Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Yummy Mummy Club

GET UPDATES FROM Yummy Mummy Club
 

Giving Birth to a Child Doesn't Make You a Parent

Posted: 08/13/2012 11:45 am

2012-08-13-are_you_my_mommy.jpg

"So, you're not her REAL mother."

The woman who said that to me at the grocery store yesterday made me clench my teeth. I had to breathe deeply as I turned and walked away, with two-year-old Allie in tow. We didn't get far before Allie gave me a toothy grin and asked, "Mommy, go home now?" with her usual lispy cuteness.

I'm still angry at the offhand comment from this woman. I'm frustrated, because she's right in the eyes of the law.

I did not give birth to Allie. She is not even my adopted daughter. I'm her foster mother, but I have no rights to make key decisions for this child in my care. I am the one who feeds her and clothes her; the one who gets up with her at night when she can't sleep; the one who lets her throw up down my back when she's sick (still a vivid memory); the one who cleans up spilled milk and crayon wall art, Every Single Day.

And, yet, I'm not allowed to cut her hair. Not even one snip. I need permission from her "real" mother to do so. I can't take her on vacation without a signed letter of approval. If Allie was school-age, I wouldn't be able to sign permission forms for school field trips, since I'm not her legal guardian or even considered her parent.

So, who am I?

When I started foster parenting, I tried to get the kids to call me "Auntie" or "Mama K" or something short and cute, since most of them had a biological mother still in the picture. Nothing stuck. Every single kid ended up calling me "Mommy." When my own children are calling me "Mom" daily, how can I expect my foster children to call me something completely different? No one in our house is treated differently. Everyone gets the same love and attention, eats the same food, and shares the same toys. But what is sad is that, apparently, that doesn't happen a lot.

I've learned that many foster families have a very definite line between their own kids and the "other" kids. There are separate tables for eating meals. There are specific foods and clothes and toys that are earmarked for "those kids." There are no extra treats, unless it's reimbursable. Many homes also send their foster kids away over Christmas -- to live somewhere else -- because they want the holiday with just their "real" family.

Am I the only one that is shocked by that?

Every 90 days, I meet with Children's Aid and Allie's biological mother to discuss whether I should be doing anything differently, in the type of care that I am providing. I have to listen to this woman -- who has never been a parent, since Allie went straight to foster care at birth -- and I have to do my best to comply to her wishes on how her child needs to be fed, clothed, and parented. How I need to take her to a specific doctor, in another neighbourhood, an hour away, for checkups. How I need to go to a specific church on Sundays, to ensure Allie gets a specific religious upbringing. How I have to dress her in pink more, so people don't think she's a boy. How I have to encourage something other than "Mommy," as my term of reference.

Click here to learn what makes foster parenting so rewarding.

I understand how it must be frustrating to want so badly to play a part in your child's upbringing -- and being denied that chance -- but I believe that if you continue to deny addictions and make poor life choices and your own personal judgement and choices are continually flawed, then you lose the right to make decisions on how a child is raised.

Allie's "real" mother has never been with her daughter for more than two hours at a time -- and only in an office where she is closely supervised. "Mom" has never taken Allie to the park, given her a bath, or put her to bed. I'm the one teaching manners, surviving potty training, and enforcing timeouts for bad behaviour. Maybe one day, Allie will be able to return to her biological mother, but until that happens -- whether it be months or years -- I am the one that is parenting this little girl. And until that time, "Mommy" is the only title I can see that fits.

Last week I drove Allie to the Children's Aid office for her regular visit, and a social worker walked Allie to the front door where her biological mom was waiting. I heard the worker say, "Look! It's Mommy!" and saw Allie turn around, point to me, and announce firmly, "DAT'S my mommy." I had to smile.

Raising a child is what makes you a parent. It has nothing to do with the uterus your child came from.

Written By: Karen Elliott, Yummy Mummy Club

More from YummyMummyClub.ca

Suspecting Child Abuse

Five Things You Won't Learn In A Parenting Book

 

Follow Yummy Mummy Club on Twitter: www.twitter.com/YummyMummyClub

FOLLOW CANADA LIVING
 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:53 PM on 08/17/2012
I have mixed feelings about this... On one hand I really agree with this post in many ways. I would consider Karen to be Allie's "real" mother because I do believe that giving birth does not automatically make someone a parent, actual parenting does. On the other hand, I think the system is all kinds of messed up... I mean, according to the system, Allie's biological mother does still have some rights to her because she is, technically, her child. When you consider that, it makes sense that Karen does not have complete control over Allie's life. It will always be like this if we have this sort of halfway between adoption. I guess the major question is we need to ask is, at what point should a biological mom have no claim of a child? And better, who gets to make that call?
10:07 PM on 08/13/2012
I agree we are parenting the children but we are not their parents. I try very hard to love them only in the moment and not think too much about their future. I've had to say good-bye 51 times and it NEVER gets easier!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Torontosaurous
07:47 AM on 08/14/2012
Wow!!!!! You must have a monster sized heart.Caring for all those kids and seeing them go would be tough.Good for you Smokey backroom.
photo
Gnomish
ego doctus ignarus
09:48 PM on 08/13/2012
This woman flawed though she may be is the mother, You are not.
trying to cut a child off from biological parents is cruel although usual punishment.

My foster parents even changed my name so my mother couldn't track us, To this day I don't know who I am.
06:35 PM on 08/13/2012
here is the thing about this. what this foster parent dont know is the CAS is likely lying about the mother in court and it is CAS who is refusing to work with the parent. I dont know if the woman has addictions or not but the CAS makes this excuse up alot because of the amount of money they make from funding from the provincial government. You are not in fact her real mother and you should not be allowing the child to call you that. they have a parent and the child should be with the parent. Did this foster parent ever stop to think the parent is denying addictions is because she may not in fact be an addict but the CAS says she is. How about this... why is the CAS telling the foster mom anything about the mother since this is a breach of the privacy act by doing so. This article is a joke and does not protray the real issues going on with the CAS. and please stop calling the CAS worker a social worker as this violates section 46 and 47 of the social work act because they are not registerd with the college of social workers thus not legally allowed to use the title social worker yet they illegally practice social work on a daily basis.
02:50 PM on 08/16/2012
What a strange post! You say that the Children's Aid Society is lying about mothers in court and that the mothers don't realize this. But mothers have the right to attend all hearings, so why wouldn't they know it? You also say that the CAS regularly lies in court in order to sustain current levels of funding. That would be funny if it weren't so sad and stupid....social workers in all major North American cities are so overburdened that they often don't have time to follow up on their current cases, and certainly don’t need to make unnecessary work for themselves. Furthermore, any mother falsely accused of being an addict merely has to agree to random drug tests. Because certain drugs, like heroin, leave the system so quickly, it’s not possible to accept the results of a test done at the time of the person being tested’s convenience.

When a drug addicted parent also has a borderline personality disorder, this can be a particularly toxic mixture, with the person claiming everyone finding fault with them is lying about them.

But your scattered,angry outburst does sound like the rantings of a drug addict.
11:39 PM on 08/17/2012
perhaps you need to do some research a bit more before assuming because I have done my research and have the documents and proof to back up what i say. as for the mothers not knowing the CAS is lying in court well the truth is they do in fact know it but cant prove it because the courts give the CAS an automatic level of credibility. in the eyes of the family courts when the CAS is involved your guilty untill you prove your innocent. the drug test you speak of is not up to the mother to prove she is not doing drugs it is up to the CAS to prove that she is.
03:34 PM on 08/13/2012
I had no idea of the loops they make foster parents jump through. I support the author's assertion that, in this case, she is more of a mother to that child than the biological mom will ever be!
03:13 PM on 08/13/2012
I wish all Foster moms were like you. I also wish moms who shouldn't be moms could learn to walk away or at least take birth control My kid has a friend with 6 siblings and all living spread out between caregivers, grandparents and the mom when she feels like it. Being a mom is a job...not the birth.
02:53 PM on 08/13/2012
You "need to go to a specific church " ? Surely the biological mother can request this, but it can't be enforceable. You "need to take her to a specific doctor...an hour away "? Again, how can this be enforceable, unless you are compensated for the travel time? It would seem that the counsellor would step in an explain to the biological mother that the money paid to foster parents and the time commitment by the foster parents limits what can be requested. If you feel taken advantage of, it's up to you to speak out and draw the line. The biological mother probably sees that making plans for all the minute details of her daughter's life will gain her points in the eyes of the counsellor, and probably feels this presents her as someone capable of having custody of her child. She has a lot of leisure to be the imaginary ideal parent, and if the counsellor doesn't introduce reality into the discussion, it's up to you.

As to smiling your encouragement when the child calls you 'Mommy', isn’t that wrong, even evil? Don’t promise what you have no control over. It should be clear, even to the very young foster child, that you can't be her real mommy. Your love can be real, but at any time she could be taken from you, and her only recourse would be to speak to the counsellor. Be her lift up in life, not a sure ticket to complete disillusionment.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:09 PM on 08/13/2012
Thank you for sharing your story, and I could not agree with you more. Really, how many chances does a biological parent deserve to get her/his life in order? A couple I know adopted two older children who had been in and out of foster care while 'Mom' half-heartedly attempted to clean up her act. Both kids were on meds for anxiety at the time, and acted out a lot. Several years later they are med-free, calmer, happier, and secure in this family - but don't ever doubt their early years affected them for life. Biological parents who won't provide a safe and secure home do not deserve the privilege of raising children.