11/18/2016 12:56 EST

Alberta vs. Texas: Study Shows Why Similar Economies Face Opposite Fiscal Realities

Similar economies, opposite fiscal realities.

Alberta and Texas – both energy-rich jurisdictions, both coming off economic booms due to falling oil prices, both feeling the pinch.

However, a new study from the Fraser Institute suggests that mismanagement and government spending has left Alberta in a worse slump than the Longhorn State.

"When you look at the fiscal situation in the two places, the story is quite different," Ben Eisen, co-author of One Energy Boom, Two Approaches: Fiscal Restraint Has Left Texas in Better Shape than Alberta, told the Edmonton Journal.

"Texas is right now in much better fiscal condition than Alberta."

According to their findings, here's why Texas comes out on top:

  • Ascent Xmedia via Getty Images
    Government spending per person in Alberta increased by 49 per cent between 2004-2014. In Texas, it only increased by 37.3 per cent.
  • Hero Images via Getty Images
    In 2004/05, Alberta spent 68.4 per cent more per person than Texas.
  • Ascent Xmedia via Getty Images
    By 2013/14, Alberta was spending 82.8 per cent more per person than Texas.
  • NurPhoto via Getty Images
    "The spending increases (in Alberta) were faster than the rate of inflation plus population, faster than the rate of economic growth and that’s what created the problem," Eisen told the Financial Post.
  • Topher Seguin / Reuters
    The absence of disciplined spending left the province with a string of budget deficits, leading to "significant erosion in its financial position," says the study.
    From 2009-2013, Texas ran surpluses.
  • Todd Korol / Reuters
    From 2009-2013, Alberta ran deficits.
  • Bloomberg via Getty Images
    In 2006/07, Alberta held net assets representing 12.4 per cent of provincial GDP. By 2013/14, those assets had declined to 2.9 per cent.
  • Allan Baxter via Getty Images
    By contrast, Texas saw very little change in its asset position in this period.
  • The Fraser Institute
    Oil and gas activity contributes 27.4 per cent of Alberta’s total GDP, while it only contributes to 12.3 per cent of Texas’s GDP – showing more diversity in Texas's economy.