11/11/2014 02:34 EST | Updated 11/11/2014 02:59 EST

Taylor Swift Looks Totally Different On Wonderland Cover

What did you do with the real Taylor Swift, Wonderland magazine??

The "Out of the Woods" singer covers that mag's November/December 2014 issue looking completely different, thanks to the "natural" toned-down styling. (Get it, guys? When Taylor says "Shake it off" she means wear less makeup!)

In the pic, the barely recognizable hitmaker wears little makeup, sports Cara Delevingne-esque brows and has wet hair. To further enhance Tay's soft look, the "Shake It Off" songstress wears a white knit Hugh Boss sweater and no accessories.

The cover is a total style 180 for the blond beauty, who's known for her signature red lips, spot-on makeup and perfect coif.

Taylor also covers British Vogue's Nov. 2014 issue wearing a face full of makeup, thin eyebrows and slicked-back hair.

Although we love this cover, we have to admit that we're a bit confused. Who is the real Taylor Swift? Is she the glamour queen we're used to seeing all over New York City or is she the simple girl who just woke up like this? Will the real Taylor please stand up (and also give us the number of that hot guy in your "Blank Space" music video)?

Also on HuffPost

Photo gallery Taylor Swift See Gallery