When Stephen Harper became prime minister in 2006 he touted a "smaller" cabinet "designed for work—not for show". On Monday, he became the first among equals in a cabinet tied for the title of largest in Canadian history.
The demotion of embattled Julian Fantino to associate minister of National Defence and the appointment of Erin O’Toole to minister of Veterans Affairs brings the size of the Harper ministry to 40 strong, matching the size of Brian Mulroney's 1984 cabinet.
MP Brent Rathgeber, who quit the Tory caucus to sit as an independent in 2013, was quick to point out the milestone.
With the addition of Erin O'Toole, the federal cabinet is now up to 40 Members, tieing the largest ever Canadian cabinet. #cdnpoli
— Brent Rathgeber, MP (@brentrathgeber) January 5, 2015
And while Rathgeber's criticism of the expansion was implied, NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair was more explicit.
"For someone who has always preached cuts for government expenditures, Harper is now proving once more he’s not able to deliver the goods," Mulcair told reporters in French on Monday.
"He’s beaten all the records of all the governments in Canada."
When Harper first became prime minister in 2006 he appointed just 26 people to his first cabinet, a move meant to contrast his fiscal conservatism with the policies of former Liberal PM Paul Martin, whose own cabinet had ballooned in size to as large as 39 members.
"My smaller cabinet and more streamlined cabinet structure are designed for work—not for show," Harper said at the time. "The structure is designed to promote accountable, efficient and effective government—more focus and purpose; less process and cost."
Asked Monday about the utility of today's much larger cabinet, now greater in size than Martin's largest ministry, Harper's press secretary Carl Vallée told HuffPost in an email that "We are confident that we have the team to deliver on the priorities of Canadians: jobs, the economy, safe communities, and standing up for Canadian values at home and abroad."
Fantino was shuffled out of Veterans Affairs on Monday after 18 controversial months on the job. Throughout his tenure, the former commissioner of the Ontario Provincial Police faced criticism for closing offices, cutting jobs and for failing to spend his department's full budget. Fantino suffered through several public gaffes, including showing up late to a meeting with angry vets and ignoring questions from the wife of a former soldier with PTSD while TV cameras rolled.
Fantino becomes associate minister of National Defence, a job which had been vacant since July of 2013. According to the Prime Minister's Office, Fantino will assist the minister of National Defence on issues of "arctic sovereignty, information technology security and foreign intelligence."