10/17/2017 04:51 EDT | Updated 10/17/2017 13:02 EDT

Ariana Grande’s 2014 Album Cover Is Your New Favorite Conspiracy Theory

"My Everything" gets a closer look.

Is she really sitting on that stool? 

Ariana Grande’s 2014 album “My Everything” is getting attention on Twitter this week after BuzzFeed’s Jesse McLaren tried to re-create her pose and found it difficult ... perhaps even impossible: 

The discussion gained steam when it was retweeted by Grande herself:  

That sparked comments, theories, stool truthers and even multiple attempts to re-create the cover, with hilariously mixed results: 

So was it a photo editing job? 

Someone tweeted other images from the shoot that appeared to confirm that Grande, indeed, was seated on the stool. 

Ariana Grande's Style Evolution