This article exists as part of the online archive for HuffPost Canada, which closed in 2021.

Northern Gateway: James Moore Slams Enbridge's Safety Record, In Sharp Divergence From Party Line

Heritage Minister James Moore opened up a rift in Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s government this week, becoming the first and only cabinet minister to take a critical stance publicly on Enbridge’s plans for an oil and gas pipeline from Alberta to British Columbia.

Moore, who represents the Vancouver-area riding of Port Moody-Westwood-Port Coquitlam, may have been reflecting local sentiment when he raised serious concerns about Enbridge’s safety record in the wake of a series of oil spills along the company’s pipelines in the U.S.

“I believe in getting Canada’s energy products to world markets and I believe that that’s Canada’s interests and I believe that’s in British Columbia’s interests,” he said during an interview Wednesday on Vancouver radio station CKNW. “But this project will not survive public scrutiny unless Enbridge takes far more seriously their obligation to engage the public and to answer those very legitimate questions about the way in which they’ve operated their business in the very recent past.”

Enbridge found itself the target of criticism yet again this week after news broke of an oil spill on a pipeline in Wisconsin. That spill came only weeks after a scathing report from the U.S. government described the company’s handling of an earlier oil spill in Michigan as being worthy of the “Keystone Kops.”

In yet another incident, an Enbridge pumping station in Alberta leaked 230,000 litres of oil in June.

Asked what alternatives British Columbians may have if they don’t want Enbridge running new pipelines through the province, Moore had praise for Texas-based pipeline operator Kinder Morgan, which is currently planning to spend $5 billion tripling the capacity on its pipeline between the Alberta oil sands and Vancouver.

Moore praised Kinder Morgan for "very judiciously and responsibly engaging with British Columbia’s First Nations” and “taking environmental challenges seriously,” noting the company hasn’t had a spill in B.C. in 60 years of operations.

"There’s a difference, I think, night and day between a company that gets public engagement, Aboriginal engagement, environmental stewardship and Enbridge," he told CKNW's Bill Good.

Moore criticized B.C. Premier Christy Clark for laying out a series of conditions her government wants to see met before it’s willing to accept the Northern Gateway pipeline. He said Clark was being too vague in her demands.

But he said Clark was right "in terms of her responsibility to represent British Columbians. To make sure that the rest of the country understands that just because British Columbia is physically the Asia-Pacific gateway, it doesn’t mean that we’re the doormat for companies like Enbridge to think that they can go ahead and do business without having due diligence and taking care of the public’s interest."

Enbridge’s Northern Gateway project would see twin pipelines built between Bruderheim, Alberta and Kitimat, B.C., carrying both oil and gas, at a cost of $6 billion. A recent poll, taken in the wake of recent Enbridge oil spills, found 59 per cent of British Columbians oppose the project, though many could be swayed with the right environmental and revenue guarantees.

Also on HuffPost

The Oil Sands and Canada's Environment

Suggest a correction
This article exists as part of the online archive for HuffPost Canada. Certain site features have been disabled. If you have questions or concerns, please check our FAQ or contact