CBC Cuts: 10 Per Cent Budget Reduction Sought By Tories Under Heritage Minister James Moore

Cbc Budget Cuts 10 Per Cent James Moore

First Posted: 09/29/11 07:45 AM ET Updated: 09/29/11 09:11 AM ET

Heritage Minister James Moore wants to slash CBC’s budget by 10 per cent, The Huffington Post has learned.

Although a government decision is far from complete, Moore has discussed his wish to see the public broadcaster’s $1.1-billion allocation cut by ten per cent, sources said. Moore had earlier this summer suggested the CBC could face a cut of "at least 5 per cent."

According to Ian Morrison, the spokesman for Friends of Canadian Broadcasting, that would be a devastating blow to the CBC.

“Ten per cent would have just huge consequences. It would result in station closures,” said Morrison, who warned that small stations serving rural areas would be particularly vulnerable.

Cuts to the CBC would flow from the Conservatives’ strategic and operation review process, a plan to find $4-billion in savings in order to balance the books by 2014-2015.

The federal government has instructed all departments, agencies and crown corporations that receive federal money to come up with two separate proposals on how they could slash their budgets by five per cent and 10 per cent.

Cabinet hasn’t approved any CBC reductions, sources said. In fact, it appears the public broadcaster hasn’t yet submitted its proposal on how it would handle budget reductions.

“The process is unfolding. We are working (on it),” CBC spokesman Marco Dubé told HuffPost.

The public broadcaster doesn't expect to find out how much it will have to cut until the next federal budget, likely in March, Dubé said.

Moore assured reporters Wednesday that the government won't eliminate the CBC's public subsidy, but he repeated comments he made in the Commons, saying the public broadcaster won't be spared from government-wide spending cuts.

“Obviously, I’m not going to talk about Budget 2012… In the campaign, we said, we’re going to balance the budget and we’re going to do so responsibly. We’re going to keep our word and the CBC has to be part of that,” he said.

The minister added: “We’re not interested in privatizing the CBC.”

The Conservative government may not want to eliminate public financing completely, but some Tory backbenchers are suggesting that’s precisely what they would like to see.

Conservative MPs on the Heritage Committee voted against an NDP motion this week that called for a study of the impacts of anticipated cuts to the CBC/Radio-Canada.

Although the meeting was held in-camera, numerous sources said the government majority voted down a request to hear testimony from witnesses on the effects of the cuts and the crown corporation’s ability to fulfill its mandate.

CBC supporters view it as the latest attack against the crown corporation.

The NDP’s heritage critic Tyrone Benskin refused to discuss his motion but he told HuffPost the CBC had already suffered enough cuts.

“If you want this economy to work, you need to get people working. Cutting the CBC is going to cut jobs,” he said.

The Tories are trying to pave the way for more drastic cuts by undermining the ability of the CBC to provide quality programming, Benskin said.

“It will… strengthen the call to say that CBC is wasting money because CBC is not doing their job. It’s almost like a two-pronged attack where you cut the legs out from someone and say, ‘well walk faster,’” Benskin said.

On Tuesday, the Tory-majority on the Commons' access to information, privacy and ethics committee also voted to study the use of taxpayers' money in funding CBC's legal battle with the Information Commissioner, another body paid for by the public purse. The Tories want to call CBC's competitors, including Sun Media journalists, to testify about the public broadcaster's refusal to turn over documents they have requested under the access to information law.


Quick Poll

Public funding of the CBC:

Should be cut outright

Should be preserved, but 10% cut is reasonable

Should be preserved, but 5% cut is reasonable

Should be left alone

Should be increased

The Conservative Party has often used the public financing of the CBC as a wedge issue, picking fights over the broadcaster’s alleged left wing bias and questioning whether taxpayers should be forced to dish out more than a $1-billion a year to the crown corporation.

The Globe and Mail reported last week that Conservative Senator Irving Gerstein had recently sent a ‘“National Critical Issues Survey’ to supporters asking whether CBC was “good value” for money.

A number of Tory backbench MPs are also quizzing constituents on the funding of the CBC or asking them to sign petitions.

Saskatchewan MP Brad Trost wants his supporters to sign a petition to defund the CBC.

Ed Holder, the MP for London West, released Wednesday the results of an unscientific survey he’d advertised in his weekly newsletter.

Although Holder reported approximately 66 per cent of his respondents wanted to maintain or increase funding for CBC Radio, with only 35 per cent wanting to reduce or eliminate funding, he told HuffPost, he believes the result were “skewed a lot” because a pro-CBC group promoted the poll to its membership.

Before the large spike in votes, Holder said the poll results were more in line with a survey last week on CBC television which suggested 38 per cent wanted of respondents wanted funding maintained or increased, 21 per cent wanted funding reduced, and 41 per cent wanted CBC TV funding eliminated outright.

"CBC radio is certainly more popular than CBC television," Holder added.


Ontario Conservative MP Jay Aspin said CBC funding is not an issue in his riding but his constituents want to see fiscal responsibility.

“Everything is under review, so certainly the CBC is no exception,” he said.

But a few other MPs suggested they have personal reasons to support a viable public broadcaster.

“Cut? I like watching it. Where would I watch my hockey?,” said Joe Preston, the Tory MP for Elgin—Middlesex—London.

The CBC has inked a deal with the NHL to broadcast Hockey Night in Canada until 2014.

Manitoba Conservative MP James Bezan told HuffPost his sister works at CBC radio in Winnipeg.

Asked if he’d like to see the CBC cut, Bezan responded: “I love my sister.”

althia.raj@huffingtonpost.com

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

Heritage Minister James Moore wants to slash CBC’s budget by 10 per cent, The Huffington Post has learned. Although a government decision is far from complete, Moore has discussed his wish to see...
Heritage Minister James Moore wants to slash CBC’s budget by 10 per cent, The Huffington Post has learned. Although a government decision is far from complete, Moore has discussed his wish to see...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 352
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
photo
All Seeing Guy
Moooooooooooorrrrrrreeee
06:19 PM on 10/04/2011
Just sell off the broadcast rights to Leaf games. Toronto tories will be rushing the money back.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DidiM
Human 'being'
10:33 AM on 10/03/2011
We expect Conservatives to KEEP THEIR WORD: Minister James Moore who, on May 3rd, the morning after the general election said: "We believe in the national public broadcaster. We have said that we will maintain or increase support for the CBC. That is our platform and we have said that before and we will commit to that".
The CBC belongs to the People Of Canada and NO MP has the 'Legal Right to TOUCH Our Property'. Their JOB is to Keep election Promises and to make sure Our Money is being Spent where it should be. THAT has been the problem with CBC Exec's - with the CRTC's blessing for DECADES. Instead of CBC honoring its "Mandate" to 'Protect & Promote Minority Stations' - They have illegally ERASED ALL ENGLISH STATIONS & JOBS IN MONTREAL - while building More French Stations in Quebeck and of course Across the Country. This Abuse is what has to be investigated & corrected. Make the Books & Actions Public and DO NOT TOUCH OUR CBC.
08:29 AM on 10/01/2011
I guess the plan is to "starve the beast" by budget cuts until the CBC replaces all that pesky investigative journalism with "Beachcomber" reruns. Then people will HAVE to turn to SUN for their news, right? And the snippy little Ms Erickson? Canada's sweetheart.
03:32 PM on 09/30/2011
Scubaguy1, you obviously live in a city where internet and cable are readily available and obviously can afford to pay for same. This is not so for all Canadians. Moreover, the portability of CBC radio and the investigative reporting of CBC television distinguish this asset.

You also do not seem to appreciate the fact that you and I own the CBC in the same way that we own the highways. There is a distinct advantage to ownership that you ignore. Your argument must rest on some rationale rather than just ideology like that of the Conservatives.

When public property is put into private hands, we all lose an asset and become subservient to that private enterprise. If you want to save money, why not petition for a removal of subsidies to private corporations. Why should our tax dollar go to subsidize local newspapers? No, my friend, the CBC is a beacon of enlightenment in our country, always has been and always will be. If you want the flip side of enlightenment try FOX.
04:01 PM on 09/30/2011
I understand your point and believe the CBC should be funded for remote communities where private businesses will not go. But that's where it ends for me. I stand on the rationale I provided earlier that in this day and age we do not need to fund the CBC to the current level we do.

Yes canadians own the CBC assets, but we also burn through $1B a year. Like Petro Canada, when a state entity is privatized it returns to its core competencies and serves them well or is take over by a business that can.

Why are we in the broadcasting business at the tune of $1B a year, so George Strom can throw a lavish party at the most expensive hotel in Toronto. How does that help people in remote communities. Why do you think the CBC is fighting the freedom for information requests from the government that funds it? Hhhmm I wonder.

On a final note not all private entertainment is bad, how about Discovery, National Geographic, History, etc. FOX is not the only game in town and neither is the CBC.
06:14 AM on 10/01/2011
I empathize with your position regarding cost. For example, I believe that taxpayer funding of stadiums is wrong. If hockey or football teams want a venue, they should build it themselves. In addition, I was disappointed that Clark took the fee out of park use. Parks should be on a payer use system. Why should the taxpayer be stuck with the bill. This may encourage more private parks. Infact, use of public lakes should also carry a charge. There is no reason why English Bay should have meters for the sunbathers.

There are other areas that could be privatized such as Driver Licensing and Food Safety Inspection. Street parking should also be sold of to the private sector who would probably be much more dilligent in monitoring the meters. Having tolls on bridges has been a great stimulus in having bridges built and we should consider selling off the many bridges in Metro Vancouver and, perhaps, even in BC. That Kelowna bridge should not be free. The days of a free ride on taxpayer dollar is over. Think of the jobs created for toll collectors. You've convinced me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DidiM
Human 'being'
10:39 AM on 10/03/2011
We don't or shouldn't 'burn down the house - because the 'Caretaker is neglecting it'. We REPLACE the incompetent Caretaker - with one who IS competent and who keeps all information accessible to the public! It's the Exec's and the CRTC that have been - violating and abusing their mandates - that are the Problem and Not Our CBC!
09:05 AM on 09/30/2011
One billion dollar funding budget from the government and running Wheel of Fortune and Jeporady every night......what's with that????
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gbourcier
06:43 AM on 09/30/2011
So the Tories, or should I say we the Canadian tax payers, are giving a consulting company 90 thousand a day to tell them how to save money. If they told those consultants to stay home for 11 days, that would equal 10% of the CBC's budget. Wheather you are for or against government funding of the CBC, keep in mind that they employ a lot of people. Far more then this consulting firm I'm sure.
Just imagine the money we could save if they could get Peter MacKay to stop flying around in military aircraft.
At this time, I would like to thank the 35% of you out there who voted for these buffoons. How can the rest of us ever repay you?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DidiM
Human 'being'
10:48 AM on 10/03/2011
You can repay us - by taking a good long look at the LIBERAL'S Hiring the CBC Buffoons - who've been mismanaging and VIOLATING their Mandate for the lat 30 years!! That's how! And toss in the Liberal Created CRTC - that has us the public - having to go on bent knees - TO OTTAWA - to be given 5 freaking minutes to speak!! And they and only they - decide whose presentation merits discussion!!! The only thing wrong with our CBC & CRTC - are the yahoos managing them!!
04:20 AM on 09/30/2011
For $3 a month we get one of the finest public broadcasters in the world. The CBC is a uniting force in Canada reaching into both rural and urban communities. The high standard they set challenges the private sector broadcasters who tend to focus on the revenue side rather than the supply side.

Criticism such as that proffered by the Conservative Towes speaks to the penance for right wingers to control everything in their favour since right wing bias is no bias at all at least according to the current regime.

Enamoured with Fox sound-alike Adler Online, the righties exude a hatred and at times an enviousness for anything public, preferring the hegemony of the corporate state. They would prefer to be governed by Coca Cola or Esso than submit to a cooperative endeavour. Any shared enterprise is socialism and any worker's cry is seen as Marxist. In their exuberance for corporate dominance they aim their slings and arrows at whatever bears the badge of humankind and in that target is set the vibrant public institution of the CBC.
01:41 PM on 09/30/2011
It's time to privatize the CBC, their mandate of linking the country was served early in their mandate. With the internet, satelite and cable offerings the CBC's mandate does not need to be funded to the same extent. Privatize and let them flourish, on their own dime. Lets allocate the $1B a year to a more worthy cause.
02:21 AM on 09/30/2011
I lived for 7 years on the Canadian Border. As a US citizen I enjoy NPR, but I was blown away by the depth and professionalism of the news and information available from CBC. I still "tune in" online and through Huff Post. It is the absolute best option for truth that I have seen in the free world...without sponsorship! Thank you, and I'll donate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DidiM
Human 'being'
10:50 AM on 10/03/2011
FF !!!
12:56 AM on 09/30/2011
A quick calculation. It appears the CBC can put an hour of TV on air across Canada for $114155. That is all the costs according to their total budget.
A half hour of Two and a Half Men costs about 3 million dollars just to make, not including broadcasting it all over the country.
Of course Two and a Half Men makes a lot of profit. So the cost is negative. But CBC still seems to be doing pretty darn well with costs.
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
01:25 AM on 09/30/2011
Why is the government in the business of producing or disseminating pop culture entertainment at all?
01:40 AM on 09/30/2011
Is that all you see on CBC? There is much more. If pop culture is all you desire to see on television, then the U.S. stuff might be of more value to you. Though the CBC does do a good job of fictional stuff too.
However, the nonfictional and important material that the CBC produces would be lost entirely if it was pure profit driven. Yes we get pretty good Canadian news coverage from other Canadian for profit stations, but CBC usually goes more in depth and also covers less profitable (if it bleeds, it leads) topics. Documentary length news and actual documentaries are also great.
01:41 AM on 09/30/2011
And there is CBC radio as well. Some of the best real variety of everything you can find on the airwaves.
01:33 AM on 09/30/2011
CTVglobemedia 2009 earned profit of $214 million on revenues of $2.2 billion, 9.7 per cent. CTV spent 11 times more buying foreign shows than they did buying Canadian. So it costs CTV about $226712 to put on an hour of TV, that is mostly just bought from other ( U.S.) stations.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GoldDustDreams
12:43 AM on 09/30/2011
Jet fuel doesn't pay for itself! They've gotta cut from something in order to continue flying around the world in overpriced planes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DidiM
Human 'being'
10:56 AM on 10/03/2011
Minister James Moore who, on May 3rd, the morning after the general election said: "We believe in the national public broadcaster. We have said that we will maintain or increase support for the CBC. That is our platform and we have said that before and we will commit to that". Our Politicians MUST KEEP THEIR PROMISES - Period. Those Conservative MP's who decided they don't like or want the CBC should be removed from their positions for violating their 'limited powers' - in particular for creating havoc and fear of job losses for CBC employees! Who do they think they are to 'mess with our property - because they personally don't like it' ?? Who do they think they are?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:58 PM on 09/29/2011
CBC doesn't have a political agenda, which means it's not a Conservative outlet, which means to Conservatives the CBC is AGAINST them and should be treated like everything else "against them", punished, slandered, defunded till it no longer works, then scrapped.

Conservatives: The Persecution Complex Party - If you're not with us, how long have you been a Commie and/or in Al Qaeda?
09:01 AM on 09/30/2011
CBC practises "bias by omission".

If they don't acknowledge certain realities...they don't exist... small business provides up to 80% of all non-government jobs. I'm talking about SMALL business, NOT the large corporations that the CBC always uses when it discusses business, and how it factors into Canadian life. THAT's "bias by omission".

CBC's business and economic "experts" are always academics... God forbid they should invite the real Fred or Sally small-business-person on for their opinions.

I vote towards the left, by the way.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lulex
11:22 PM on 09/29/2011
It's PUBLIC radio folks. CBC is OUR VOICE. In this day of hype we need to protect these institutions like gold. Don't let Harper or anyone else encroach upon the CBC. It is ours to protect.
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
01:27 AM on 09/30/2011
You like it?
You pay for it.
The government doesn't need to be in the entertainment business.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles Allen
06:01 AM on 09/30/2011
Why do you get to say what the governments business is and what it isn't?
10:58 PM on 09/29/2011
I am very sorry see that some try to use and hijack Huffingtonpost.Canada to advance their right wing agenda ... Fortunately, it's kind of useless as your electorate does not read Huffingtonpost blog.

You maybe try to use Ann Coulter and Dick Cheney to promote your anti-progressive agenda here and we will show them, again and again, that they are not desirable people in this country... For me, if Canada goes further in this direction, I will vote for the secession of Quebec....as many others.

Our "Northern Tea Partiers" want to take over what used to be a very good website for progressive bloggers in USA. As their American counterparts so loudly shout in 2008 : " I want my country back ! " i.e. the progressive and respected Canada we used to know and love.
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
01:27 AM on 09/30/2011
Hey, I'll vote for quebec to go right now.
The sooner the better.
10:54 PM on 09/29/2011
5% of $1 Billion = $50,000,000 ....the exact amount of our taxes that our corrupt Cabinet Minister stuffed into his Riding undercover of the G20 Fiasco.Figures don't lie....liars figure.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:34 PM on 09/29/2011
CBC has no friends with the other medias having no subsidies as large. Yet the CBC covered the last election like an echo-chamber to the pollsters. Just like the private media outlets, who stood to gain a nice corporate tax cut if the cons won. Perhaps CBC would report more substance and speculate less at the next election--- if they are still around. Welcome to all corporate news! Conservative dream come through.