05/01/2014 11:21 EDT

Amal Alamuddin's Engagement Ring Is Similar To Angelina Jolie's

When news broke that George Clooney and girlfriend Amal Alamuddin were engaged, we didn't believe it. (He's the eternal bachelor! He's Leonardo DiCaprio Sr.!)

But then we saw the engagement ring and our disbelief quickly evaporated.

People magazine's latest cover features a close-up photo of the massive rock: an ethically-mined emerald-cut diamond boasting seven-plus carats flanked by two tapered baguettes set on a platinum band.

It's been pointed out that the sparkler, worth an estimated $650,000, is strikingly similar to Angelina Jolie's engagement ring, given to her by Brad Pitt.

Not only do the rings feature emerald-cut diamonds but both Clooney and Pitt helped design their respective bling. The one difference lies in the amount of diamonds: Angie's ring features several emerald-cut rocks, whereas Amal's features one.

According to reports, George cooked dinner before getting down on one knee and presenting Amal with the ring.

She's one lucky gal!

Compare that to Angelina Jolie's rock:

More celebrity engagement bling:

Photo gallery Celebrity Engagement Rings See Gallery