Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Werner Patels

GET UPDATES FROM Werner Patels
 

Alberta - Canada's 'Banana Republic'?

Posted: 02/27/2013 12:43 pm

Canadians are taking in the daily news stories out of Alberta and are seriously beginning to wonder whether the country's once-richest province is on its way to becoming a banana republic within the Confederation.

To recap: Alberta is facing a major deficit, and even that is being underplayed by the provincial government, because it doesn't include the money drawn from the Heritage Fund. With things being murky out there at best, the deficit could easily be stated as nearing or, possibly, exceeding, $10 billion.

The Alberta government blames virtually all its troubles on the "bitumen bubble", a sharp discount on Alberta oil that forces oilsands companies to sell the precious resource at dumping prices.

As Alberta's economy is the very opposite of a diversified economy, when oil is in trouble, so is the entire province.

But this is only part of the truth, for Alberta doesn't just have a revenue problem, but also a spending problem.

For years, Alberta's politicians have spent money as if it grew on trees. Most infamously, the premier, Alison Redford, has gone so far in her belief that she's entitled to her entitlements as to expense her law society membership dues to the taxpayers.

Nothing was ever too good for MLAs and anyone considered a friend of the Progressive Conservatives.

Now that Albertans are slowly beginning to wake up, the scandals of the PCs are seeping into the public's view - almost daily. As a result, for example, there is now a realization setting in that the PCs may have been dirtier than even the federal Liberals at the height of their former scandals (Adscam, Human Resources Boondoggle, etc.).

Leaving aside any suspicions of government corruption, there are enough problems in Alberta that would make anyone shiver with fear of what the future holds.

Already the province with some of the longest wait times for medical procedures, Albertans will soon face a full-blown healthcare crisis, as doctors will move away, while a lot fewer doctors will be trained. Entire medical disciplines are vanishing from Alberta.

The lack of economic diversification is what will break this particular camel's back. There is very little anyone outside the oil and gas sector can do to make a decent living in Alberta. Premier Redford has now set aside some money to help drive a more diversified economy, but her thinking is flawed: the economy can't be diversified overnight, and even if that feat could be pulled off, it would require an investment of several billion dollars, and not a couple of hundred million.

Fearful that a decision by U.S. President Barack Obama against the Keystone pipeline will exacerbate the bitumen bubble even further, and result in even higher deficits, the premier has only recently begun to campaign for the pipeline at home and in the U.S. - literally at five minutes after the stroke of twelve, rather than before.

But yet again, short-sightedness has become the chosen approach: cancelling the carbon capture program removes one redeeming feature of Alberta's oilsands, which will make it even harder for Obama, the environmentalist, to approve the pipeline.

It's enough for anyone to pull out his hair. Whenever Alberta's government is faced with two choices, it invariably opts for the bad one.

Therefore, it shouldn't surprise Albertans, many of whom still carry a grudge over the National Energy Program (NEP), that the rest of Canada has decided that natural resources, such as the oilsands, should belong to and be managed by all of Canada.

It's no longer a question of if, but rather when, the next NEP will be implemented. There simply is no way around it. Alberta isn't an island, nor is Canada. In this globalized world of ours, we need to speak with one voice, not five or ten, if we are to stand strong and protect our national interests - particularly vis-à-vis an increasingly hostile neighbour to the south.

 

Follow Werner Patels on Twitter: www.twitter.com/WernerPatels

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jack Hope
Occasionally quoted by Mainstream Media
06:07 PM on 03/01/2013
Alberta's been a banana republic since the days of King Ralph.
05:12 PM on 03/01/2013
Harper's pet project is ruining Alberta instead of boosting their economy. But those huge oil corporations are making out like bandits. Now Harper wants people in BC to believe him when he says the pipelines will be good for us and if there's a huge oil spill that it would be good for the economy. Clean up crews would provide jobs. Toyally insane logic. The representatives from Northern Gateway said this:
"Northern Gateway witness John Thompson told the Joint Review Panel that given what happened after the Exxon Valdez spill in Alaska in 1989, clean up crews attending a spill could generate economic spin-offs.

"Part of the evidence in the spill recovery document is, in fact, a lot of those companies in the Alaska communities made more money catering to the clean-up of the spill than they would of under normal circumstances," Thompson said under questioning from the United Fishermen and Allied Workers' Union."

http://www.princegeorgecitizen.com/article/20130227/PRINCEGEORGE0101/302279982/-1/princegeorge01/oil-spills-can-benefit-economy-panel-told
10:15 PM on 02/28/2013
Alberta has been betrayed by its politicians and sold out to the wealthy elite.

This is no time to be smug in retaliation of a few ignorant trollers who took pleasure in Quebec's difficulties. I think most Canadians feel badly for the citizens of Quebec who have been so betrayed and robbed and save their disdain for the politicians and racketeers.

This is not about left/right, east/west, secular/religious. It's about fellow Canadians who have been ripped off. I bet we could all get behind some national transparency laws so we could see exactly where our tax dollars are going.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Benoit Brousseau
Progressives built the Western world.
08:23 AM on 03/01/2013
Very well said! Too bad I can't fan you twice!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CalgarySandy
If you have a brain you can have a mental illness.
07:50 PM on 02/28/2013
Alberta is only rich for the rich. The province my great grandparents and grandparents built is no longer for regular people. The resources do not provide money for the citizens. They go to the uber wealthy. Our health care plan is a disgrace. I have seen suits in the core cursing and laughing at the street people. I have listened to them in boardrooms. Our schools are caving in. Our neighbourhoods have bushes growing in sidewalks. Storm drains and clogged and frequently flood. The Calgary I grew up in is now a cesspool of oil suits and money managers. Workplace bullying against those who are not gung ho Capitalists or who indicate empathy for the poor is rampant. As in TV and TV commercials, bullying is done for fun against those who are not mindlessly in tune with the right wing agenda. I did leave but the dot.com crash took my work permit and my house and furniture. I had a job offer in Toronto but they pulled it out from under me and I ended up having to come to Calgary where I had family. Now I am too old and poor to leave. If I won a lottery I would flee this place as fast as possible for the sake of my adult son who is being left behind by right wing policies. I love the land and even that is being sold off and destroyed by these money grubbers.
09:27 AM on 03/01/2013
Alberta had so much promise for itself and the rest of Canada but it thought it could do it all on its own. Now the real concerns have come to haunt the most blessed child of the Confederation. The mismanagement of Alberta's wealth is down-right shameful.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CalgarySandy
If you have a brain you can have a mental illness.
05:40 PM on 03/03/2013
Alberta is not an entity. It is a geographical location. It did not think anything. There is no typical citizen. I am far to the left and green. The oil industry; which was primarily owned by American oil companies, is in the hands of greedy people, many of them not Canadian. As the East bought its petroleum products from the US because it was cheaper so companies here sold it for a better price to the US. Alberta has no industries. We have resources so the economy has been boom bust for decades depending on the price of coal, wood and petroleum products. It was easy to see the complete takeover by the oil companies but no one wanted to know or got hostile at the idea that the rich would lie. There is no single Alberta. There are the big money and power of international oil companies,and there are the agricultural roots and there is the urban world of high tech.
12:40 PM on 03/04/2013
You shamlessly paint an inaccurate one-sided caricature. The delusion in your comment makes it clear your mind has not stood the test of time.

Seriously - Bushes growing in sidewalks? Clogged storm drains? I live in Calgary too - If you call 311, they show up and fix these things.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CalgarySandy
If you have a brain you can have a mental illness.
08:43 PM on 03/04/2013
Visit the older neighbourhoods, the ones I grew up in the 50's. Altadore has lots of bushes coming up and tearing the concrete to pieces. Glendale/Glamorgan/Tuxedo are going the same way. I never saw a storm drain back up into the streets like they do all the time now. I was born here and am a fourth generation Albertan; descended from homesteaders. This was my home and they have let it go to ruin where the older people live and before the hideous huge houses are slapped up so close to each other if one goes up in flames they all do. My son worked in construction for years and saw the same ruin where the working class live and spit and polish in the over priced, badly built houses for those who think they are upper middle class. I taught social studies in Calgary.

I shall refrain from insulting you as you insulted me. I don't need to win. I have a complaint about what has happened and it is my experience not my delusion. I am not trying to convert anyone or tell anyone their brain is dead. That is you.
06:33 PM on 02/28/2013
Interesting..albertans..these guys were pretty smug commenting Qc's unfolding corruption crackdown and financial/ fiscal challenges!
Seems qc might have only been ahead of the curve!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CalgarySandy
If you have a brain you can have a mental illness.
07:55 PM on 02/28/2013
Some Albertans. We did not elect Harper as we do not have enough seats to do so. Ontario and Quebec always provide the most seats. I have never been smug in my life. I am a Canadian first. My relatives did not fight in WW2 for Alberta; where they were deeply poor. They fought for Canada. They fought for our allies. I suspect that you have spit at us because of a handful of those who do support the destruction of my home. FYI Alberta has long been the place with jobs for Easterners. There are not that many people in Alberta who were born here. I find Easterners who complain about Albertans hypocrites as thousands of people come here to work and then send the money back east. They are here to get as much money as they can and then leave. They do not support our schools or cities. They hate the place but they like the money.
03:07 AM on 03/01/2013
Sandy
Don't know never been to Alberta... Flew over a few times on way to Asia.
04:56 PM on 02/28/2013
The so-called "bitumen bubble" is all a smoke screen. The government knew long ago the bitumen is sold at a lower rate than refined product. They knew what they were making on a barrel or bitumen (roughly). But now they are pulling out this gem and offering it to the public like a get out of jail free card. "Oh, we forgot that our product is not worth as much as a barrel of refined oil!" Get your head out of the sand Redford, Albertans are finally starting to see that not everything ruins on oil...