What is happening to our daughters when they hit puberty? In a recent report from the Canadian Women’s Foundation (CWF), self-esteem and mental health in girls almost universally plummets between the ages of nine and 13.
Check out just a few of their recent stats:
• 36 per cent of grade six girls say they are self-confident, but only 14 per cent of grade 10 girls do.
• 25 per cent of both grade six boys and girls reported feeling depressed some time, but by grade 10, girls are three times more likely than boys to be depressed.
• In one study, 50 per cent of girls reported wishing they were someone else.
The big question is why is this happening to our girls? And just as importantly, what can we do about it?
From a developmental perspective, adolescence is the time of discovering one’s identity. Youth are also transitioning into the role of adult and hate anything childlike or associated with immaturity.
They imitate and pine for anything grown up to prove their progress forward into adulthood, which can create stress and pressure. Compounding that stress are feelings of grief and loss as they see their easy-going childhood days slipping away.
So imagine now, that you are young budding tween girl in North America in 2016. How does one “do” being a women successfully?
While your own mother serves as a role model, so too does the greater culture of TV, movies, magazines, advertising, music videos, games, apps, billboards, YouTube and clothing retailers. They all paint a picture of what it means to be a women and sadly, the research from the Canadian Women’s Foundation reveals that the pervasive message is this: Be sexual, be beautiful, and by beautiful we mean thin. Be voiceless and passive.
"36 per cent of grade six girls say they are self-confident, but only 14 per cent of grade 10 girls do."
The American Psychological Association (APA) states that the sexualization of girls is the main reason for the decline in their mental health. The organization defines sexualization as “when a person’s main value is believed to come from their sexual appearance -- rather than their intelligence or other qualities -- and when they are held to unrealistic standards of physical attractiveness.”
Now, imagine you are 14 and you don’t want to be sexual yet. Imagine your body is rounding out from the pubescent surge of hormones. If society has taught our girls their singular value comes from looking thin and finding a boy to assure their worth, these girls will have a huge surge in feelings of inferiority and inadequacy.
And so the cycle starts: a girl will think she doesn’t have what is needed to be worthy within this society, low self-esteem ensues, depression follows and self harm begins.
Here are some more shocking numbers from the CWF’s report:
• Almost half a million girls posted YouTube videos of themselves asking “am I pretty or ugly?”
• 90 per cent of girls say the fashion industry puts a lot of pressure on them to be thin.
• In B.C., 60 per cent of girls who were actually too thin, said they were too fat.
• The number of girls aged 18 and younger who had breast implants has tripled in one year.
• 50 per cent of grade six girls are dieting, this increases to 60 per cent by grade 10.
What can we do about the sexualization of our daughters?
Well, my own daughter Lucy, now 21 and a third-year university student, struggled in adolescence to accept her strong athletic body which did not conform to the skinny beauty ideal her peers were striving for. Now she enjoys being strong and muscular over willowy and is using her own experience to empower other girls.
"50 per cent of grade six girls are dieting, this increases to 60 per cent by grade 10."
She and a co-facilitator lead a program called “Go Girls” established by Big Sisters and Big Brothers.
The program was established to help young girls identified as high risk, who need extra support in the area of body image and self esteem. Her decision to volunteer with Go Girls was because of her desire to help others and to cement her own convictions while pushing back against the cultural standards that crush girls’ esteem.
What can you do?
1. Ask your school counsellors if such a program is available in your school or take the initiative to start a similar group.
2. Begin discussing the cultural phenomena of sexualization with your daughter and listen to her opinion while helping her shape a healthier perspective.
4. Provide alternative messages through alternate media sources. Buy magazines like New Moon instead Seventeen.
5. Watch and read stories with strong female heroines from The Paper Bag Princess and Harriet the Spy through to Katniss Everdeen.
6. Bookmark Common Sense Media and use the resources there to help make select media consumption.
7. Model healthy attitudes and think before you speak. For example: never ask your daughter “does this make me look fat?” And don't comment: “Wow, you look great! Have you lost weight?”
8. Speak up and cast your vote when something offends your sensibility. Marketers will listen. In 2014, Apple and Google removed a Barbie “plastic surgery” app that was designed for children to perform cosmetic surgery on a virtual girl, allowing them to make her “slim and beautiful.”
9. Discuss gender issues when they make the news. Trudeau’s recent cabinet assignments come to mind.
10. Forward or post this article so other parent become aware.
Please add your favourite resources for girls' self-esteem in the comment section below!
ALSO ON HUFFPOST:
Read a good mystery novel for a surefire ego boost. But here's the clincher: The case must be crackable yet still satisfying, with a reliable "Aha!" moment, found an Ohio State University study. While all readers enjoyed not knowing for sure whodunit, those whose self-confidence was down at the time got a bigger boost when the villain turned out to be the one they sort of suspected all along. To strike that sweet spot, Kate Stine, the editor-in-chief of Mystery Scene magazine, recommends books by Alexander McCall Smith (No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency Mysteries), Margaret Maron (Deborah Knott Series) and Lindsey Davis (Marcus Didius Falco Mysteries).
Enter a few small competitions that you're likely to win -- a debate in your area of expertise, a race against your sluggish partner, a Boggle battle, anything. Tiny victories build confidence on a biological level, says neuropsychologist Ian Robertson in his book The Winner Effect. Each feat sprouts androgen receptors in the brain's reward-and-motivation areas. The more receptors you have, the more testosterone influences you -- and the bolder you'll be in your next challenge (especially in a familiar context). Anecdotally, the edge you get from consecutive victories can last for months, Robertson says. (Note: This brain boost was observed in mice, but early evidence suggests it applies to humans too.)
An antidote for life's put-downs: sit-ups -- 12 extra ones. Or one more volley, two more staircases, four surplus squats. To pump up deflated self-esteem and improve overall life satisfaction, extend your normal exercise for just a few minutes more than usual, found a study led by Jaclyn Maher at Penn State University (and if you don't have a routine, do a little exercise of any sort, she says). It's well documented that a workout improves mood, but Maher says that making the extra effort when the ego is weak may also strengthen a feeling of control -- which leads to self-confidence.
We all know that journal writing is therapeutic. But a study at Israel's University of Haifa surprised us: Blogging our innermost feelings turns out to be more confidence-building than the old leather-bound lock-and-key approach. After two months, students who posted intimate and sometimes agonized entries online at least twice weekly showed greater improvement in self-esteem -- especially if their (totally anonymous) blogs were open to comments (which were usually supportive). The explanation: A blog's "safe self-exposure" aspect helps us to feel connected and less socially anxious.
Go ahead, spread some juicy gossip about someone you know. It'll make you feel better about yourself. But there's a condition: no bad-mouthing. A study at England's Staffordshire University found that when volunteers spread kind gossip about fictional others ("You'd never know she's actually a genius at coding"), they immediately experienced a feel-good jolt and a slight but significant (5 percent) increase in self-esteem. (Meanwhile, spreading mean-spirited rumors led them to feel a 34 percent increase in negative emotions.)
Channel a moment in your life when you felt genuinely powerful (you tamed a tough crowd, charmed your first clients, gave birth). Write about it for 10 minutes. If you're like the volunteers in a study published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, this exercise will make you feel (and come across as) noticeably more confident. And not in a cocky way: "Power-primed" people were simply more persuasive and impressive than usual in written essays and face-to-face mock business-school interviews. (They were also 81 percent likelier to receive a thumbs-up.)
Throw one arm over the armrest of your chair. Stretch the other over the back of the chair next to you. Rest one ankle on the opposite thigh. If you're like the volunteers in a study at Northwestern University's Kellogg School of Management, this expansive pose "activates" power-related behaviors (as examples, they made bolder blackjack moves and indicated a willingness to speak first in a debate). Ann Cuddy, a social psychologist at Harvard Business School, found that holding an arms-up/legs-spread "power pose" for two minutes boosted confidence on a hormonal level by increasing testosterone and decreasing the stress hormone cortisol.
Look to Michelle Obama, Hillary Clinton, Angelina Jolie (or any other bigwig) to get a little ego boost. Sure, the relationship is one-sided -- you know all about her, and she doesn't know you -- but an impression of intimacy works in your favor, found a study at the University of Buffalo. When people with flagging self-esteem wrote down the ways in which they were similar to their favorite same-sex celeb (we share smarts, cheekbones, alcoholic moms and a weakness for goofy men), they felt closer to -- or at least more confident about becoming -- their own best selves.