06/27/2014 06:24 EDT | Updated 08/27/2014 05:59 EDT

How Taxes Could Affect the Leafs and Senators Next Season


July 1 is an important day for Canadians as they celebrate the country's founding. It's also the first day that NHL teams can sign free agents for the upcoming season. Many will be watching to see if their favourite teams land a superstar.

There's a lot of speculation that the Ottawa Senators and Toronto Maple Leafs will be active this free agent season. Both teams failed to make the playoffs last year and will likely pursue new players to get them back into contention.

But taxes can be a roadblock to attracting new talent. For these two Ontario-based teams, statutory personal income tax rates are now among the highest in North America. And if the re-elected Wynne government retables its May budget on July 2, upper earners including professional athletes will face even higher personal taxes.

NHL players in free agency can choose which teams they want to play on. Of course, a number of factors matter for where free agents such as Jarome Iginla and Martin Brodeur ultimately end up. This includes things like whether a team is a Stanley Cup contender, the calibre of the coach, and a city's climate and amenities.

But one important consideration is a jurisdiction's personal income tax system. After all, high personal tax rates result in lower after-tax income so players who earn the same salaries but play for different teams will have different after-tax income. A Maple Leafs player living in Ontario will keep much less income after tax than a Dallas Stars player living in Texas.

We shouldn't be surprised that taxes play a role in these decisions. Athletes are generally highly-skilled, young, and mobile.

And research confirms the importance of taxes. Consider a 2013 study published in the prestigious American Economic Review journal that looked at the extent to which tax rates in Europe are associated with the movement of soccer players. The study found that tax rates significantly affected the decisions of soccer players about which to team to play for. Similarly, a 2011 study examined the relationship between tax rates and the quality of basketball players that NBA teams attract and found teams in states with lower income tax rates signed more skilled players.

Unfortunately, Ontario-based hockey teams do not fare well with respect to competitive tax rates. Leaving aside other types of taxes and certain tax deductions and provisions (including so-called "jock taxes" whereby certain U.S. states impose taxes on visiting athletes), the fact is players for the Leafs and Senators face high statutory personal tax rates.

Using the minimum league salary of $550,000 as the benchmark, the top income tax rates in 2014 among the provinces with NHL franchises vary from 10 per cent in Alberta to 20.53 per cent and 20.97 per cent in Ontario and Quebec, respectively. After accounting for the top federal personal income tax rate, players on the Maple Leafs and Senators could be paying marginal rates as high as 49.53 per cent of their income.

In comparison, players on American teams face lower combined federal and state tax rates at this income level (with the exception of the three California-based teams). And if we account for the marked difference in income thresholds at which these tax rates apply (the top federal rate in Canada applies to income above $136,270 versus $406,750 in the U.S.), Ontario-based teams are at an even bigger competitive disadvantage.

Ultimately, this means that teams in uncompetitive tax jurisdictions like Toronto and Ottawa will have a more difficult time attracting NHL free agents. But these challenges are not unique to professional hockey players. Ontario's high personal taxes also erect roadblocks to attracting and retaining other skilled workers such as entrepreneurs, doctors, and engineers.

The NHL's free agency frenzy is a good reminder of the potential consequences of uncompetitive taxes. High taxes not only make it difficult to attract top NHL talent to Toronto and Ottawa, they also create disincentives for businesses and workers to move to and invest in Ontario. That's simply not a way to win a Stanley Cup or to turn the province's economy around.


  • 14) The Basic Beard: André Roy
    Getty Images
    André Roy's team, the Tampa Bay Lightning, took home the Stanley Cup when Roy sported this well-manicured playoff beard in 2004.

    Pros: even distribution, nice color, above-average grooming
    Cons: lack of imagination, and...above-average grooming
    Final Score: a solid C
  • 13) The #TeamEmo Beard: The Phoenix Coyotes
    Getty Images
    The Coyotes' 2012 line-up featured several of the Phoenix Coyotes sporting hip, patchy scruff during their journey to the Stanley Cup championship.

    Pros: huge props for team effort
    Cons: notable lack of aggressive, unruly growth
    Score: C+
  • 12) The Classic Beard: Patrick Maroon
    Anaheim Ducks
    2014 has seen its share of playoff beards too. This one from the Anaheim Ducks' Forward Patrick Maroon is straightforward, but robust.

    Pros: the perfect beard for the well-groomed guy
    Cons: not ambitious enough for a dude with some serious hair-growing potential
    Score: B-
  • 11) The Redbeard Beard: Raffi Torres
    Vancouver Canucks
    Raphael "Raffi" Torres, who played for the Vancouver Canucks at the time, grew this ruby masterpiece for the 2011 playoffs against the Boston Bruins.

    Pros: striking color to scare off predators
    Cons: missed growth opportunity (i.e., could be longer)
    Score: B-
  • 10) The Two-Tone Beard: Jake Voráček
    Philadelphia Flyers
    Czech Jake Voráček of the Philadelphia Flyers has this gnarly beard in the works for his team's current run at the championship.

    Pros: inexplicable blonde-black combo, impressive handlebar mustache situation
    Cons: sideburns noticeably absent and/or undefined
    Score: B
  • 9) The Dapper Gentleman's Beard: Chris Higgins
    Vancouver Canucks
    Chris Higgins grew this impressively full beard during the 2011 playoffs. His Vancouver Canucks made it to the finals that season, but lost to the Boston Bruins four games to three.

    Pros: the kind of beard that makes one stop and think, "damn, that's a manly beard."
    Cons: distracting, untrimmed mustache hairs
    Score: B
  • 8) The Mood-Appropriate Beard: Jordie Benn
    Dallas Stars
    Jordie Benn of the Dallas Stars is also rocking a pretty mean beard for this year's playoffs.

    Pros: excellent facial expression/facial hair harmony
    Cons: none really, but we've seen better
    Score: B
  • 7) The Mid-Length Beard: Ville Leino
    Philadelphia Flyers
    Finnish player Ville Leino grew this beard out for the 2010 playoffs with the Flyers. He currently plays for the Buffalo Sabres.

    Pros: perfect juxtaposition of untamed length and well-groomed shaping
    Cons: holding back a bit on the sides
    Score: B
  • 6) The Orange Extravaganza Beard: Claude Giroux
    Philadelphia Flyers
    This might as well be the same picture as the previous bearded Flyer, but Center Claude Giroux of the Philadelphia Flyers grew this fiery gem for the 2010 playoffs. His team advanced to the Finals that season, but were defeated by the Chicago Blackhawks.

    Pros: coloring pairs perfectly with the Flyers uniform (sorry, Ville)
    Cons: notable gap between mustache and chin beard
    Score: B+
  • 5) The Neck Beard: Daniel Winnik
    Anaheim Ducks
    Daniel Winnik of the Anaheim Ducks is growing out this beard for the current playoffs.

    Pros: aggressive neck beard, yet still somehow real-life appropriate
    Cons: perhaps a little too real-life appropriate
    Score: B+
  • 4) The Super Neck Beard: Radko Gudas
    Getty Images
    Here's the beard that Radko Gudas grew for this season's playoffs. His team, the Tampa Bay Lightning, was unfortunately knocked out during the first round by the Montreal Canadiens in late April.

    Pros: basically sets a new standard for all of mankind's future neck beard attempts
    Cons: didn't fulfill expectations
    Score: B+
  • 3) The No-Boundaries Beard: Scott Hartnell
    Philadelphia Flyers
    Continuing the Flyers' domination of the playoff beard lineup, the steely-eyed Scott Hartnell of the Philadelphia Flyers grew this wild beauty for the 2010 playoffs.

    Pros: thinks outside the box (and face)
    Cons: too much of a good thing?
    Score: A
  • 2) The Gap-Happy Beard: Ken Daneyko
    New Jersey Devils
    Ken Deneyko, who spent his entire career with the New Jersey Devils, rocks a toothless grin and shaggy beard in this photo after his team won the 2003 Stanley Cup.

    Pros: epic toothlessness makes this glorious masterpiece even more complete
    Cons: objectively, very patchy
    Score: A
  • 1) The Ultimate Playoff Beard: Mike Commodore
    Carolina Hurricanes
    Mike Commodore of the Carolina Hurricanes grew out this beard for his team's successful Stanley Cup journey. The Canes came out on top of the league in 2006.

    Pros: nails the playoff beard hat trick -- loud color, unruly shape and all-over shag. Plus, the bathrobe brings the Dude aesthetic to life in a truly delightful way.
    Cons: absolutely none
    Score: A+
  • Bonus: François Beauchemin's Beard Progression
    Anaheim Ducks
    Here's a real treat. Check out how Duck player François Beauchemin's beard has come in. It's looking pretty strong!