Fox Simpsons Streaming Lawsuit: I'm Bankrupt, Defendant Says

Posted: Updated:
A Canadian man who was ordered to pay 20th Century Fox $10.5 million for streaming episodes of “The Simpsons” and “Family Guy” says he has been driven to bankruptcy by the court’s decision. (Photo by FOX via Getty Images)
A Canadian man who was ordered to pay 20th Century Fox $10.5 million for streaming episodes of “The Simpsons” and “Family Guy” says he has been driven to bankruptcy by the court’s decision. (Photo by FOX via Getty Images)

A Canadian man who was ordered to pay 20th Century Fox $10.5 million for streaming episodes of “The Simpsons” and “Family Guy” says he has been driven to bankruptcy by the court’s decision.

Fox reportedly filed a lawsuit with the Federal Court in Toronto last October, alleging that two websites — Watch The Simpsons Online and Watch Family Guy Online — violated its copyright.

In its ruling, the Federal Court found the defendant had copied episodes of the TV shows, uploaded them to a server and gave the public access to them through embedded video players.

It awarded Fox $10 million in statutory damages, and another $500,000 in punitive damages. According to Torrentfreak, a news site that covers copyright issues, the two sites are now property of Fox.

The defendant in the lawsuit, identified as “Mr. Hernandez” in earlier reports and as “Nick” in an interview with Vice magazine, said he was surprised by the lawsuit because such suits had not been common in Canada.

I assumed I'd hear about a movie site in Canada being taken down first and then I would have voluntarily followed suit to avoid any issues … but obviously I never expected to be the guinea pig,” he told Vice magazine.

He said he set up the websites out of frustration over the fact that more recent seasons of “The Simpsons” are not available on DVD, and he doesn’t see his activities as being harmful to Fox.

“I filled the gap,” he said. “I was hoping Fox would eventually create their own service that I could link to or use in some way.”

“Nick” said he did make money off the sites, but not enough to make a decent living. He says he was struggling with credit card debt while running the sites.

“They are getting every penny from my house sale and that's really all I have for them,” he told Vice. Despite his financial problems, Fox was “trying to paint a picture as though I made half a million dollars per year with the thing.”

According to Torrentfreak, Watch The Simpsons Online got about 80 million visitors during its lifetime, which began in 2008, and Watch Family Guy Online got about seven million.

Under Canadian law, people who infringe copyright for commercial purposes can be fined up to $20,000 per infringement. The maximum amount in this case would have been $14 million, law news site Lexology reports.

Nick argues entertainment companies themselves could end piracy if they took steps to make their content more easily available.

“If all the entertainment industries got together and made a worldwide Hulu of sorts, they could and would kill piracy even if it [had] a minimal fee similar to Netflix,” he said.

Also on HuffPost:

15 Crazy Lawsuits
of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

TV may change forever: Four broadcasters file lawsuit against Aereo over ...

Sony Settles 'Blurred Lines' Lawsuit With Marvin Gaye's Family

Dude, You Can't Copyright That Hookah

Authors Guild appeals decision in Google Books copyright suit