Twelve-year-old Victoria Grant of Cambridge, Ontario, has become an overnight Internet sensation after a video of her giving a scathing criticism of Canada’s banking industry went viral.
Grant has been giving a rehearsed speech to audiences at conferences about how “the banks and the government have colluded to financially enslave the people of Canada.”
Her father has been posting the videos to YouTube. One such video, of an appearance by the youthful Grant at a Public Banking Institute conference in Philadelphia, got picked up by various blogs over the past few days.
Apparently Grant was added as an “impromptu speaker” at the conference.
Grant’s argument is one that has been picking up some steam in recent years on the fringes of Canada’s economic debates.
The core of the idea is that Canadian taxpayers are being ripped off by the banks and the government because elected officials are unnecessarily borrowing money from the private banks at commercial interest rates.
Until the 1970s, the government borrowed directly from the Bank of Canada, which is a Crown corporation and issues Canada’s currency. But in recent decades, it has been borrowing from private banks instead. Critics say that the government is unnecessarily paying extra in interest rates to cover private banks’ profit margins.
Or, as Victoria Grant puts it: “It has become painfully obvious … that we are being defrauded and robbed by the banking system and a complicit government.”
Grant is not alone in making this argument.
In an article published last year at the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, George Crowell argued that getting the federal government to borrow directly from the Bank of Canada “would make available tens of billions of dollars that are urgently needed to rebuild our public infrastructure, protect our environment, and strengthen Medicare and other social programs so vital in meeting human needs.”
But critics say allowing the government to borrow directly from the BoC would essentially be allowing it to print its own money, whenever and however it likes. If the government were to borrow money at interest rates below inflation, it would cause inflation to skyrocket, critics argue.
"At zero percent interest we would actually be subsidising, and hence encouraging, government borrowing," Green Party of Canada activist Ard Van Leeuwen argued.
Reaction to Grant’s video has been mixed. While some online commentators have been impressed by the girls’ economic prowess, others have wondered if her father is behind the campaign.
“I’ll bet money she didn’t write that herself,” commenter ianmcphee420 wrote on YouTube.
<strong>Profit per dollar earned by the CEO: $162.27</strong> National Bank's Louis Vachon took home $7.5 million, the lowest total of any of the six major banks, but the most in terms of the bank's net income.
<strong>Profit per dollar earned by the CEO: $326.32</strong> Gerry McCaughey's total compensation grew 12 per cent, to $9.5 million, in 2011. Source: <a href="https://www.cibc.com/ca/pdf/investor/proxy2012.pdf" target="_hplink">CIBC Management Proxy Circular</a>
<strong>Profit per dollar earned by the CEO: $330.81</strong> Bill Downe's total compensation for 2011 was up 4.2 per cent from his 2010 pay of $9.5 million. Source: <a href="http://ca.reuters.com/article/businessNews/idCATRE81Q1W320120227" target="_hplink">Reuters</a>
<strong>Profit per dollar earned by the CEO: $480.40</strong> Gordon Nixon's total compensation fell 8 per cent in 2011, to $11 million. Source: <a href="http://www.rbc.com/newsroom/2012/0206-proxy.html" target="_hplink">RBC Management Proxy Circular</a>
<strong>Profit per dollar earned by the CEO: $501.71</strong> Waugh's total earnings for 2011, at $10.6 million, were down slightly from the $10.66 million he earned in 2010. Source: <a href="http://www.thestar.com/business/article/1137400--scotiabank-ceo-s-pay-down-slightly-from-2010" target="_hplink">Toronto Star</a>
<strong>Profit per dollar earned by the CEO: $517.45</strong> Ed Clark's total compensation for 2011 was meant to be around $12 million, but the bank's board scaled it back to $11.3 million -- roughly the same as in 2010. Source: <a href="http://www.thestar.com/business/article/1135817--td-bank-ceo-ed-clark-s-pay-down-to-11-3-million-in-2011" target="_hplink">Toronto Star</a>