07/31/2014 05:35 EDT | Updated 09/30/2014 05:59 EDT

The Habs and the Have-Nots: Why Subban Should Leave Canada

Mike Stobe via Getty Images
UNIONDALE, NY - DECEMBER 14: P.K. Subban #76 of the Montreal Canadiens skates against the New York Islanders at Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum on December 14, 2013 in Uniondale, New York. The Canadiens defeated the Islanders 1-0 in overtime. (Photo by Mike Stobe/NHLI via Getty Images)

There was a time when Montrealers could overlook superficial and linguistic differences to rally around a groundbreaking sporting prodigy. Despite being black, anglophone and a foreigner, Jackie Robinson was, by all accounts, welcomed in Canada's then-largest city in 1946. Robinson played a single season with the Brooklyn Dodgers' farm team in La Métropole. He led The Montreal Royals to the Little World Series. More importantly, Robinson proved that there could be a willing white audience for a racially integrated baseball team. It was a stepping stone towards the MLB, where Robinson would break the colour line. The first African-American MLB player faced angry, intolerant crowds and colleagues alike.

But not in Canada.

In fact, it was quite the opposite. "I experienced no racism here. [...] The French-Canadian people welcomed us with open arms," said Robinson.

It's been documented that the Montreal fans would pay close attention to any ear-to-the-ground or press reports of racism or mistreatment Robinson and the Royals received when playing on the road. Fans of the Royals would voice their displeasure when that city's team visited Delorimier Stadium. [source: CBC]

That was then. This is now.

There's another black, anglophone sports prodigy in Montreal these days. P.K. Subban has electrified audiences, opened up a new stream of hockey fans, and brought the Montreal Canadians to contention in the playoffs.

But the Habs aren't bending over backwards to sign a Norris-trophy alum. In a familiar refrain, the Subbanator has the talent on which a winning team can be built for years to come, but, as Quebec sport writer Jeremy Filosa put it in 2013, there's a physical trait that can't be overlooked:

"Voilà que le Tricolore se retrouve aujourd'hui avec, dans ses rangs, peut-être le meilleur défenseur de la planète et il est noir. Pas un peu noir, il est très noir..."
Liberal translation:
"Now the Habs find themselves with, in their ranks, perhaps the best defenceman on the planet and he is black. Not just a little bit black, he is very dark-skinned black..."

And PK's pigmentation has drawn the ire of many, though most, like Don Cherry, are apt at masking their racial anxiety behind Tea Party-like euphemisms and innuendo.

PK Subban has been chided and disrespected throughout his professional career: From the blackface-donning fans, to bigotdismissive coaches, and even teammates who have called him out in public. The graceful player has suffered in silence, thus co-opting the NHL's steadfast refusal to take any meaningful action on the league's interminable racial inquietude.

Broadcaster and Hockey Night In Canada co-host Kevin Weekes took to Twitter to express his frustration on Subban's dragging contract negotiations.

Weekes, who was a professional hockey player and shares Subban's Caribbean extraction, believes there is trickery behind the scenes.


Montreal is not the place where an ebony player like Subban can thrive. In a town where blackface is still considered acceptable - even on the public broadcaster's airwaves, a dark-skinned prodigy in the "white man's game" just can't get the respect nor the remuneration he's earned.


Subban has the pedigree, the poise and the personality to be a transcending figure à la Michael Jordan. He speaks proper English. He comes from a picture-perfect traditional family. He's never been in trouble with the law. A marketing the U.S.A. If the NHL played its cards right, Subban's forthcoming success could cement hockey's popularity among its least-represented groups and shape a new generation of diverse players and fans.


The social experiment of a hockey prodigy with dark chocolate skin in Canada has lasted long enough. Montreal is no longer the bastion of racial progress it once was. PK Subban should thank the Habs for the stepping stone years and move on to more culturally mature and inclusive locales.

Los Angeles was the first city to welcome a black NFL player in 1946. California's franchises have taken pride in seeking out talent from non-traditional sources, shoring up support from both the Asians and Latino communities. New York hosted the first black NBA player in the 50s and the city continues to set the trend for the rest of the nation.

Both U.S. coasts would serve as ideal launch pads for the second phase of Subban's career. They can promise something Canada can't -- unencumbered race-transcending support.


Subban 'Black Jersey' Tweets