Toronto's Earl Beatty Public School Bans Balls

Toronto School Bans Balls

The Huffington Post Canada   First Posted: 11/16/11 01:21 PM ET Updated: 11/17/11 09:17 AM ET

Correction: The spelling of St. Catharine's, Ontario was incorrect, that error has now been fixed.
Toronto's Earl Beatty Public School took an extreme approach to a minor injury by banning students from playing with hard balls earlier this week.

The ban was placed by school administrators after a parent suffered a concussion after being hit in the head by a soccer ball.

"Any balls brought will be confiscated and may be retrieved by parents from the office," a statement obtained by CTV said. "The only kind of ball allowed will be nerf balls or sponge balls."

The Toronto Star reports that the ban has been unpopular with students and parents alike. One six-year-old, Jacob Stateski, reportedly was "crushed" by the ban.

“He said, ‘Daddy, what am I going to do with all my friends?’ He wanted to change schools,” his father, Chris Stateski said to the Star.

The school cites the small playing area and the number of small children in and around it as the main reason why they've instituted the ball ban.

This isn't the first time that over-protective educators have cracked down on flying, round, objects that could cause serious injuries.

A school in the U.K. was criticized for banning balls.

"George Best and all the football stars wouldn't have got where they are if they were kicking sponge around, they kicked footballs in the backyard and if they fell over and scarred themselves it was part of the learning curve," Tam Fry, chairman of the Child Growth Foundation told the BBC.

In St. Catharines, Ontario, a ball ban was met by outraged students who organized a petition and got the ban reversed. So instead of keeping kids safe, the educators might instead give them a crash course in political activism and community organizing.

With childhood inactivity and obesity a serious issue, the wisdom of the ban has also been questioned.

"Sure space is tight in urban school yards like the one at Earl Beatty. I have to be very cafeful to stay out of the line of fire when I pick up my youngest son from his small school yard, so I can appreciate the risk," writes ParentCentral editor Brandie Wiekle.

"But that's the thing about risk. It has to be balanced against reward. And in this case the reward is just the kind of free play and exercise that today's screen-addicted kids need," she argues.

Quick Poll

What do you think of the school's ball ban?

Well balls can really, really hurt.

Seriously? What's next a ban on running around?

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
butchcliff
The future is unwritten
05:47 AM on 11/18/2011
Doesn't this knee-jerk reaction reduce physical activity for kids? There must be other alternatives to keep the younger children safe. Let the kids play. Not allowed to have fun or exercise.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:48 AM on 11/18/2011
Restricting the the type of games played in confined places within the school property makes sense.
Soccer balls belong in the 'field area' softer balls are o.k.elsewhere. Restricting all balls is just wrong.
11:17 PM on 11/17/2011
I can't vote in the poll because I agree with both options: Balls DO really hurt, but also this IS an overreaction.

And what's to blame? Teachers and parents evading responsibility, mainly. I was accident prone as a child and I have some choice words for the grown ups who think these accidents are unavoidable:

http://loveablehomebody.blogspot.com/2011/11/dont-blame-it-on-school-balls-my-fond.html
evecaren
Every cloud has a silver lining
04:47 PM on 11/17/2011
I think I understand why the school principal decided to ban all hard balls in the school The article
states that a parent in the school was hit by a hard ball while on school property. The parent was
hit so hard by the ball, maybe a soccer ball, that she received a concussion and was hospitalized.
It is my opinion that the principal does not want anyone else injured on school property by a hard
ball thrown by students, not another parents, not another student. Those soccer balls when they are
kicked by a student, carry a lot of force and can cause a lot of damage. When I was in grade four,
someone kicked a soccer ball and it landed in my stomach and it was extremely painful. My point
being that soccer balls can cause a lot of harm. I understand why the principal made this decision,
it doesn't mean that the ban is permanent.
03:36 PM on 11/16/2011
The issue at the St. Catharines school was overexaggerated by the local paper. They for some reason didn't have all the facts right. Balls were not banned on the playground. Only on the very small tarmac area, and only when the field was too wet to play soccer and there was well over 200 kids outside. At least kids there were getting fresh area and outdoor time. On days like that, most schools keep the kids indoors! FYI
photo
SeeTheFnords
Look out - there's one behind you!
04:21 PM on 11/16/2011
You are talking about the St. Catharines (sub)Standard, never known for excellent reporting.

And thumbs up for spelling St. Catharines correctly.
01:40 PM on 11/16/2011
I once worked at an elementary school for an after-school program. Soccer was a regular free-time activity and we were lucky to have a soccer field. One day, a student got a slight bloody nose from getting a soccer ball in the face. The after-school director then took away all hard balls based on the mother's over-reaction to the incident. The kids were SO upset. And who can blame them? There were other outrageous rules concerned with liability issues. Seriously, if people are going to be this extreme, perhaps we should seal kids up in a box. Wait! We do! That's why so many kids are sick and obese and unable to socialize normally.