02/04/2014 11:40 EST | Updated 04/06/2014 05:59 EDT

Michael Schmidt, Raw Milk Crusader, Takes Fight To Ontario's Top Court

TORONTO - A crusading farmer and his supporters are taking their self-professed right to drink unpasteurized milk, which the government calls a "significant public health risk," to Ontario's top court this week.

Raw milk farmer Michael Schmidt is arguing that by making the sale and distribution of unpasteurized milk illegal, the province is infringing on both his and his customers' basic freedoms.

The charter includes "the right of individuals to make decisions pertaining to their own bodies and their own health," Schmidt's lawyers write in arguments filed with Ontario's Appeal Court.

"The appellant's long-standing efforts to make unpasteurized milk available to non-farmers have been an important and fundamental life choice, having demonstrably profound psychological, economic, social and ethical consequences for him."

But the province doesn't see it that way. The law is meant to protect public health and infringes neither Schmidt's nor his customers' charter rights, the government argues.

"Consumers of unpasteurized milk do not have a liberty or security of the person 'right' to consume unpasteurized milk," government lawyers say in their written arguments.

"Like selling unpasteurized milk, drinking unpasteurized milk is not a fundamental life choice."

Schmidt has been locked in a decades-long battle with the province — including a hunger strike — over raw milk, which he believes is not only safe, but offers health benefits.

The farmer from the municipality of West Grey was originally charged in 1994, and later convicted, of selling or distributing unpasteurized milk.

It's not illegal for farmers to drink raw milk from their own cows, so a few years later Schmidt devised a so-called "cow share" program, through which his approximately 150 customers bought ownership in a cow or herd for $300, $600 or $1,200.

Schmidt believes that's legal, through a concept known as agistment. An agister cares for livestock owned by other people, who are the ones entitled to the animals' products, Schmidt's lawyers say.

The Crown argues that Schmidt is still the one with legal title to the cows, as there is no evidence his customers "enjoy the benefit" of ownership except for a right to consume the milk and cheese products for a fee.

A provincial court judge convicted Schmidt in 2011 of 13 charges under the Health Protection and Promotion Act and the Milk Act and fined him $9,150. That decision overturned an earlier one, in which another judge had acquitted Schmidt.

The case will now go before the Court of Appeal for Ontario, set for arguments Wednesday.

Schmidt's lawyers want to admit some fresh evidence — a new study they say shows that unpasteurized milk reduces kids' risk of developing asthma or allergies.

Experts testified for the Crown at Schmidt's trial that raw milk is a known source of food-borne illnesses to which pregnant women, elderly people and others with compromised immune systems are particularly vulnerable.

"The sale and distribution of unpasteurized milk is a significant public health risk," the Crown writes in its Appeal Court arguments.

"People who drink unpasteurized milk can transmit illness by person-to-person contact to persons who do not drink unpasteurized milk, even if they do not themselves become ill."

Two raw milk consumers told the court in Schmidt's earlier case that raw milk had a positive impact on their health, but the judge ruled that it had no bearing on Schmidt's charges.

"Even if one were to accept the testimony proffered in support of the purported health benefits...the right of these individuals to consume raw milk is not prohibited by law," the Ontario Court judge wrote.

"Given the expressed restriction on the sale and distribution of raw milk and raw milk products...(Schmidt) could not acquire a right to sell or distribute raw milk simply because others establish a right to acquire it."

The judge also considered, and ultimately dismissed, constitutional arguments similar to what Schmidt is arguing on appeal. The farmer argues that the legislation is too broad, suggesting that under such a broad interpretation of "distribution" it would be illegal for one co-owner of a cow to hand a glass of milk to another co-owner.

The Crown says that there is no evidence anyone has ever been prosecuted for such a scenario, and argues that Schmidt would be found guilty even under the most restrictive interpretation of the law.

"(Schmidt) and his customers may be willing to assume the risks posed to their own health, but the sale and distribution of unpasteurized milk pursuant to 'cow-share agreements' risks the health of others and the public at large," the Crown writes.

"This is precisely the type of harm that the legislation was enacted to address."

Also on HuffPost

  • Thaw Frozen Fish In A Milk Bath
    Thaw Frozen Fish In A Milk Bath
    Getty Images
    Frozen fish sometimes feels dry and gross. It can acquire a metallic, frozen flavor that isn't very much fun, and it's hard to cook with. If you thaw it in a milk bath, though, this natural moisturizer will bring hydration and flavor back to the fish, making it much more tasty.
  • Facial Mask
    Facial Mask
    Remember those hydrating properties? Buy some milk powder and mix it with just enough water to create a paste, and then gently massage it into your face. Let it sit for about ten minutes before rinsing. You can add essential oils (choose scents that are gentle on skin) and other ingredients like oatmeal or finely-ground walnut shells for exfoliation and additional benefits. You can also toss some of that milk powder into your bath to create a luxurious milk bath for yourself, if you want to feel a bit decadent and Roman. Essential oils go really well in milk baths if the scent is a little intense, but of course milk and honey is a classic combo. But make sure, even if it's the dead of a Minneapolis winter, that HVAC systems are working properly; if your bathroom isn't ventilated well, a luxurious bath one day can result in mold and mildew the next.
  • Polish
    Sour milk (or milk that's been soured with the addition of a splash of citrus or vinegar) can be used to soak silverware to remove tarnish; just soak, wash, rinse, and wipe dry. It also makes a good furniture polish. It'll deeply moisturize the wood at the same time the acidic component lifts up dirt and grime. Pretty cool, eh?
  • Repair Fine China
    Repair Fine China
    We know this sounds pretty out there, but give it a shot. If you have a piece of fine china with a hairline crack, put in a big pot with a heavy bottom and cover in milk. Bring the heat up until the milk boils, and turn it down low to simmer for 45 minutes. Proteins in the milk can bond with the clay in the cup, sealing the crack.
  • Soothe Itchy Skin Or Sunburn
    Soothe Itchy Skin Or Sunburn
    Remember that milk paste above? It works like a treat for irritated skin, too. If you're crawling out of your skin thanks to insect bites, definitely consider a nice milk paste; cold oatmeal can help relieve a case of the itchies too.
  • Industrial Strength Hand Cleaner
    Industrial Strength Hand Cleaner
    Your hands might be dirty from working on the car, spending some time in the garden, or another task. Mix oatmeal and milk to create a thick paste, and rub it all over your hands. The paste will lift the dirt while also moisturizing your hands, leaving them feeling soft, fresh, and clean. Better yet, the small cracks and fissures that tend to develop if you work with your hands a lot will be less likely to appear. Use it to make a special treat for the handyman in your life; nothing tears your hands up quite like working on household tasks every day.
  • Stain Removal
    Stain Removal
    Getty Images
    Soak clothes stained with ink in milk overnight (or dab at inkstains with milk), and rinse well before tossing in the wash (on cool). Milk can help lift ink stains, although your clothes may need a second rinse to ensure they don't end up smelling like sour milk later -- you don't want to trade one problem for another.
  • Quick Shine For Patent Leather
    Quick Shine For Patent Leather
    Getty Images
    Run a milk-soaked rag over patent leather items for a fresh new look. For a deeper shine, apply milk and let it dry before buffing your shoes, purses, and jackets. The milk can help seal cracks and scuffs to keep patent leather looking shiny and new.
  • Makeup Remover
    Makeup Remover
    Getty Images
    Powdered milk and warm water gently lift makeup off your face without leaving residue behind, and they moisturize your skin in the process. If you've been having problems with breakouts, you might want to consider this trick for getting your makeup all the way off.
  • Pill Aid
    Pill Aid
    Getty Images
    Horse pills are tough to swallow, but milk can make it easier. It coats your throat to smooth the way down, and even better, it protects the lining of your stomach. If you have medications that should be taken with food, a glass of milk can do in a pinch, although you shouldn't do that regularly.
  • Five Alarm Fire Recovery
    Five Alarm Fire Recovery
    Getty Images
    If you ate something a little bit too hot (like that salsa I had last night), milk can be your best friend. It binds with the capsaicin molecules to rapidly ease discomfort from eating hot foods. Whatever you do, don't drink water or beer, because capsaicin isn't water-soluble.