Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Yves Engler

GET UPDATES FROM Yves Engler
 

Harper's Keystone Lobbying Is Tarring Canada's Good Name

Posted: 02/15/2013 8:09 am

On February 17, Presidents Day, tens of thousands are set to converge on the White House in what organizers are promoting as "the largest climate rally in U.S. history." The protesters will be calling on Barack Obama to reject the Keystone XL pipeline. For the first time in its 120 year history, the million member Sierra Club has endorsed civil disobedience actions on that day.

Alongside one of this country's biggest corporations, Stephen Harper's government has entangled Canada in one of the most controversial decisions of Obama's presidency. The Conservatives have lobbied vigorously in support of Calgary-based TransCanada's plan to build a $7-billion pipeline to take up to 800,000 barrels of oil a day from Alberta to refineries on the Gulf Coast. The prime minister has pressed Obama to approve Keystone XL while his ministers have visited Washington to pursue the matter with the Secretary of State. During two visits to Washington in recent weeks foreign minister John Baird said Keystone XL was his main priority.

Canada's ambassador in Washington, Gary Doer, has also spent a large amount of his time pushing the pipeline, prompting TransCanada to send him a "thank you" note on August 30, 2011. "Gary," reads an email from the pipeline firm, "I just wanted to send a quick note to thank you and your team for all of the hard work and perseverance in helping get us this far, I know it has made a big difference."

The ambassador responded to critical media commentary and pressed state officials to support the pipeline. When Nebraska's Republican governor Dave Heineman initially came out against the project Doer visited him in Omaha. Similarly, the 28 members of Congress who urged the State Department to consider the "major environmental and health hazards" posed by Keystone XL received an immediate letter from Canada's ambassador and Alberta's minister of intergovernmental relations. "I believe it necessary to address several points in your letter," Doer wrote. The ambassador's letter trumpeted Canada's plan to reduce overall greenhouse gas emissions 17 percent below 2005 levels by 2020. "[This is] a benchmark we intend to meet," Doer wrote, even though planned tar sands expansion will make this objective impossible to reach.

Canada's 22 consular offices in the U.S. have also been instructed to take up the "energy advocacy" cause. When the New York Times ran an editorial titled "Say No to the Keystone XL" Canada's consul general in New York wrote a letter supporting the project.

TransCanada has been equally aggressive in its lobbying. Last week the company's chief executive Russ Girling told reporters in Washington that rejecting the pipeline would be "the craziest thing I could think of for the largest consumer of oil on Earth."

The company has spent millions to convince federal and state politicians. In Nebraska alone TransCanada has spent almost $1 million lobbying lawmakers and also helped set up a non-profit called Nebraskans for Jobs and Energy Independence. The group paid for a robocall that contained the following: "Please Press 1 now to authorize us to send a letter to Secretary of State Hilary Clinton in support of the Keystone XL Pipeline, which will help to lower gas prices, create American jobs and reduce our dependence on foreign oil."

On the other side environmentalists have used social media and traditional protests to heap scorn on TransCanada and Canada. A November 23 New York Times article headlined "Pipeline Protest Draws Pepper Spray From Deputies" reported on protests outside Wells, Texas. The paper reported that 40 protesters "chanted 'Go back to Canada' and waved signs with messages like ... 'Don't mix Canadian tar with Texas water.'"

Many Canadians share American environmentalists' concerns about the tar sands' ecological footprint. But, even those who do not should worry about the impact the Harper government's lobbying will have on this country's reputation.

Once upon a time Canada was seen as a beacon to progressive Americans. What will we be known for in years to come?

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
On February 17, Presidents Day, tens of thousands are set to converge on the White House in what organizers are promoting as "the largest climate rally in U.S. history." The protesters will be calling...
On February 17, Presidents Day, tens of thousands are set to converge on the White House in what organizers are promoting as "the largest climate rally in U.S. history." The protesters will be calling...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 40
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
11:27 AM on 02/19/2013
This pipeline is an aberration to all of us who care more about our children's and grandchildren's future than filling the pockets of oil barons who have the moral development of alley rats. If this was REALLY about Canadian jobs then we would be talking about building refineries in Alberta not moving sludge thousands of kilometers when it is totally unnecessary. King Stephen is no patriot, he's a personality disordered demagogue of the first order, who has made us look like fools the world over.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
08:25 AM on 02/19/2013
They say a barrel of oil has the equivilent energy as 25,000 man hrs of work.
And because we have acces to cheap oil we are rich.
Our entire way of life 1850-2013 is because we have had access to cheap oil.
Many would argue that oil is ridiculously underpriced.
In light of its potential.
But because it is so cheap and has been for so long , we waste it.
Shamefully.
When the price of oil triples or quadruples 'again' and the price of food and just about every single other necessity of our modern lives follows suit, people will beg for this pipleine.
Oil touches every single aspect of our lives.
It is, for the lack of a better word, our god.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:18 PM on 02/18/2013
Rhetoric is not what is needed, we have forgotten the give away of our natural resources through NAFTA, and we have equally forgotten about the odious CHAPTER 11, due to that Canada ; U.S. ; Mexico Governments cannot stop these projects. They are guaranteed to go forward, any dissent goes to WTO, but, that will not happen unless one country stops the pipeline, discussions with affected parties is not on the top of the list, in fact Canada and the U.S. want to abolish tieing the environment along with economy. something the premier of alta stated.
10:06 AM on 02/18/2013
I would rather have a patriotic Canadian like Harper representing Canada to the world than "50+1" Mulcair who panders to the Quebec seperatists at every opportunity.
09:29 AM on 02/17/2013
We all know that the world is not going too stop using oil. Mr Obama say's that the U.S. Is moving away from oil but yet there oil production is the highest it has been in years.
I would rather Canada benefit over OPEC and Venezuala.
We need to step back and stop with the rhetoric, and come too a comprimise. Canada is losing out on a lot of money.
I will wait and see what is said on HP when the LPC are in power and the keystone pipeline get's the o.k.
01:22 PM on 02/19/2013
You do not know the proper use of the word too. You meant to use to. In two different sentences. It's too much. Your comment is now invalid since you can't grasp basic grammar. Too-da-loo.
10:33 PM on 02/15/2013
The Prime Minister would be doing all Canadians a disservice if he did not promote this hugely important economic project.
Even rational environmentalists are not calling for an end to oilsands development..
GET REAL !!
05:48 PM on 02/15/2013
I can't think of anything Harper has done which hasn't tarred the name of Canada. He has silenced the scientists and the press and stopped debate in the house of commons. He rolled hundreds of changes to environmental laws into the budget and so they were passed without debate or even knowledge of the changes. His mister of family alues, Vic Toews seduced his children's seventeen year old baby sitter but continues to serve as a minister in another portfolio. the scandal over the F35's, building three new jails when the crime rate was dropping, the destruction of the long form census and the the Wheat Board 9most farmers wanted to keep it, the scandal of Tony Clements and fifty million secretly channelled into his riding to build gazebos and other necessary things, Peter Kent, getting out of Kyoto, helicopteringa minister from a private fishing lodge to a government jet so he could fly home for a minor affair, three exposed senators he appointed, Bev Oda and on and on and on. Shsme shame shame.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
logicanada
Blogger, radio co-host, writer, editor, voice-over
04:44 PM on 02/15/2013
They obviously want a pipeline built to go . . . somewhere.

Why not to the center of the earth.
03:31 PM on 02/15/2013
How how long will it take to clean up the mess; how much will taxpayers pay to foot the bill to set the environment right again and help those who become sick with toxic water, air. It won't be ordinary taxpayers who get the clean-up jobs, it'll be Harper's cronies. So as usual with this government, it's a no-win situation for Canadians.
03:18 PM on 02/15/2013
20 year old Isabel Brooks & two of her friends locked themselves inside a segment of the Keystone XL pipeline controversial pipeline being built to carry toxic tar sands oil to the US coast for export -- to protest its construction. While inside the pipe, they discovered something shocking: there are already holes in the Keystone XL pipeline, created by faulty welding.

But moments after snapping a photo of the light coming into the supposedly airtight pipe, Isabel was arrested and held for 24 days in prison. An hour after her arrest, TransCanada laid that segment of pipeline in the ground without inspecting it.

Despite federal regulations making independent inspection mandatory, TransCanada pipeline contractors hire their own pipeline inspectors. Without truly independent oversight, TransCanada can cut corners and rubber stamp inspections. And when TransCanada cuts corners, our communities, farmland, water, health and planet suffer.

What’s really scary is that if Isabel found one segment of faulty pipeline, it’s likely there are others.

TransCanada has a legacy of pipeline spills. In the Keystone pipeline’s first year of operation, it spilled 12 times -- more than any other first-year pipeline in US history. This is a huge moment to show just how dangerous the KXL pipeline really is. With each day that passes, TransCanada is moving ahead with the construction of this pipeline, potentially burying more uninspected pipe, and putting more communities at risk.

If we speak out now we can make sure that TransCanada’s legacy of spills is stopped before it’s
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:03 PM on 02/18/2013
www.sumofus.org has an action alert and petition on this very subject. I cannot believe how absolutely quiet the media has been on this.
03:14 PM on 02/15/2013
Activists were protesting the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline, and while inside, they discovered something shocking: there are actually holes in the Keystone XL pipeline, created by faulty welding.

But moments after snapping a photo of the light coming into the supposedly airtight pipe, they were arrested and held for 24 days in prison. An hour after their arrest, TransCanada laid that segment of pipeline in the ground without inspecting it.

Join me in signing this urgent petition to TransCanada to get independent inspection for every single inch of the Keystone XL pipeline to identify and fix any holes in the pipe, before something catastrophic happens.

http://action.sumofus.org/a/kxl-hole/127/?sub=taf
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:06 PM on 02/18/2013
added this action to my comment without realizing you put it into your next one. hopefully this goes viral, we cannot continue with same old same old practices.
02:25 PM on 02/15/2013
At least they have toned down the rhetoric -radicals etc.The cons are fixated on oil and big business- and they think Canadians are supporting them. I didn't vote for them and neither did 66% of my compatriots. I am ashamed of the world-view of Canada, thanks to Harper.
01:10 AM on 02/16/2013
And yet we have a Conservative Majority government.
One day you will learn to live in the real world, but then why would you want to do that. ?
12:49 PM on 02/16/2013
I live in the real world where a con "majority" was won by deceptive means with 40 & of Canadians supporting it. I used to believe that I lived in a TRUE democracy. My reality came late as I "woke up" to the lying and hypocrisy of the harper government. I believe the truth is finally coming out and I rejoice!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:07 PM on 02/18/2013
Steven Harper Gerrymandered Government of Canada with ..
.Get by with a little help from my friends....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
01:49 PM on 02/15/2013
19 billion dollars worth of oil left in the ground in 2012 due to a lack of pipelines to get it to market.

Insanity.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rick Papineau
10:02 AM on 02/18/2013
'cuz oil spoils if it isn't shipped immediately? And, further, the oil in the ground being discussed doesn't go to "market". It's shipped to refineries (not in Canada and thus not creating Canadian jobs) and then sold back to us at a profit. That is "insanity"...

Provide sources for your claims... pretty sure we've had this discussion before.
10:12 AM on 02/15/2013
The pipeline would be very good for Canada, creating many jobs and increasing tax revenue. Thousands more jobs, billion more in tax revenue, whats not to like.

Of course without the pipeline, it really helps people like Buffett who owns the Burlington Northern railway, the way much of the oil is shipped. The $10-15 a barrel leaves Canada, instead of staying in it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:25 PM on 02/15/2013
I think refineries built in Canada would be better.
03:27 PM on 02/15/2013
You're joking right. You might want to check out the facts: "Despite federal regulations making independent inspection mandatory, TransCanada pipeline contractors hire their own pipeline inspectors. Without truly independent oversight, TransCanada can cut corners and rubber stamp inspections. And when TransCanada cuts corners, our communities, farmland, water, health and planet suffer.

What’s really scary is that if Isabel found one segment of faulty pipeline, it’s likely there are others.

TransCanada has a legacy of pipeline spills. In the Keystone pipeline’s first year of operation, it spilled 12 times -- more than any other first-year pipeline in US history. This is a huge moment to show just how dangerous the KXL pipeline really is. With each day that passes, TransCanada is moving ahead with the construction of this pipeline, potentially burying more uninspected pipe, and putting more communities at risk."
11:26 PM on 02/15/2013
You know, if you look hard enough you can find something wrong. Take fracking, there have been over 175,000 wells fracked in Canada over the last 50+ years, nothing reported to speak of.
Every day, yes EVERY SINGLE DAY, there are car accidents and people get hurt, even killed, we should ban cars, right???
09:49 AM on 02/15/2013
Wow, what a shock. Canadian government supports major project that will bring in billions in tax dollars every year. Who would have thought?

And when was the last time Americans ever paid attention to the way we do things here? Canada has never been a beacon for Americans, save for Michael Moore.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rick Papineau
10:08 AM on 02/18/2013
Source for the revenues you've quoted? There's a huge number being thrown around for short term benefits for the USA, but... I'm sure you're right, but just throwing around numbers is ridiculous.

Question, though: why is the CPC pushing for THIS pipeline, rather than expanding operations within Canada, so that ALL of the economic benefit stays in Canada? That SHOULD be the CPC's first priority...