The world rejoiced last week when Aerie announced a new male body positive campaign called #AerieMAN, which featured four diverse men and their diverse bodies. It was followed by the statement, "The Real You Is Sexy."
"Brilliant!" we all thought. "Another conversation about body awareness is making international headlines!"
And then the unimaginable happened. Aerie (basically) said "just kidding, April Fools."
— American Eagle (@AEO) April 1, 2016
American Eagle Outfitters, Aerie's parent organization, said in a released statement on Friday, "American Eagle Outfitters proves once again they're not afraid to take a risk and have a laugh in support of a good cause... the brand reveals today its #AerieMAN campaign, featuring a mix of quirky characters of different sizes and personalities sharing 'real life' stories in their skivvies, was all in good fun to parody the #AerieReal campaign by Aerie, a leader in body-positive marketing."
The brand then stated it has pledged to, "forego retouching its male models in its underwear and swim images beginning Holiday 2016."
For many (read: the Internet), that was not a good enough answer as to why Aerie, AEO's loungewear spinoff, decided to use male body image issues as a punchline.
Aerie thought it would be a good idea to mock men's body positivity as an April Fools joke. That's so gross of them.— World Eater (@haleythewarrior) April 2, 2016
Really @Aerie you decide to make body positivity for men an April Fools joke? Body positivity is NEVER a joke. You couldn't fail worse— Michelle Anneliese (@manneliesemedia) April 2, 2016
this is so disgusting, this is a serious issue for so many men and u mad an a*ril fools' joke about it????? https://t.co/B9WRiRkBq0— ˗ˏˋ mike ˎˊ˗ (@THEDIANAPRlNCE) April 4, 2016
@AEO the only joke here is shopping at your stores— Ianterstellar Darko (@movienerd15) April 1, 2016
"#AerieMan was not a prank but rather an opportunity for us to raise awareness about body positivty," an American Eagle spokesperson told Mic, who was also dissatisfied with the press release answer.
However, it seems as though the campaign wasn't all a bust, at least for Brendon Williams of Langford, B.C. who plays Doug, a man who, "always liked being in [his] underwear" in the ad. The role, along with his daring series of boudoir birthday poses, a gift to his wife, landed him a starring role in the ad campaign — even thought he knew it was a gag from the start.
"This has actually improved my self esteem,'' says Williams in an interview as reported by The Canadian Press. "Not so much that I think I look better on the whole, but I think it's more that I don't have to be concerned about my flaws as much. I don't think I have the greatest body in the world, obviously, but this has made me go a little bit easier on myself.''
In a campaign that champions "being you," it's a shame that body diversity was the victim in a rather thoughtless April Fools joke, especially for a company like Aerie who first promoted body-positivity in their #AerieReal ads back in 2014. The mission of many of their campaigns has been to stop using unretouched photos and challenge “supermodel standards by featuring unretouched models in their latest collection of bras, undies and apparel.” Now why make a joke of that?
Lesson learned, American Eagle and Aerie? When it comes to body image, it's no laughing matter.
Also on HuffPost