ATLANTA - Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said his team's 19-inning game against the Braves deserved a better ending.
After his review of his contested call which ended the game, home plate umpire Jerry Meals said he "might" agree.
Julio Lugo scored from third base on a contested play at the plate, giving Atlanta a 4-3 win in 19 innings over Pittsburgh early Wednesday morning.
The game, which ended at 1:50 a.m., was the longest in Turner Field history and matched the longest in the major leagues this season. At six hours 39 minutes, it was the longest by time for both teams.
Lugo took off from third on Scott Proctor's grounder to third baseman Pedro Alvarez, whose throw to catcher Michael McKenry easily beat Lugo to the plate.
Lugo tried to avoid McKenry's tag with a pop-up slide. Replays indicated McKenry made the tag, but home plate umpire Jerry Meals called Lugo safe.
"I didn't feel the tag," Lugo said. "He made the right call. I got in there."
Hurdle argued the call vigorously, following Meals off the field as the Braves celebrated.
"The game tonight deserved way better than that," Hurdle said.
"For it to end that way is as disappointing as it gets in this game. Every player in the game laid it out there."
Meals said he thought McKenry missed Lugo the way a matador misses a charging bull.
"I saw the tag, but he looked like he ole'd him and I called him safe for that," Meals said.
Meals said a review of the play showed the tag "might" have been made.
"I looked at the replays and it appeared he might have got him on the shin area," Meals said. "I'm guessing he might have got him, but when I was out there when it happened I didn't see a tag.
"I just saw the glove sweep up. I didn't see the glove hit his leg."
With one out in the 19th, Daniel McCutchen walked Lugo. Jordan Schafer followed with a single to centre, moving Lugo to third.
With their bench and bullpen depleted, the Braves had to let Proctor (2-3), their eighth pitcher of the game, hit. Schafer advanced to second without a throw before Proctor's grounder led to the final play.
Proctor tripped trying to leave the batter's box, and reliever Daniel McCutchen tried to encourage McKenry to throw to first for a possible double play.
Then McCutchen realized Lugo was called safe.
"Can I say that he was out? Is that legal?" McCutchen asked, adding he saw the tag.
"I didn't know what everyone was screaming about," he said.
Despite the controversial ending, McCutchen said it was a special game.
"It was awesome," he said. "It was fun. It was like backyard baseball, no rules."
McCutchen (3-2) gave up one run in 5 1-3 innings.
The Phillies and Reds played 19 innings on May 25.
The Pirates' previous longest game was 6:12 at San Diego on Aug. 25, 1979. The Braves' previous longest game by time was 6:10 against the Mets on July 4, 1985, at Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium.
The Pirates scored two runs in the first and pushed their lead to 3-0 in the second on McKenry's homer. The Braves answered with three runs in the third, and the score remained 3-3 through the next 15 innings.
Several thousand fans from the announced crowd of 22,036 were still in the stands in the 19th inning, many standing and chanting.
The Braves lost catcher Brian McCann in the 10th inning when he strained his left oblique. He will be placed on the 15-day disabled list on Wednesday. Manager Fredi Gonzalez said he hopes McCann misses only 15 to 20 days. He plans to recall catcher J.C. Boscan from Triple-A Gwinnett.
The Pirates fell one game behind first-place St. Louis in the NL Central.
The Pirates had a chance to avoid extra innings but wasted a scoring chance in the ninth. McKenry had an infield single off Craig Kimbrel and moved to third on pinch-hitter Brandon Wood's single.
The Braves called a pitchout as Xavier Paul was squaring to bunt and McKenry was running toward the plate. McKenry stopped too late and was thrown out at third. Kimbrel struck out Paul to end the inning.
Atlanta's Chipper Jones, who strained his right quadriceps in Monday night's game, hit a groundout as a pinch-hitter in the eighth.
Jones, 39, came off the 15-day disabled list on Monday following arthroscopic surgery on July 9 to repair torn cartilage in his right knee.
Nate McLouth and Gonzalez were ejected by Meals in the ninth. McLouth struck out swinging and then remained at the plate, apparently to argue a called strike two by Meals. Gonzalez ran onto the field too late to intervene and keep McLouth in the game.