The outspoken Toronto Blue Jays catcher tweeted he was leaving the social media website and promptly deleted his account Tuesday morning.
"It's unfortunate to see how words are twisted to make false stories," he said in a three-part tweet to some 145,000 followers. "I give way too much of myself to have others try and make me out to (be) something/someone I'm not."
Arencibia has struggled on the field this season, prompting criticism from both fans and the media.
"I will no longer be on twitter," he said. "Thanks to all the fans who support and praying for the others that hate. God bless."
It's not the first time Arencibia has responded to his critics. Earlier this month, Arencibia lashed out at Sportsnet analysts Dirk Hayhurst and Gregg Zaun over their negative comments.
Batting .219 this season, Arencibia has made five errors, allowed 34 stolen bases and 10 passed balls.
The Jays have also struggled and sit last in the American League East, 13.5 games back with a 45-53 record entering play Tuesday night.
They were hammered 14-5 by the Los Angeles Dodgers on Monday night.
His decision to leave social media prompted an immediate reaction on Twitter.
"Really sad @jparencibia9 shut down his account. Used twitter for a lot of good, touched a lot of special kids lives," one tweet said.
The next post expressed a different sentiment.
"@jparencibia9 YOU SUCK, no one likes u," said the tweet.
The timing of Arencibia's announcement was curious as it came on "Tweeting Tuesday," a Blue Jays promotion that gives followers the "opportunity to interact and communicate with the Blue Jays and their fans while watching the game."