget that as journalism goes, so goes democracy.

 

Follow Tim Knight on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TimKnight6

FOLLOW CANADA
Tim Knight writes the regular media column, Watching the Watchdog, for HuffPost Canada. There's a notion abroad in this fair and frozen land -- particularly among the young -- that we don't really ...
Tim Knight writes the regular media column, Watching the Watchdog, for HuffPost Canada. There's a notion abroad in this fair and frozen land -- particularly among the young -- that we don't really ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:35 PM on 12/14/2012
Mr. Knight, you've been in the business for a long time, much of it at the CBC. Here's the link to the CBC's most popular flagship radioshow in Montreal. Click on the tab "Chroniqueurs". 24 contributors. All whites. All French Canadians except for their U.S. based commentator. http://www.radio-canada.ca/emissions/cest_bien_meilleur_le_matin/2012-2013/index.asp
Radio-Canada? More like Radio-Apartheid.

1/4 of Canada is composed of visible minorities. Visible minorities are now 50% of the people in Vancouver, just shy of 50% in Toronto and 30% in Montreal. You don't see a problem here? No wonder more and more of us are shunning your much vaunted General Interest News Organizations. Because, if anything, they're not.
12:44 PM on 12/14/2012
I agree with you that society cannot place its trust solely in social media, and those individuals that do run the risk of viewing the world from a narrower and narrower point of view. Our democracy is dependent on an open and unbiased discussion in public and the GINOs can and do for the most part provide that forum.
You say in your article “GINOs aren't perfect” and “GINOs screw up sometimes”, but I am more concerned by the increasingly accepted bias and blatant fabrication within media entities presenting themselves as GINOs. I see this is a greater threat to journalism and how we view journalism than the rise and increasing impact of the bloggers and social media in passing on “news” or information.
12:01 PM on 12/14/2012
"Ideally, the job of journalists in these GINO information centres is to report on the world we live in with accuracy, honesty, fairness, impartiality and objectivity, producing disinterested, but not uninterested journalism, without bias, fear or favour."

Sadly, a good part of the turning away is due to the fact that mainstream media seems to have forgotten about the "accuracy, honesty, fairness, impartiality and objectivity..." bit.

The "false equivalence" culture that has grown in newsrooms has seriously compromised the value of reporting. The overwhelming reluctance to speak truth to power doesn't help much either.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:42 AM on 12/14/2012
Canada is a democracy? Since when? Harper has stolen 3 elections so far with the 100% support of the right-wing 1% owned media. I don't even blame Harper for robbing Canada blind. I blame the owners of mass media for every evil visited upon Canada, EVERY ONE YOU CAN BLAME THE MEDIA FOR THIS PLAGUE.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:41 AM on 12/14/2012
The Aspers who owned most of the newspapers and Global TV helped ferry Harper around southern Ontario in their private chopper during the last run up to the election. There have been a few commissions on media monopolies and concentration but none of the recommendations seem to be implemented. Senator Keith Davey led a commission back in 1970 on media concentration but can't see that any recommendations were implemented.

Here's a site describing the monopolies:
http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/media-ownership/media-monopoly.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:40 AM on 12/14/2012
Asked to give a toast before the prestigious New York Press Club, John Swinton, the former Chief of Staff and editorial writer at the New York Times, made this candid confession at a banquet held in his honor in 1880, nearing the end of his career:

http://constitution.org/pub/swinton_press.htm

"There is no such thing, at this date of the world's history, as an independent press. You know it and I know it. There is not one of you who dares to write your honest opinions, and if you did, you know beforehand that it would never appear in print. I am paid weekly for keeping my honest opinions out of the paper I am connected with.

Others of you are paid similar salaries for similar things, and any of you who would be so foolish as to write honest opinions would be out on the streets looking for another job. If I allowed my honest opinions to appear in one issue of my paper, before twenty-four hours my occupation would be gone.

We are intellectual prostitutes."

[It's worth noting Swinton was called "The Dean of His Profession" by other newsmen, who admired him greatly]:
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:39 AM on 12/14/2012
You no longer have reporters, you have repeaters.

http://thetyee.ca/Mediacheck/2010/12/28/NewNewJournalism/

The new game began in Canada on Aug. 27, 1980. “Black Wednesday”, as it became known, was the day newspaper corporations across the country colluded to swap properties and kill competition. The Ottawa Journal and the Winnipeg Tribune folded, and Vancouver Province's owner, Southam, bought the Vancouver Sun. The two had been in bed together since 1950s via a press-and-profit-sharing agreement at Pacific Press that killed the third paper and defended against upstarts.

Suddenly competition for readers was no longer necessary; these publicly traded corporations now focused on advertiser-pleasing copy as the technique for pulling more ads.

At least Postmedia has an understandable reason for changing standards: they're legally obligated to maximize profits. But the fact that the commercial-free public broadcaster also ignores the public good suggests that there is a new definition of journalism.

http://thetyee.ca/Mediacheck/2010/12/28/NewNewJournalism/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:39 AM on 12/14/2012
How Rich Elite & Corporate Propaganda Hijacks Democracy

Do you ever wonder why so many of the Fraser Institute’s right-wing commentaries get into Canadian daily newspapers? Perhaps you’ve been disturbed by the spate of articles about the inevitability of Canada forming closer ties with the United States. Maybe you’re troubled by the constant media attacks on medicare?

Former SFU communications professor and occasional Straight contributor Donald Gutstein explains how Canadians are being duped by a sophisticated, broad-ranging, and reactionary public-relations assault financed by some of North America’s largest corporations.

Wealthy Americans such as brewing magnate Joseph Coors and newspaper publisher Richard Mellon Scaife funded several think tanks in the 1970s to spread a libertarian message of deregulation and lower taxes, which countered the consumer revolution led by Ralph Nader.

http://www.straight.com/article-266343/gutsteins-theory-pries-lid-think-tanks

http://www.amazon.ca/Not-Conspiracy-Theory-Propaganda-Democracy/dp/1554701910
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:39 AM on 12/14/2012
Media convergence, acquisitions and sales in Canada

Here is a survey of some of the major Canadian media players, past and present.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/story/2010/04/29/f-media-ownership-canada.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:39 AM on 12/14/2012
On Thursday, February 9th, 2012, Bell Media, owners of CTV and CFRA Radio in Ottawa, fired talk show host Michael Harris. Harris is a journalist of the highest integrity, a Woodrow Wilson Scholar and award winning author of numerous books, four of which have sparked Canadian Royal Commissions. He has been outspoken on Palestinian rights, environmental issues and the Harper government’s undemocratic behaviour just to name a few.

More recently (April 2011) he was fired from the Sun newspaper chain, (owned by the right-wing Quebecor group with strong ties to the Prime Minister’s office) after writing a series of articles critical of the Harper government. He suspects, that a column he wrote just before the May 2011 election titled “Harper no longer on high moral ground,” was the stimulus for his dismissal.

http://dissidentvoice.org/2012/02/a-voice-of-integrity-in-the-canadian-media-fired-again/

Michael Harris was fired from the Ottawa Sun in May 2011. Eric Margolis had been fired not long before that. Michael was fired from CFRA radio on Feb 9, 2012. At first he thought is was due to pressure from the Israel lobby as Michael has been outspoken on Palestinian rights right back to 2001. It later came to light that it was the regime that got him fired. Read my article here. http://seriouslyfreespeech.ca/2012/02/dissident-voice-a-voice-of-integrity-in-the-canadian-media-fired-again/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:38 AM on 12/14/2012
Canada’s indentured press

Why are Harper’s enablers, some of them sitting on the editorial board of my beloved Globe and Mail, so untroubled by the fact that the PM has his boot on the neck of Canadian democracy?

Is this what happens when the Report on Business rules the editorial roost?

Has editorial board policy scaled the newsroom walls on Front Street as the Publisher’s Office once did in the days of Roy Megarry and Norman Webster? Is the Globe’s zeal for a Biznocracy in Canada so keen that it now believes, along with the government, that the end justifies the means?

With the anniversary of Watergate upon us, it is time for a little soul searching at the Grey Lady. My advice? Send a few marquee columnists into official government service and hire Maher, McGregor, Ditchburn and Naumetz. No doilies behind those heads.

http://www.ipolitics.ca/2012/06/20/michael-harris-conservatives-have-campaigned-and-governed-with-no-regard-for-democracy/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:38 AM on 12/14/2012
Who Killed Canada
Media Ownership and the Radical Right in Canada

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d8D67YiLcOM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fiurWhmOIgk&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRnZ43wxGvY&NR=1
Part 1, 2 & 3. Note: each video about 10 minutes long

No time for video? Read review instead:
http://pushedleft.blogspot.com/2009/11/under-stephen-harper-we-are-no-longer.html

Mr. Hurtig begins by discussing the Canadian media and how we now have the greatest concentration of media in the western world. In fact, he states this would simply not be allowed in any other western democracy.

And since these same media outlets control newspaper, television and radio news; we are essentially only being given one voice. There are few or no alternative views. As stated in the video, a healthy democracy should foster a healthy and independent news media.
photo
albertarick
These are questions for wise men with skinny arms
10:07 AM on 12/14/2012
"only one truth and one answer to every question". The GINOs offer a corporate friendly-one-way-wealth-and-power-distrubution context for most issues, and on the balance frame every democratic attempt at fairness as 'left leaning'. It is very difficult for many, faced with this obvious bias, to engage in dispassionate assessment.
While I sympathize with your sentiment that 'less than perfect' may be better than the messy alternatives, perhaps the GINO's should strive for a little closer to perfect, instead of complaining.
photo
AcunningDisguise
magnus gigas caput
08:59 AM on 12/14/2012
I quite agree but social media puts a human face on the news.
Often the word on the street is totally opposite of what your being told.