Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
GET UPDATES FROM Yoni Goldstein
 

Remember That School Yard Bully? Hello, He's Now Your Boss

Posted: 08/31/2012 9:00 am

As a new school year begins, anti-bullying campaigns have become more formidable than ever before. This is obviously a good thing since the world would be a much, much better place for kids if there weren't so many little turd belligerents around. Anti-bullying champions are a noble bunch, and they present an articulate plan of action that rests on two principles: building kids' self-esteem and sense of self-worth so that they will instinctually deflect the abuse of bullies, and encouraging them to open up to parents and school administrators when bullies get to them.

Again, a noble effort, but not without some glaring holes. For starters, there's a reason kids tend to not speak up about bullying, which is that doing so will most likely result in further bullying. Children a) relish the opportunity to punish one another for the grievous crime of "telling" and b) abhor being told what to do, much less being threatened, by adults. Speaking up will more than likely result in a reputation as a brownnose, not a hero's welcome at lunchtime, which in kid land is justification for bullying.

It's a fine strategy in the adult world -- a workplace environment, for example, where an HR person can basically hold the continuance of a paycheque over a bully's head -- but it's completely useless when dealing with children, who are smart enough to know tattle-taling -- even on some puke jerk-off -- is one of the worst social crimes they can commit.

As for the strengthening kids' self-esteem part, this is an important exercise but very difficult to maintain outside the home, because, once a child is on his or her own it doesn't matter how much a parent builds them up if it isn't reinforced by their peers -- and you can bet it's not being reinforced by their peers because kids aren't in the habit of doing that kind of thing (friendship at a young age is based on mutual interests -- sports or video games or music -- not admirable personality qualities).

The sad reality is this: You can't stop bullying and you certainly can't protect your kids from it. There are, however, two ways to combat it.

The more mature method is to offer your child a reality check: There are a lot of losers out there and one must learn to live with the losers because they are for some unexplainable reason a part of life. This approach offers the added bonus of serving your child well as he or she eventually grows to become a working stiff and undoubtedly encounters adult jerks.

Explain to your children that not everyone is as smart and/or talented as they are and therefore must resort to hurting others because it's the only way they can get attention. Use examples from your own life, like that useless lump of a coworker who resorts to insults to overcompensate for his lack of intellect and ability. This is a lesson your child is going to have to learn eventually, so why not get started early?

The other, potentially more satisfying, plan of action is to teach your kids how to fight back. This may seem hypocritical -- fighting bullying by, essentially, bullying back -- but in my view is completely acceptable when used in moderation. As I said before, your average tough guy is overcompensating for something, typically stupidness or ugliness though, there are other possibilities: Teach your child to hit back -- we're talking about kids here, so even the most basic insult about looks, or weight or bad grades will likely do the trick. Generally speaking, bullies prey on the weak; if your child proves his or her strength, the onslaught should stop.

(You might even want to encourage your child to involve his peer group -- the more the merrier.) Of course, you must set very clear boundaries: bullying as a means to end bullying must only continue until the bully gets the message. Otherwise you risk creating your own monster, thus defeating the purpose of the exercise and proving how terrible you are at parenting.

I won't advocate fighting back with fists, even in scenarios where the bullying is physical. Still, it's never a bad idea to teach your tykes a bit of self-defence. Because a bloody nose is also something that bullies respond well to.

Bullydom is but another of God's cruel jokes, a state of being that serves no discernible purpose to mankind. And yet there it is anyways, so the best we can do is limit bullies' ability to negatively affect us. Each child that learns how to successfully counteract bullying means one less opportunity for the bully to wreak havoc. Eventually, one envisions the bullies only have each other to torture, which would actually be really entertaining for the rest of us, come to think of it. And at that point perhaps the benign message of anti-bullying crusaders won't be so glaringly lacking.

 

Follow Yoni Goldstein on Twitter: www.twitter.com/yonigoldstein

FOLLOW CANADA LIVING
As a new school year begins, anti-bullying campaigns have become more formidable than ever before. This is obviously a good thing since the world would be a much, much better place for kids if there w...
As a new school year begins, anti-bullying campaigns have become more formidable than ever before. This is obviously a good thing since the world would be a much, much better place for kids if there w...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:56 PM on 09/01/2012
Not sure that Yoni Goldstein is anyone that should be listened to about schoolyard bullying. How many kids has he successfully raised? None, I'd guess. Another Dr.Spock here who tries to give advice about things of which he knows nothing. Most of his columns come across that way - a smart mouth who has very little life experience. Those with real life experience finally realize they don't have all the answers, but usually things work out because they are atuned to those around them, including their kids who may be subject to bullying at school. To tell kids that their best defence is to become bullies themselves hardly seems like wise counsel!
02:37 PM on 09/01/2012
ha! Love it. Great article.
07:27 PM on 08/31/2012
First off, thank you for continuing the important discussion of bullying in our schools.

Your strategy is one way to advocate for kids in bullying situations but I think it's frequently more complicated than the scenario you've described. Yes, some bullies are simply trying to cover up their perceived or actual inadequacies, but it could also be the the bully is him/herself being abused at home, has a substance abuse problem (it can start at amazingly young ages), or even has a learning disability or psychological condition that has been undiagnosed. In cases like these, your "bullying the bullier" strategy wouldn't resolve the situation – the bully would just find another target, or turn his/her destructive behaviour back on him/herself, potentially with catastrophic results.

Kids who are bullied for any reason can be emotionally and psychologically scarred for life (if they don't commit suicide first) and it simply cannot be understated how important it is for the kids to get the help and advocacy that they need (including self-defense lessons!). Kids, schools and parents need a multitiered approach to resolving bullying in their schools. Advocate for the kid being bullied, advocate the bully him/herself, facilitate the school's anti-bullying policy. When everyone (kids, parents, and the school) work cooperatively to create a safe environment for learning and development, we all learn an important lesson about resolving conflict in positive ways. Thank you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
agsterino
Less stuff . . . more meaning
12:20 PM on 08/31/2012
I realize I was very limited as a consultant. I have had occasion of working under a bully who caused more problems by her lack of ability, but because of her one brilliant ability to suck up to those in power above her, she was considered a darling. I confronted her when she phoned to say she would not pay me for all of the hours I worked (only a matter of 2 hours), but she obviously was not confonted very often and was definately surprised. I stated my case very clearly. She listened and agreed. However, when I received the pay, she had not paid me for the hours. The true sign of a bully is the cowardice when they are confronted.

However, she was still employed there, and I was not asked back.
It was only a discrepancy of 2 hours
But for that price it was clear she was an overbearing bully, and I was honest.

Negotiating properly (manipulating) a bully is obviously a skill that is very crucial to being a consultant, and I admit, that is a skill I still have trouble with.
11:52 AM on 08/31/2012
Further to previous, your statement that at work you can just go to HR, who will hold a paycheque over the bully's head, is not true. Some bullies are valued as employees and will never be punished. If that's the case, espy in a nonunion environment, it's unlikely anything will be done about them unless they become a liability to the company. That can't be proven unless a group of employees document bullying behaviour until they have enough to speak up and present a very solid case and threaten legal action. The problem is, most people in that situation would rather look the other way, just put up with it and get on with their day. In a way, the bully makes them accomplices. So finding people to join forces can be really difficult. It takes a person with nerves of steel to stand up to that kind of hostility, and chances are the scars will run very deep.

Really bad advice.
photo
Gnomish
ego doctus ignarus
10:49 PM on 08/31/2012
I work with several I've beaten them all by being a bigger SOB then all of them!

Then I go back to being my usual charming self.
11:50 AM on 08/31/2012
"your average tough guy is overcompensating for something, typically stupidness or ugliness"

This is not true. There is no physical or mental prototype for bullies or victims. One of the main reasons bullies bully is they've been bullied themselves. Bullying is about feelings of inadequacy, but it's a *perception* of inadequacy. For kids, it's often a reflection of what's happening at home. For older kids, it's often a reflection of what's been happening to them at school. Victims often become bullies. It's important to get to the roots of bullying, but that won't happen as long as social programs to kids and families are continually cut.

I've known some very intelligent and attractive adult bullies. They just go about bullying in smarter, harder-to-prove ways, ways that others will say "oh, you're just being hypersensitive" or "you're just being politically correct." Bullying back may or may not solve the problem with male bullies, who tend to be more physical, but females tend to be subtler. And a) it's not so easy to bully back at behaviours that you can't even clearly identify, and b) when the target engages in the bullying, it becomes entrenched.

I'm sorry, but your advice on bullying is really badly misinformed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cordierite
always misunderstood
04:05 AM on 09/01/2012
Don't know if this writer is speaking of this situation in his home country but in the U.S. there are instances where people have gone "postal" over being terminated and some of the situations like this was a result of superior & co-workers being liked this.
11:38 AM on 08/31/2012
Bullying is a spectator sport, and one tactic missed here is to encourage non-bullied kids to step in and defend the victim, thereby eliminating the bully's main source of strength: a supportive audience.
I was bullied in the first few weeks of high-school, and the only thing that finally stopped it was when an older, popular girl I did not even know intervened and put the bullies in their place, verbally. I became friends with her and her group, and was never bullied again. Teacher involvement only intensifies the bullying by forcing it outside of school grounds. But peer support, and showing that other kids 'have your back' is the best tool there is.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GeoffMorton
09:48 AM on 08/31/2012
I'm gonna go punch my boss right now!
08:58 AM on 08/31/2012
Yoni while I believe your words to mean well in the fight against bullying , your suggestion to teach kids to bully back is not the best approach. Bullying has been around forever only now it's more visible. This is because of awareness and education. The anti bullying campaigns are not enough but they are getting the ball rolling. People need to step up too.... no more of this " oh well it's not happening to me so it's not my business attitude " This type of hush and pretend behaviour hurts kids and adults . Kids need to know there is help available and if one person doesn't helpkeep asking because another will. Schools need to tackle this subject head on and be consistent with resources and rules ie: anonymous incident reporting, supervision, teach social skills, zero tolerance and most impotantly accountability. Workplace bullying can throw one back into the playgraound scenario and the old hurt rises inside again. The same rules and assistance should apply here too. No one has the right to bully no matter who they are. I agree fight back but do so by education and awareness helping making sure no one allows bullying or pretends it doesn't happen. The more we get involved with the anti bullying campaign the less bullying will happen.