After nine of the 12 main jurors were seated, their ranks included a longtime football season ticket holder, a rising senior in the university, a man with bachelor's and master's degrees from the university and a soil sciences professor who retired after 37 years there.
The first day of jury selection showed the strength of Sandusky's and Penn State's links to their rural central Pennsylvania community, and the presiding judge indicated that those connections wouldn't by themselves be enough to keep them from being selected.
The jurors and four alternates could be selected as early as Wednesday, with opening statements not scheduled to begin until Monday. Sandusky is fighting dozens of criminal charges that he abused 10 boys over a 15-year period.
In the first questioning of 40 prospective jurors, about half said they or immediate family members worked at Penn State or were university retirees. One woman rented apartments to college students. Four knew Sandusky, a former Penn State assistant football coach. Two knew his wife.
Sandusky's lawyer won the right to have jurors chosen from the local community, and prosecutors had concerns that Centre County might prove to be nearly synonymous with Penn State. Sandusky had helped build the football team's reputation as a defensive powerhouse known as Linebacker U, his arrest toppled Joe Paterno from the head coaching position just months before his death from cancer and prosecutors say some of the attacks on children occurred inside university showers.
One of the first jurors to be seated wasn't just a season ticketholder since the 1970s: She said John McQueary — a possible trial witness and the father of a key witness — once worked with her husband.
When Sandusky's lawyer sought to have her removed for cause, Judge John Cleland signalled he would need more grounds.
"We're in Centre County. We're in rural Pennsylvania," the judge said, noting that such connections "can't be avoided."
Sandusky attorney Joe Amendola opted not to use one of his eight challenges, and she joined the panel. Amendola did strike parents with children of roughly junior high school age, similar to the ages for the boys prosecutors say Sandusky abused.
Other jurors selected included a 24-year-old man with plans to attend an auto technician school, a mother of two who works in retail, a retired school bus driver, an engineer with no Penn State ties and a property management firm employee.
All the jurors will have to say under oath they can be impartial.
Prospective jurors also learned that Paterno's wife and son were among the potential defence witnesses, about which a family spokesman declined to comment. Members of Sandusky's family also were on a list shown to the prospective jurors, along with assistant coach Mike McQueary and his father.
Mike McQueary, on leave from the team, has said he saw Sandusky naked in a team shower with a young boy more than a decade ago and reported it to Paterno.
Mike McQueary is also on the prosecution's list, along with young men who have accused Sandusky of abusing them.
Sandusky, 68, faces potential penalties that could result in an effective life prison sentence. He has maintained his innocence, acknowledging he showered with boys but saying he never molested them. His wife, Dottie Sandusky, has said he is innocent and his accusers are making up their stories.
Among those potential jurors who were struck from the pool were a nurse who said people make up stories all the time — prosecutors used a challenge for her — and a man who had volunteered for the charity Sandusky founded, The Second Mile. Also struck were a mother of 10 who said she has made up her mind, a Penn State fan and township manager who said news coverage of the case has been destructive to her community, a woman who taught Sandusky's son in third grade before the Sanduskys adopted him and a 1994 alumnus who knows the Sanduskys.
The judge told the more than 220 potential jurors he would not sequester them, meaning they can spend nights at home during the trial.
While about a dozen TV news trucks and more than 50 reporters waited outside the courthouse for updates, the judge urged members of the jury pool to avoid news accounts or social media postings.
"No one in the world will know as much about this trial as the people sitting in the jury box," he told them.
Sandusky attended jury selection and laughed at some of the judge's humorous remarks to potential jurors. But when the judge told the pool the nature of the charge, Sandusky put his head down.
More than 600 summonses were sent out to residents in Centre County, the home of Penn State University's main campus.
The judge addressed the prospective jurors in a sombre, packed courtroom. The prospective panelists were to be taken in groups of 40 for more questions and, ultimately to face one-on-one questioning in a third phase, for those who were not dismissed beforehand. The jurors who were selected were allowed to leave for the day.
Early in the process, jurors were asked to indicate through a system in which they held up cards whether they had connections to Penn State.
About a dozen signalled that they worked or had retired from the university; another half-dozen said they had spouses who worked for the school.
Four indicated they knew Sandusky. Two said they knew his wife, who was not in court on Tuesday.
Two potential jurors indicated they had previously volunteered with The Second Mile.
Of the first group of 40 to be questioned Tuesday morning, the judge dismissed five for medical reasons or vacation plans.
Some of the accusers are expected to testify during the trial, which the judge said may last three weeks.
Prosecutors have claimed that Sandusky groomed boys he met through The Second Mile, which he founded for at-risk youths in 1977, then attacked them, in some cases in his own home or inside university athletic facilities.
Lawyers must pick three more main jurors and four alternates. The defence and the prosecution have used five of their allotted eight strikes.