Bilingualism Canada: Cost Of French $2.4 Billion Per Year, According To Fraser Institute Study

Bilingualism In Canada

The Huffington Post Canada   First Posted: 01/16/12 05:31 PM ET Updated: 01/16/12 05:34 PM ET

A new study has found the price tag for bilingualism in Canada is $2.4 billion per year.

The report from the Fraser Institute claims the federal government spends approximately $1.5-billion each year while the provinces shell out $900 million. Ontario spent the most ($600 million), followed by New Brunswick (approximately $85 million, according to Postmedia.

"The issue we examine in this study is not whether bilingualism is good or bad policy, but the costs above and beyond that of providing education and other services in the majority language,” Francois Vaillancourt, a Universite de Montreal economics professor, said in a statement.

The report comes on the heels of the federal government’s announcement that it will require the new head of the country’s broadcast regulator to speak both English and French.

"The next Chair of the CRTC will be bilingual," Heritage Minister James Moore wrote on Twitter.

Bureaucrat bilingualism made headlines last years when Michael Ferguson was named Canada’s next auditor general. The catch: Ferguson can't speak French fluently.

"I am already in the process of improving my skills in the language," he told The Canadian Press, adding that he should be able to become proficient in the language in a “reasonably short period of time.”

The Harper government stated that Ferguson was taking French lessons, emphasizing that he was selected based on merit. However, opposition parties refused to endorse his nomination.

Just last month,Robert Chisholm dropped out of the NDP leadership race after realizing he wouldn’t be able to master French by March when the next leader will be picked.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

A new study has found the price tag for bilingualism in Canada is $2.4 billion per year. The report from the Fraser Institute claims the federal government spends approximately $1.
A new study has found the price tag for bilingualism in Canada is $2.4 billion per year. The report from the Fraser Institute claims the federal government spends approximately $1.
 
 
  • Comments
  • 109
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
04:34 PM on 10/21/2012
Forced nationwide bilingualism is a total waste of time and energy by the governments. It should be left to private business. In Brighton Beach even the ATM machines are in Russian and in San Diego eveything is in Spanish and English. All paid for by private industry who knows how to do it right. In Canada we have to provide services of the Federal government even if there are no French living there. It gives us a poorer level of government of workers because we are prohibited from hiring those who speak English only by the laws.

This is one of the most brain dead ideas I have ever heard. Even U.S. doesn't have it and try forcing that on a country that doesn't have the wealth Canada has.

Change the law and save some tax money.

Brian
02:09 PM on 06/20/2012
I believe this foreign language and culture that is called ‘French’, which is either self-imposed or duped with, is costing Canada more than 50% of its overall economy and productivity... a great deal of efficiency and meritocracy is sacrificed in the name of this bloodsucker bilingualism...

I would like North America to be completely cleansed and free of anything that is to do anything with this freakin language, its culture or anything that has any association or affiliation with it. Until then, Canada will always be a second-rated country.
10:01 AM on 01/19/2012
This is the same Fraser Instutite that proposed eliminating poverty in Canada by changing the definition of the word "poverty" a few years ago?
The ultra-right-wing, pro-big business, anti-government, anti-multicultural, anti-public service Fraser Institute that has spent decades trying to erode this country and turn it into a deregulated, 3rd-world backwater with no safety laws, no minimum wage and no corporate income taxes?
Anyone who trusts any findings from the Fraser Institute should just head South of the border and ask Rick Perry to move here and take over Canada right now.
12:13 AM on 01/19/2012
The Fraser ? ..... you mean that right wing libertarian lobby group that receives funds from right wing american foundations such as Charles G. Koch Charitable Foundation or Exxon Mobile ? This is not a scientific study, this is a highly partisan study - the Fraser has a very bad rep, most of its studies are not peer reviewed - this fact SHOULD have been mentioned in the article.

It costs 0 to be bilingual in Montreal - we learn French or English at school, with friends, on the streets and with the community.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JackHoffman
Pundit
02:17 AM on 01/18/2012
Hey, how about raising your kids to speak at least ONE language fluently.
10:14 AM on 01/19/2012
Be patient, special interest groups can only wipe out public education and public services in one language at a time. I'm sure the Fraser Institute will get around to funding for a study that "proves" basic literacy (just enough to read up on who is behind the Fraser Institute and what its political aims are) in any language is bad for Canadians eventually.
08:36 PM on 01/17/2012
One tends to learn more than a language once they begin there journey to being multilingual. There are cultural experiences, sometimes life changing, that accompany most foreign language undertakings which are not available to persons who do not indulge.
05:12 PM on 01/17/2012
If we were better about making sure all our kids made it out of school fluently bilingual, the costs would disappear. If anyone you hire is guaranteed to be functionally bilingual, then there are no extra costs associated with serving people in either official language.

I used to live in Alberta and I live in Montreal now; I regret that I didn't appreciate French as much when I was young. No matter where I move to, though, I'll insist that my kids grow up fluent in both languages.
04:31 PM on 01/17/2012
Next up from the neocon Fraser Institute. "Metrification has high cost"
01:23 PM on 01/17/2012
>> Federal government spends approximately $1.5-billion each year while the provinces shell out $900 million. Ontario spent the most ($600 million), followed by New Brunswick (approximately $85 million, according to Postmedia.

Funny how Quebec doesn't spend $$ on bilingualism...

~

I'm all for bilingualism, just as long as it goes both way.
08:13 PM on 01/17/2012
I have heard that some French go both ways.
09:22 PM on 01/17/2012
You must be talking about the Greek...

;-)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
baizhongtang
Reality has an anti-neoliberal agenda
08:33 PM on 01/17/2012
Um, Quebec has more bilingual people, I think....ya, it does!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JackHoffman
Pundit
02:18 AM on 01/18/2012
lol I know. Some people are so dense. Fanned.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gx5000
Life's too short, be happy..
10:25 AM on 01/18/2012
We don't ? Really ? I've lost count of the Documents I've sent in for Translation...lol
http://ca.news.yahoo.com/blogs/canada-politics/bilingualism-costs-taxpayers-2-4-billion-173241373.html

Québec spends over $50M a year.....
photo
Jay from Ottawa
sovereignty sale, 1.3T OBO
12:11 PM on 01/17/2012
Some out there would just love to see Canada turn into a culturally sterile unilingual nation.

There's a wealth of wonders and literary marvels awaiting those willing to learn other languages.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ansdlmol
05:03 PM on 01/17/2012
Yes but not necessarily french. When it comes to % of the population french is very low on the Totem Pole in BC.
08:50 AM on 01/17/2012
I am an American living in Quebec and my four children attend French school. I am so grateful for this opportunity for them to become bilingual, and maybe perhaps someday becoming trilingual. It was a challenge for them in the beginning but the obstacles they face are giving them an unparalleled education.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gx5000
Life's too short, be happy..
10:20 AM on 01/17/2012
I meet Europeans on a regular basis, I still get the "tell me about this language issue" question...
They're usually trilingual, this German guy I just saw last week knew five (cinq-multilingual ?).
They just don't get the lack of interest in expanding one's knowledge...
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
photo
db44
From My Perspective
08:08 AM on 01/17/2012
With slightly more than 600,000 anglophones in Quebec, that province spends $50M annually or about $82 per anglophone. Ontario’s annual bilingualism expenditures of $623M for a francophone population of about 583,000 results in a figure of about $1060 per francophone. The report serves to remind everyone that when it comes to providing services for minority language populations, Quebec should be encouraged to do more for its anglophones. The Fraser Institute could have provided more information on reasons for that discrepancy. db
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gx5000
Life's too short, be happy..
10:21 AM on 01/17/2012
Maybe buy them bus tickets out ?

;-p
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ansdlmol
05:06 PM on 01/17/2012
If the anglophones leave Quebec it will sink. After the last referendum they left in droves and Quebec became a third world country overnight.
12:31 AM on 01/19/2012
If the data is real - Fraser Institute is a lobby group, not a scientific institution.
photo
Daniel Kilgallon
Calgary Heavy Oil
12:59 AM on 01/17/2012
I don't care what language you speak, but here in Alberta we don't have a significant French population. There is, however, a significant latino population and there are now quite a few Spanish immersion and even German immersion schools in Calgary. I'd love to see that happen in Quebec with their racist language laws.
Robert Vitulano
What did the dino say to the car? RAWR
09:56 AM on 01/17/2012
We have German, Hebrew and Greek schools in Montreal. With a google search, I'd probably find Spanish-immersion and Italian as well.

The language laws aren't racist. Discriminatory, yes, but definitely not racist. They passed a Charter analysis though, so they fly.

FYI, Franco-Albertans exist and there is a decent French population in Edmonton. Franco-Albertans voted and have their own flag and will likely be asserting their rights more in the upcoming years.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gx5000
Life's too short, be happy..
10:23 AM on 01/17/2012
You would benefit greatly by spending a few months in Montréal...
OUr "Racist" language laws have their roots in History, and you won't understand unless you lived through the quiet revolution, when to be French in Québec meant being a second class citizen. It's a French Province, wake up already.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
baizhongtang
Reality has an anti-neoliberal agenda
08:41 PM on 01/17/2012
I live Gatineau, and New flash! Quebecers are apparently still second-class citizens outside of Quebec...like people from first nations. If it's not WASP, it's not class...
photo
Daniel Kilgallon
Calgary Heavy Oil
12:53 AM on 03/14/2012
Two wrongs don't make a right.

That's like says it's okay to be racist because you're in a state that was part of the confederacy.

Also, there are Franco-Albertan's however there is a much more significant Sino-Albertan population that doesn't cry for things like bilingual speeding tickets.

Grow up and realize that English is the language of international business.
12:58 AM on 01/17/2012
I don't believe this number, but even if it is true - worth every penny.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gx5000
Life's too short, be happy..
10:24 AM on 01/17/2012
You should really change your name to Rational Canadian, or would that be too obvious ;-)