School boards have submitted their LGBTQ policies to the province, but it doesn't look like they'll all make the grade, according to one non-profit.
In a report released Tuesday, Public Interest Alberta (PIA) examined four school boards policies in Red Deer, Lethbridge, Grande Prairie, and St. Albert. They found inconsistencies in how well they actually set up LGBTQ students to succeed.
The Alberta government gave schools a mandate earlier this year to implement changes to better support LGBTQ students.
The government drafted a series of guidelines to help schools, but ultimately left it up to each board to build their own.
PIA graded schools on six criteria:
- Does the school have a specific standalone sexual orientation and gender identity policy, and is it publicly available?
- Does the policy comply with Alberta's human rights legislation?
- Does it clearly address the needs of LGBTQ students, staff and families?
- Does it provide specific supports and accomodations for trans or non-gender-binary students?
- Does it protect student privacy?
- Does it impose no additional constraints or requirements on students?
While Red Deer's school board passed with flying colours, it looks like St. Albert Catholic schools might end up in detention.
The school district doesn't have standalone policies that specifically apply to LGBTQ students. There's also "no acknowledgment of the existence of or legal rights of transgender students," according to PIA's report.
It's also St. Albert Catholic schools' policy to push students with same-sex attractions to focus on "prayer, self-control and chastity."
Dr. Kristopher Wells, director of University of Alberta's Institute for Sexual Minority Studies and Services, said the group's motive is to ensure LGBTQ youth aren't seen as "a problem" in school systems.
"We wanted to ensure that LGBTQ youth were not seen as a problem to be managed through these policies in schools, that somehow they had to be constrained, contained or hidden away within these school communities," he said in a statement.
All Alberta students should be entitled to the same supports, resources, and protections "regardless of where they go to school," he said.
The organization is hoping their rankings motivate all Alberta schools to modify their policies to "make the grade."
Schools refuse to make policies
There are still some boards that are refusing to comply with the government's policy.
Pastor Brian Coldwell, chair of the Independent Baptist Christian Education Society, says his board's two schools will not be enacting guidelines to support LGBTQ students. Both schools receive funding from Alberta's government.
“It’s trying to impose the gay activist rainbow ideology, if you will – that’s really the hidden agenda here," Coldwell told Global News.
Education Minister David Eggen has not confirmed if boards who refuse to comply will face consequences, CBC News reported.
On August 16, Eggen posted an open letter on Facebook welcoming Alberta students back to school and reminding them they all have the right to feel safe.
Also on HuffPost:
When Vladimir Putin signed the ban on "gay propaganda" into law on June 30, 2013, it was only a glimpse of what was to come. The law criminalised LGBT-friendly public acts and demonstrations, which in turn set off a firestorm of events including arrests, international protests, boycotts, and outrage from public figures and celebrities alike. Which brings us to 2015. With the "gay propaganda" law still in place many events have occurred within the year and without the media attention of the Sochi Olympics, many activists have been left to fight the battles alone. In July, Putin's party unveiled a "straight flag" which one of its politicians described as "Our answer to same sex marriages, this mockery of the very concept of family. We must prevent gay fever in our country and support traditional values." By November it became clear that a law could be passed in the state that would make the act of coming out illegal. The proposal was made in an attempt to expand upon the 2013 propaganda ban. Two elected officials made the announcement that they are seeking to criminalise the act of coming out. The proposed amendment to the Russian Administrative Code would make "public expression of non-traditional sexual relations" a violation punishable by a fine. But the the penalty is more severe--up to 15 days in jail--if the "offence" takes place in an educational or governmental setting. The future for LGBT in Russia is uncertain, and there has been small victories. In March the Dzerzhinsky District Court of Nizhny Tagil overturned the January 23rd conviction of an activist, Elena Klimova, for "promotion of homosexuality," in what could be described as a landmark ruling. A spokesperson from Russian LGBT Network told the Huffington Post UK about the feeling on the ground in Russia in 2015. "Right now, the situation with LGBT rights in Russia is quite complicated. The consequences of the so-called "propaganda law" itself are numerous. "One the one hand, now everyone in Russia know who are gays and lesbians - before we had to explain just the fact that we exist. We got a lot of new allies and supporters. On the other hand, the hate crimes against LGBT became numerous. "Moreover, now the perpetuators know that the state supports them. In mass media, LGBT portrayed almost exclusively as perverts, sick people or "agents of West." "Indeed, the Olympic Games attended a load of attention to the violation of LGBT rights in Russia worldwide, but unfortunately, it had very small impact on the situation in the country,".
Arguably the biggest LGBT crime of our time is happening under the brutal rule of the so-called Islamic State. Notorious for their gruesome methods of killing, Islamic State, also known as Isis, Isil and Daesh, reserves one of its most brutal for suspected homosexuals. Videos it has released have shown masked militants dangling men over the edge of buildings by their legs to drop them head-first or tossing them over the edge. At least 36 men in Syria and Iraq have been killed by IS militants on charges of sodomy, according to the New York-based OutRight Action International. Gays often fear they could be turned over to the militants by friends or family because of the stigma against homosexuality. Islamic State's own announcements are the main source of information, but the group often does not name the victims, perhaps in deference to their families, who could lash out in anger at having their names publicly linked to homosexuals.
Here is Saudi Arabia's Foreign Minister Prince Saud al-Faisal (R) holding a joint press conference with his German counterpart Guido Westerwelle. Westerwelle, Europe's first openly gay top diplomat, said human rights issues were fully aired during a visit to Saudi Arabia. Prince Saud told the same news conference that during their discussion, he had made it clear to Westerwelle that regional, cultural and religious traditions must be respected. Fast forward five years later and the country's stance on LGBT rights has not changed. In September the country insisted that the UN remove its gay rights from the organisation’s Global Goals, saying it is “counter to Islamic law”. Homosexuality is illegal under Sharia law in Saudi Arabia and punishments for those engaging in same-sex relationships include execution, chemical castration and imprisonment.
In 2014, a tough anti-gay law was reintroduced by Uganda's President Yoweri Museveni, threatening anyone convicted of homosexuality with a life sentence, and banning the promotion of gay rights. Two years prior the country had gained international notoriety when the original version of the anti-gay bill came to light, involving references to a severe death penalty for "numerous offenses". In September this year Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni said he would not pursue further anti-gay legislation in the country, because of the country's existing laws that punish gays. "That law was not necessary, because we already have a law which was left by the British which deals with this issue," Museveni told reporters. Uganda's existing homophobic legislation already punishes gay sex with up to life imprisonment under a colonial-era anti-sodomy law, and same-sex marriage is also banned as part of the country's constitution. In addition to the laws, most recently the country has passed a bill that allows repression of activist groups. The Ugandan parliament unanimously passed the legislation on 26 November that would give the government broad powers to disband any nongovernmental organization that it considered contrary to the public interest or "contrary to the dignity of the people of Uganda." Leaders of any organisation operating without government approval could be imprisoned for up to eight years, according to the original text of the bill. The specific language of the bill, as passed, was not immediately available, but its original text was condemned by a wide range of organisations, including groups seeking recognition of the human rights of LGBT Ugandans.
When beleaguered former prime minister Tony Abbott refused to advocate marriage equality he might not have realised just how popular such a measure would be. Just months before he was ousted as leader, a poll showed a record 70% of Australians and many senior figures in his cabinet supported the move towards marriage equality. In August he acknowledged it was "OK to be gay" while still advocating "the traditional position that marriage is between a man and a woman". The major competitor in resistance against same sex marriage has been the Australian Christian Lobby (ACL) - a grass roots movement of people who want to inject Christian ethics into national politics. Managing director of the lobby Lyle Shelton, claims that the views of traditional marriage supporters have been drowned out by gay lobbyists and the media. The Australian struggle for LGBT rights hit an important point at 2008, when 84 laws were amended that discriminated against same-sex couples. The future of its progress could be held back by such lobbyists, and by conservative powers.
Meanwhile in the UK - although death sentences and chemical castrations are not in the picture for LGBT people, there are still advancements to be made. Long since the days of Section 28, an act that banned local authorities from "promoting" homosexuality or gay "pretended family relationships", some activists are still calling for changes. In December a protest was held at the BBC Sports Personality of the Year awards taking place at the SSE Arena in Belfast. Grassroots LGBT activists protested in opposition to the addition of Heavyweight champion Tyson Fury to the short list of BBC Sports Personality of the Year 2015 following his comments regarding homosexuality. Elsewhere in Northern Ireland the fight for same-sex marriage rages on. Pressure is mounting after its southern state passed a referendum for the act earlier this year. Not just a fight for LGB issues, Transgender rights are coming to the forefront of debate in Britain. The right for transgender prisoners to be held in the correct gender prison to which they define is one of the talking points. This comes after a number of female inmates took their lives when they were moved to male prisons this year. Statistics exclusive to the Huffington Post UK revealed that 62% of trans people have experienced transphobic harassment from strangers in public places, and 81% have had to avoid public situations out of fear.