11/10/2012 03:27 EST | Updated 01/10/2013 05:12 EST

Minister Defends Decision To Halt Vets Privacy Breach Probe

Getty Images
Canadian veteran soldiers parade in front of the Canadian memorial, on April 9, 2012 in Vimy, northern France, during the commemoration ceremony marking the 95th anniversary of the Crete de Vimy battle during World War I. A total of 3,598 Canadian Corps troops were killed and 7,004 were wounded over four days of fighting as they seized control of the ridge from German soldiers. AFP PHOTO PHILIPPE HUGUEN (Photo credit should read PHILIPPE HUGUEN/AFP/Getty Images)
Veterans Affairs Minister Steven Blaney is defending his decision to halt an investigation by Canada's veterans ombudsman into a controversial breach of privacy, saying that the Office of the Privacy Commissioner was best suited to handle the matter.

Blaney asked Guy Parent, the federal veterans ombudsman, in July 2011 to discontinue a probe his predecessor had ordered seven months earlier, according to documents obtained by The Canadian Press.

In an interview with CBC Radio's The House, Steven Blaney, Minister of Veterans Affairs, told host Evan Solomon "any privacy breach of a veterans' file is totally unacceptable."

Blaney said as soon as he was informed there could be a potential breach of privacy, he asked federal Privacy Commissioner Jennifer Stoddart to investigate and instructed officials in the Department of Veterans Affairs to "fully cooperate."

But in January 2011, Blaney's predecessor, former Veterans Affairs Minister Jean-Pierre Blackburn, felt it necessary to order the veterans ombudsman to investigate the matter even though he knew the privacy commissioner was already looking into what had happened separately.

The focus of Stoddart's audit was different from that of the veterans ombudsman.

Blackburn ordered the probe after hundreds of senior bureaucrats accessed the confidential medical information of Gulf War veteran Sean Bruyea in an alleged smear campaign. The federal government later settled a lawsuit with Bruyea out of court, but other veterans have since made similar complaints.

When asked why he cancelled an investigaton his predecessor thought was relevant, Blaney said, "for me, it's clear. In this country, the privacy commissioner is the best one to investigate in any potential breach of privacy.

"We, as parliamentarians, have dedicated a privacy commissioner and given her full power to do a thorough investigation, that's why this is the best person and the best office," the Veterans Affairs minister said.

In an audit released a few weeks ago, Stoddart gave the Veterans Department a thumbs-up, suggesting it had cleaned up its act.

Veteran complaints mount

After settling with Bruyea, the federal government implemented a series of measures intended to ensure that the personal information of veterans is better handled within the department. But news that Blaney halted a controversial investigation did not sit well with the veterans advocate.

In an interview airing on The House, Bruyea told Solomon "the minister interfered in an independent investigation."

"If the minister and the department had nothing to fear from the ombudsman's investigation... why didn't the minister let it go forward?" Bruyea asked.

Blaney rejected the assertion by opposition critics that his decision to shut down the investigation called into question the independence of the veterans ombudsman.

The ombudsman "is free to study" what he feels is important, Blaney said.

Bruyea doesn't blame the veterans ombudsman. Instead, Bruyea said what this shows is the veterans ombudsman job should be legislated by Parliament, as is the case with independent officers of Parliament like the federal privacy commissioner or the auditor general.

Blaney was in Trenton on Saturday to attend the unveiling of a new Afghanistan Repatriation Memorial. He spent the better part of Veterans' Week defending the federal government's record and treatment of veterans — including news that soldiers' families are raising serious concerns over the care their loved ones are receiving at the largest veterans care facility in the country.

Retired sergeant Tom Hoppe, one of Canada's most decorated veterans of the Bosnia war, announced this week he will not be wearing his medals on Remembrance Day Sunday in protest of the federal government's treatment of vets and in support of a group of Afghanistan war veterans that have filed a class-action lawsuit, saying the disability payment regime under the New Veterans Charter violates their human rights.

In an interview that aired Friday on CBC News Network's Power & Politics, Hoppe said it was a "difficult" decision but a necessary one because the new charter — which he supported when it was first introduced — was suppose to address the very concerns vets are now going to court over.

"It's an outrage that this has happened, and on top of that, people's privacy was breached," Hoppe told guest-host Hannah Thibedeau.

"We have tried to work within the system and we have tried to get mediation with the minister and nothing has happened, what's left to do? The public has to know what is going on," said Hoppe.

Hoppe has said that his personal privacy was also violated when federal officials snooped in his records in 2006.

Meanwhile Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who is on a trade mission in Manila, was asked by reporters why a federal burial fund for poor veterans was rejecting two-thirds of applicants.

"Let me just say that government of Canada puts, as you know, a very high priority on care for our veterans. This government has made enormous, billions of dollars worth of investments in programs, particularly for the most needy veterans," Harper told reporters at a news conference with the Philippine President Benigno Aquino.

"Obviously those programs are under constant review and we will continue to assess their suitability going forward," Harper said.

The federal government has ended its legal fight to maintain tax clawbacks on disability payments for soldiers. It has also put money into "helmets-to-hardhats" programs to help former servicemen and women enter the workforce.

Blaney told Solomon there are "many reasons" to believe that in four year from now Veterans Affairs will be "thoroughly transformed" pointing to recent efforts by the federal government to cut red tape and offer greater online services.

Also on HuffPost

Marking Remembrance Day -- 2011