Written by Wayne Karl
Prospective homebuyers in Toronto -- get used to one thing: ever-increasing prices. Either that or move further out in the GTA. Or rent.
These are the limited options -- and unfortunate unintended consequences -- caused by government policy and market forces in the Toronto area, says Benjamin Tal, deputy chief economist of CIBC World Markets.
And things aren't going to get better any time soon.
Speaking at the recent Building Industry and Land Development Association's 2017 Economic Outlook Conference, Tal cited the Ontario government's Places to Grow plan as the primary cause of skyrocketing home prices in the GTA.
The average price of detached homes in the GTA recently surpassed the $1-million mark for the first time. Buyers are now looking further out of the city, causing markets there to see double-digit price growth. Oshawa, for example, recently recorded the fastest year-over-year gain in average price -- at 26 per cent -- in all of Ontario.
Places to Grow is the Ontario government's program to plan for growth and development in a way that supports economic prosperity, protects the environment and helps communities achieve a high quality of life across the province.
No one can argue with government's program to better plan growth and such important issues as investment in infrastructure, Tal says. But Places to Grow has had an underestimated impact on the price of housing across the GTA.
"Affordability and Places to Grow cannot co-exist," he says.
It is such forces, and not foreign investors or other factors, that are the primary cause of rising home prices in the Toronto area.
"The number one reason for house price inflation in the GTA is supply -- which is all about government policy," says Tal. And there is "zero chance" of that policy changing.
Nor are foreign buyers the chief cause of rising prices in Vancouver, he says. There, the cause is geography, with limited ability to expand housing supply because of the city's waterfront location.
"More money, not less, will be leaving China. The only question is where it's going."
The recent introduction of a foreign buyers' tax in Vancouver, and other conditions, have caused sales there to pause significantly -- but not prices, at least not yet. Royal LePage, in its latest House Prices Survey, for the third quarter of 2016, says these developments could soon lead to a more balanced market in Vancouver.
Royal LePage President Phil Soper is among the experts who do not expect capital to automatically migrate to Toronto.
"We are not seeing a significant migration of foreign capital from Vancouver to Toronto in the wake of the new property transfer tax," he told YPNextHome. "Most people, whether they be of domestic or international origin, buy houses for the location and lifestyle, not simply based on financial investment criteria.
"While there has been a recent increase in foreign interest in Canadian markets like Toronto or Calgary, this has more so to do with the regions' characteristics and prescribed lifestyles, which differ greatly from that of Vancouver. Put another way, if a Canadian had their heart set on purchasing property in Florida, a new tax would not automatically entice them to purchase property in Arizona. The two markets are completely different, and in many cases they are purchasing in Florida for a specific reason."
'Welcome To Ontario'
Tal, on the other hand, is not so sure more foreign investment in Canada is not heading east.
"More money, not less, will be leaving China. The only question is where it's going."
Vancouver, through its new tax and discussion of another levy -- a "vacancy tax" -- seems to be telling the world "no more."
As a result, "it's going to be 'Welcome to Ontario,'" especially Toronto, says Tal, as foreigners look for places to invest.
"The only question is what will the government do about that," he says, pointing to speculation that Ontario will introduce its own foreign buyers' tax.
One positive for prospective homebuyers is that interest rates in Canada are not likely to rise any time soon, as the Bank of Canada is focused on keeping the dollar low. "If anything, the Bank will cut rates, not raise them," Tal says, citing low interest rates around the world.
But this also contributes to an "affordability mirage," as buyers are blinded by low interest rates.
Post originally published on YPNextHome.ca
Follow HuffPost Canada Blogs on Facebook
Also on HuffPost:
Location: Stuart Lake, B.C. Price: $175,000 American Island is 8 acres (3.24 hectares) in size, and has a kilometre of shoreline to run around on. The island is the seventh-largest in B.C., running 90 kilometres north-south, and 13 kilometres east-west. It has plenty of trees, and two bays good perfect for mooring boats. (Photo: PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Location: Stuart Lake, B.C. Price: $85,476 Like American Island, Sweet Island is also in Stuart Lake — a great spot fishing rainbow trout, char, lake trout, and sturgeon. Sweet Island has a high elevation with no cliffs and boasts tons of pine and aspen trees. There's already old house for accomodation, and a half-acre clearing for a garden. The entire island is 66 kilometres long, 10 kilometres wide, and has 170 kilometres of shoreline. And if anyone ever needs a break on the mainland, the town of Fort St. James is also on Lake Stuart's shoreline with full services like lodges and motels. (Photo: Private Islands Online)
Location: Tusket Island Chain, Yarmouth County, N.S. Price: $65,000 A great place for a summer retreat, the Big Tusket Island Parcel is actually two pieces of land that total 37 acres of size. The chain, a group of granite islands located off of Nova Scotia's Southwestern coast, is primarily uninhabited. The islands offer a very natural environment and is home to a number of unique lighthouses. There's electricity on both islands, and amenities are available in Comeau's Hill — an attractive Acadian coastal town. (Photo: PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Location: Lama Passage, B.C. Price: $249,000 Lizzies Cove Island is a magnificent 6.5-acre, virgin-forested island with almost two kilometres of ocean front. Cruise ships and killer whales regularly pass by one side of the island, and fishing in the area is "superb," according to its listing. The nearby town of Bella Bella offers plenty of amenities, including a hospital, post office, and liquor store. (Photo: Private Islands Online)
Location: Mahone Bay, N.S. Price: $90,000 At 11.5 acres, Tancook Island is the largest island in Mahone Bay — an area with lots of fishing and about 125 year-round residents. (Photo: Private Islands Online)
Location: Stuart Lake, B.C. Price: $431,482 Johnson Island is a private, 20-acre space that has been occupied by the same family since 1947. It has about one kilometre of shoreline, and the cabin's beachfront has stunning views of the northern lights and stunning sunsets. The cabin, built in 1949, is made of reclaimed old growth timber from the island. It has a large front room divided into a kitchen, as well as a comfortable dining room. The house, which sleeps six people, also has a detached shower room and smokehouse. Access is by float plane or boat, the latter of which can be launched from the nearby village of Tachi. (Photo: Private Islands Online)
Location: Ontario, near Manitoulin Island Price: $103,000 Little Island, or Jenny Island, is a historically significant commercial fishing outport, where the fisherman and their families lived for the season during the 1800s and early 1900s. The land is accessible both by boat and by plane. (Photo: Private Islands Online)
Location: Southern Gulf Islands, B.C. Price: $380,000 This 7.5-acre property has been left entirely in its natural state. Located in the southern Gulf Islands, it's a completely private island with an impressive fir forest. The island isn't far from Ladysmith, and sits in the Stuart Channel. (Photo: Private Islands Online)
Location: Mitchell Bay, N.S. Price: $150,000 Just 290 metres from the mainland, Tidmarsh Island has 24 acres of land that boats a thick forest a natural cove for mooring. Halifax is about two hours away, and the town of Sheet Harbour — with shops and amenities — is less than a half-hour trip. (Photo: Private Islands Online)
Location: B.C. Price: $449,000 Echo Island, which is a 25-minute flight in a float plane from Williams Lake, is made up of four, one-acre lots. There's a dedicated road just for the island, a bridge crossing for ATVs, and pedestrian access from mainland to island. There's also a 15-metre dock neighbouring the two-bedroom cabin. (Photo: Private Islands Online
Follow YPNextHome on Twitter: www.twitter.com/YPNextHome