As Canada’s Liberal government pushes forward with a controversial $15-billion arms export deal with Saudi Arabia, a spokesperson for Sweden’s government says cancelling its own Saudi arms deal didn’t hurt the country.
“We have not experienced any economic effects due to [the cancellation] and our bilateral relations with Saudi Arabia are good,” Swedish foreign ministry spokesperson Anna Ekberg told the Globe and Mail.
Sweden’s own arms and training contract with Saudi Arabia was smaller than the proposed Canadian deal. According to the Financial Times, the Swedish deal was worth some C$750 million between 2011 and 2014.
Swedish Foreign Minister Margot Wallstrom addresses The Lakshman Kadirgamar Institute of International Relations and Strategic Studies in Colombo, Sri Lanka, on April 25, 2016. A spokesperson for Wallstrom says cancelling a defence contract with Saudi Arabia didn't hurt Sweden. (AFP/Getty Images)
Still, Sweden’s experience stands in contrast to Foreign Affairs Minister Stephane Dion’s claims that cancelling the Canadian deal would negatively impact Canadian trade.
Dion said last month that the Saudis’ reaction to Sweden’s cancellation was “very harsh. … Saudi Arabia reacted in a way that cut many things.”
Sweden failed to renew its deal with the Saudis in March, 2015, after Saudi Arabia blocked Swedish Foreign Minister Margot Wallstrom from giving a speech at the Arab League. Wallstrom had been critical of sharia law and of Saudi Arabia’s flogging of blogger Raif Badawi.
Calling Wallstrom’s comments "offensive" and a "blatant interference in ... internal affairs,” Saudi Arabia recalled its ambassador and suspended business visas for Swedes.
But the Globe reports that within weeks, relations had been normalized. Wallstrom struck a more conciliatory note, saying she wanted to clear up the “misunderstanding that we have insulted the religion of Islam,” but did not apologize for her criticisms.
Foreign Affairs Minister Stephane Dion argues that cancelling the Saudi arms deal could bring a "harsh" response from Saudi Arabia, but Sweden's government says the country has not suffered from the decision. (Canadian Press photo)
According to data obtained by the newspaper, only one specific sector of Sweden's economy — arms exports — suffered as a result of the cancellation. Though trade between Sweden and Saudi Arabia declined last year, it also did so the year before, making it difficult to tell if the deal's cancellation played much of a role in that.
The federal Liberals have taken heavy criticism for their decision to go forward with the arms deal that the previous Conservative government struck in February, 2014.
The $15-billion contract for a fleet of armoured vehicles is expected to create 3,000 jobs in southern Ontario, where the vehicles will be produced by General Dynamics Land System.
Though polls show that only one-fifth of Canadians back the arms deal and nearly half oppose it, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has argued it’s a matter of principle.
"The principle at play here is that Canada's word needs to mean something in the international community," Trudeau said last month.
Asked last month if there were any countries that would be disqualified from trading with Canada over their human rights record, Trudeau would not answer, saying only that Canada has a “nuanced” position on trade, and engages with adversaries such as Iran.