LIVING

The Biggest Loser Weight Loss: TV Show Doesn't Help Others Lose Weight, Study Finds

10/26/2012 03:17 EDT | Updated 10/28/2012 08:27 EDT
NBC Universal

It may be inspiring to watch contestants shed upwards of 100 pounds on TV's "The Biggest Loser," but it's not doing anything for your own weight loss plan.

A new study out of the Faculty of Physical Education and Recreation at the University of Alberta found that people who were shown a short clip of people exercising on the TV show were turned off doing physical activity.

"The depictions of exercise on shows like The Biggest Loser are really negative," said the study's lead author, Tanya Berry, the Canada Research Chair in Physical Activity Promotion. "People are screaming and crying and throwing up, and if you're not a regular exerciser you might think this is what exercise is — that it's this horrible experience where you have to push yourself to the extremes and the limits, which is completely wrong."

The show has been criticized in the past for the extremity of both its contestants weight and their weight loss progress, which is often in the double digits each week.

"I think a lot of people can feel quite defeated that they're losing weight in what we would call a recommended amount [one to two pounds a week], but they would have been voted off the show immediately," Robert Kushner, the clinical director of the Northwestern University Comprehensive Center on Obesity, told LiveScience. "So the message, to me, is just all wrong."

Even one of the show's former contestants, Kai Hibbard from season three, has spoken out against the way the process is conveyed, telling CBS' "The Early Show," “I have people that come up to me and talk to me and ask me why they can’t lose 12 pounds in a week when I did. It didn’t happen. It’s TV…a week is not a week in TV.”

In the Alberta study, students watched clips of either the beginning of season nine of "The Biggest Loser" or a clip from "American Idol," and those in the first group demonstrated far worse attitudes about physical activity when they were questioned afterwards. Berry is mostly concerned that popular shows like this can cause people to give up on exercise altogether.

"There's a lot of effort and good work out there just to get people more active [with public campaigns], but it's such a small voice in this big wash of different depictions of exercise. It's a big mess," she said.

Also on HuffPost

Weight Loss Success Stories