Remembrance Day Poppies: What Are The Rules To Honour Vets?

The Huffington Post Canada     First Posted: 11/11/11 07:57 AM ET   Updated: 11/11/11 11:55 AM ET

The red poppies dotting Canadians' lapels since the beginning of November are a familiar and respectful sight nationwide. But that doesn't mean that they don't inspire their fair share of controversy. How long do you wear them? Should the centres be green or black? And how the heck can you keep from losing it ten minutes after you fasten it to your coat?

The Royal Canadian Legion, who runs the Poppy Campaign each year, has answers for at least one of these queries.

"There is no set period when the Poppy should be worn," states the organization's website. "In fact, a person may wear a Poppy at any time. Traditionally, however, the Poppy is worn during the Remembrance period, which is from the last Friday in October to the end of the day on 11 November." They also recommend wearing the poppy at other events honouring veterans.

The Legion also advises that the poppy is a sacred symbol of Remembrance, and should not be "defaced" in any way. That apparently includes using another pin -- say, a safety pin instead of the given straight pin -- to attach it to your lapel. Even using a Canadian flag as a fastener is not encouraged.

Story continues below slideshow
We've noticed some innovative ways to honour Remembrance Day with the poppy around the world. If you've seen one near you, let us know below.

Poppy Man
1  of  9
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 
In the UK, the Royal British Legion runs a poppy campaign the likes of which Canadians cannot even imagine, complete with the mascot -- Poppy Man -- seen here at Trafalgar Square in 2009.
RATE IT!   |  
VOTE
MEH
GREAT
CURRENT TOP 5 PICK YOUR OWN TOP 5
USERS WHO VOTED
NEW! CREATE YOUR OWN SLIDESHOW

The way in which you dispose of your poppy is "left to the discretion of the individual," according to the Legion, though they deem placing it at the base of a war memorial or cenotaph an appropriate spot to leave it. Reused poppies from year to year are a definite no-no.

There are also some strict guidelines around the poppy's image that are enforced by the Legion, which have brought forth some legal issues since it was first established as an official symbol in 1921. Last year, a campaign for white poppies in Prince Edward Island and Ontario, meant to symbolize peaceful conflict resolution, was given cease and desist orders to halt distribution. While Legion spokesperson Bob Butt said it was a trademark issue, others saw it as a political stance.

"The people who are distributing these poppies are normally people who have never spent a day in the service of their country in their lives. To denigrate a symbol of the remembrance of people who died for this country certainly is emotional." --Jim Ross, president of the Legion's P.E.I. provincial command, to CBC News

Around the same time, students from the Nova Scotia College of Art and Design had set out to create a more eco-friendly, longer lasting poppy for remembrance all year round. The handmade pins, which look almost identical to the Legion's wares, were crafted from paper bearing poppy seeds, so they could be planted once the pin became unwearable. They also included a piece of cardboard with John McCrae's "In Flanders Fields" inscribed upon it, the poem that was the original inspiration for the symbol. While the Legion didn't sanction this new option, they did appear open to discussing the design with the students.

And as far as that green or black centre goes, either is acceptable in terms of the trademark -- though the black is more true to life, and perhaps more appropriate for this day of respect and mourning.

Quick Poll

What do you do with your poppy after Remembrance Day?

Drop it at a cenotaph

Keep it in a drawer

Throw it out

I usually lose it by November 11

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA LIVING

The red poppies dotting Canadians' lapels since the beginning of November are a familiar and respectful sight nationwide. But that doesn't mean that they don't inspire their fair share of controversy.
The red poppies dotting Canadians' lapels since the beginning of November are a familiar and respectful sight nationwide. But that doesn't mean that they don't inspire their fair share of controversy.
 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nanaofmysky
Adopt from a rescue or shelter.
07:29 PM on 11/11/2011
I buy a poppy every year and wear it proudly. Knowing the young men and woman sacrifiside so much for our country. However I only wear it for 2 days before and remove it at the end of the 11th. I do not know why we can not use a Canadian or American flag to secure it. I also think the idea of seeds and planting them a good idea. This would show rememberance all year long.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CommonWealth-SinglePayer
Walk on the Right, VOTE on the LEFT
06:24 PM on 11/11/2011
Canadians should be wary of excessive patriotism. An older friend of mine, who's father was in both Wars, said his father only wore a poppy the day before Remembrance Day and during it and that was it. Current politicians and corporations can also over use the true feelings we all have for Veterans and exploit that for sales and votes. My great uncle slogged it through North Africa and all the way into Italy, I remember and respect his efforts, but I dont paint myself red and white.
photo
SkeeBee
Offending InFoxtrination Sufferers With Facts.
06:23 PM on 11/11/2011
"A woman wears a hat made out of poppies outside Westminster Abbey and smiles like the clueless, shallow dooooosh she would have to be to wear that head dress."
04:20 PM on 11/11/2011
- seems to me that it's more about the money than the remembrance (having all these 'rules' in place) - a bit too militaristic for my taste ...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oxjr
12:12 PM on 11/11/2011
Re-using a poppy should be fine if you re-donate, they are plastic so leaving them at a monument is just the same as throwing them away - except instead of them being put into a land fill, most will wash away into storm drains and be eaten by seabirds. Dispose of plastic poppies properly and leave flowers at the monument.
11:39 AM on 11/11/2011
I am a veteran. Wear the poppy that is closest to your heart. I spent 28 years in uniform so that you have the freedom to express yourself the way that you want. I won't wear a white poppy yet I won't criticize someone who does. As for the legion my response is a quote from my father a WWII veteran. "...a bunch of old men sitting around drinking beer lying to each other about the good old days, There was nothing good about the old days. The Bosch killed all my friends." After Verrieres Ridge he was changed forever.
03:47 PM on 11/11/2011
I had a vet yell at my friend once for wearing a poppy on his hat rather than on his lapel. Is this a dis-respect or was the old guy just having a bad day?
10:23 PM on 11/11/2011
Not everyone who wore a uniform truly understands what the significance of their service was. For some it was just a job because of deep unemployment. For others like myself it was a commitment to family, god and country. There is no answer to this other than in my opinion there is a lack of respect and civility in today's society. By the by when I was in uniform we wore the poppy on our hat.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
imperator prime
liberal INTJ agnostic militant guy-on-guy's guy.
08:40 AM on 11/11/2011
Doubtless I'll get some hate for this (mostly from folk who suspend their critical thinking on emotional holiday like today), but when the Legion says not to use any other, more reliable means of securing your poppy to your jacket (no safety pins, no flag pins, etc) and when they resist so vehemently *any* "unapproved of" use of the poppy symbol-- even by veterans, as in the case of the Ottawa vets biking club and their crest-- and when they go after any alternative symbols (white poppies by those who want to show their respect by extolling that promise of peace we've made and broken to the veterans of war over and over again, or environmentally friendly poppies, or what have you)... well... all told, those things combined make it seem a bit like there's a certain element within the Legion who take our veneration of vets as license to act like ogres, content to profiteer off of the repeat-replacement of lost poppy pins and ruthless in maintaining a monopoly. I just wonder how faithfully that subset represents the whole organization-- I certainly hope the majority aren't so cynical.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
sillyfrog
Pastafarian and UU student
05:01 PM on 11/11/2011
I wonder who made it a sacred symbol.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
imperator prime
liberal INTJ agnostic militant guy-on-guy's guy.
05:35 PM on 11/11/2011
We all know, of course, right? But if it was The Veterans that made it meaningful, why does the opinion of some veterans-- the ones who take offense to any 'alternative usage'-- matter more than the opinion of those veterans who don't? Why are we all subject to the preference of those who object, unable to accept any license from those who approve, or those who are indifferent? Doesn't that second group have as much right to a say in the matter that the rest of us can take our cues from?