Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Andreas Souvaliotis

GET UPDATES FROM Andreas Souvaliotis
 

Lessons From Greece's Bankrupt Society

Posted: 10/06/11 10:09 AM ET

Greece, the country that once upon a time was busy inventing democracy, philosophy and the notions of social justice for the world, has suddenly earned a reputation as one of the most reckless nations of our times -- a dishonest, fiscally irresponsible and nearly rogue problem child of the West that now also has the ability to trigger a global domino effect and pull us all into a whole new financial crisis. How did the Greeks manage to get themselves into such an abyss and what lessons could their experience hold for the rest of us?

I have just returned from spending a week in my sunny birth country, where the only topic of conversation seemed to be "the crisis." They are all debating the root causes of their financial demise and they're as dramatic and angry about it as Greeks have always been -- except this time their exchanges also contain a remarkable amount of genuine introspection and perhaps even a little bit of self-recrimination. They're shocked by the extent of their catastrophe. They can't even see their way out of it yet and they're actually afraid to speculate about their future. As a result, most uncharacteristically, their passionate debates are now almost exclusively focused on trying to figure out just how they got themselves into this mess.

Two hundred years ago Greece emerged from centuries of foreign occupation as an extremely poor nation. It remained near the bottom of Europe until the second half of the 20th century, when it suddenly began to prosper, joined the EU, happily absorbed vast amounts of infrastructural development funding from its wealthier European siblings, attracted some decent foreign investment and showed up one day as one of the continent's most insatiably consumerist "nouveau riche" societies. Ten years ago, when George W. Bush was trying to persuade his fellow citizens to spend their way out of their post-9/11 economic doldrums, he may have been drawing his inspiration from Greece, where meagre income earners were receiving unsecured loans from their banks to fund their extended summer vacations!

But in the end it wasn't just a domestic credit crisis that brought that country to its knees -- it was a much more serious case of social corruption and mistrust, an ailment so deeply entrenched in their national psyche that it could only be wiped out with the help of a deep and painful crisis. Evidently citizens of the modern Greek state had never been willing or able to organize themselves into a properly functioning society.

For a third of the country's families, the state had always been viewed as nothing more than a convenient source of livelihood (one million Greeks are employed in the public sector -- in a country of just 11 million, or roughly three million households). For the wealthier third of the population, the state was nothing but a nasty, enormous and usually very avoidable layer of overhead for their highly individualistic lifestyles. And for the demoralized and disillusioned final third, the ones that were once upon a time considered to be their country's "middle class," the state was nothing but a desperate, worthless and unavoidable source of financial punishment. The publicly-employed third are still draining that nation's coffers at a remarkable rate; most of the wealthier or self-employed know exactly how to avoid paying taxes; and the former middle class is now rapidly losing its historical ability to prop up the state through its own economic activity and taxes.

A society becomes truly bankrupt when the breakdown of the social trust bond (the foundational relationship between the state and its shareholders) eventually morphs into a form of extreme individualism among the majority of its citizens -- and that's exactly what is happening in Greece now. The public employees are angry and can't imagine having to sacrifice an inch; the wealthy are angrier because they have never believed in contributing; and the relentless squeeze of the middle class is now translating into a national panic and the beginnings of a brain-drain. It is unfortunate that it took a crisis this deep and this painful for Greeks to begin realizing what was wrong with the way they organized themselves over the past few decades, but I remain optimistic that my birth country will eventually come out of this mess as a wiser, more functional society -- and hopefully the world economy will manage to contain the spread of this very localized infection.

For the rest of us, however, there should be a fairly obvious lesson in all this: Resist and refute the siren songs of an emerging class of anti-establishment, ultra right wing (previously fringe) politicians whose populist messages about an ever-shrinking role for governments are sometimes quite catchy among the uninformed. It is perfectly reasonable and responsible for us all to be demanding more accountability, transparency and efficiency from our public service providers -- but it's wrong to assume that the path to more prosperity is through ever lower taxes and less government. The more we try to erode the social trust bond and shift the pendulum away from supporting the common good, the more we risk putting ourselves on that same slippery slope of pure individualism that is now wrecking the livelihoods of millions of Greeks.

 
Greece, the country that once upon a time was busy inventing democracy, philosophy and the notions of social justice for the world, has suddenly earned a reputation as one of the most reckless nations...
Greece, the country that once upon a time was busy inventing democracy, philosophy and the notions of social justice for the world, has suddenly earned a reputation as one of the most reckless nations...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:53 AM on 10/07/2011
The Harper government has shown Canadians how to be like the Greeks. Take Tony Clement. Please take him. Throw him in the fake lake with rocks tied around his neck. Then take Baird. Please please take Baird. Then Peter Mackay - please Santa I will be really really good. Two million to fly from Vancouver and back to greet vets whom the Harper government is treating like dogs. C' mon. A pay out for losing a leg instead of a pension for life. How low can you get.
photo
Kai-HK
Don't Share My Wealth! Share My Work Ethic!
12:13 AM on 10/07/2011
Mr Souvaloitis:

Greece stands as a cautionary tale against the welfare state and the folly of borrowing your way to prosperity. As many European welfare states in Europe having faced a crisis earlier or facing crises now and turning away from those failed and ruinous policies, it is imperative that the US learn from these disasters and move to reduce government spending, dial back failed Keynesian stimuli, and focus on what works: encouraging autonomous real private sector growth and jobs.

Greece stands as a testament to big government bankruptcy.

kai
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
11:57 PM on 10/06/2011
Good article.

The socialists like to talk about rights and entitlements, but never about duties and responsibilities.
If you truly believe the state owes you a living then you should also believe you have an obligations to contribute to the state.
But it doesn't work out that way.
Socialist greed and sloth destroy any chance of it working.
01:41 AM on 10/07/2011
From where I sit....socialists who want entitlements without responsibilities are no different than capitalists who want things their way while they do their best to get out of their responsibilities.

SOMEBODY has to pay taxes....and passing the buck....leaves us just where we are, in bad shape.
You do not have a "small" government in charge of a "BIG" country....but that is a topic for another time.
SOMEBODY has to pay taxes.....

Sadly, the fringe elements are in charge, though I see more from the hard right than the left at this time.
America needs its Repug and Dem moderates who can negotiate and compromise....NOT the wingnuts who would rather destroy the country than even consider compromise.

Socialist greed and sloth?
Or capitalist greed while working to screw everybody else over to get maximum profits?
Either extreme (or both together) could do terrible financial damage.
09:11 PM on 10/06/2011
I am not Greek, but I am deeply offended by this mishmash of stereotypes and generalizations. The author is determined to blame the victims for the failure of the global financial system. He makes nothing but sweeping generalizations about the feelings and motivations of his invented three classes of people. Then he tops it off with the use of the word "infection".

If the Greek society is to blame, then what happened to Iceland, Ireland, Portugal, and Spain?

I suppose Greek immigrants "infected" them all.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mrfreeze
A Disciple of Nietzsche
05:40 PM on 10/06/2011
I think far too little attention has been paid to the "on-the-street" view of the crisis in Greece. Thanks to Andreas for this interesting essay. I have heard that Greece suffers from a total lack of tax collection which has fueled many problems. Of course, when the citizens lack any confidence in their government, institutions or for that matter their neighbors, why have any skin in the game?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NorthSide
04:15 PM on 10/06/2011
Reduction of the government role is not just desirable, but inevitable. For example, the Greek national railroad has an annual wage bill 4 times greater than its annual revenues. One may debate on how prifitable a railroad must be, or how much it should be subsidized, but the current situation is insane. I suspect what will end up happening is that Greece will withdraw from the Eurozone, reintroduce the drachma, and then run the printing presses 24-hours, trying to pay everybody off in worthless shinplasters.
09:50 AM on 10/06/2011
"But in the end it wasn't just a domestic credit crisis that brought that country to its knees -- it was a much more serious case of social corruption and mistrust, an ailment so deeply entrenched in their national psyche that it could only be wiped out with the help of a deep and painful crisis"

I'd be surprised NOT to see this exact recounting in the future of how the US. economy and government tanked if they don't come to some realizations soon that the 'Other 99%' are just that: 99% of the labour force, tax base, and voting demographic. Money and corruption in politics and the running of that country's economy has gone largely overlooked for too long, and the 99% deserve the FREE country that their ancestors founded. Don't let the USA become the next Greece. If Greece's problems don't lead to a tectonic change in world economics and politics, the USA's surely would.
04:36 PM on 10/06/2011
All brought on by the Republican propaganda machine and 24 years (out of 33) of Republican policy in the USA. Corruption, pollution, and elitism are their creed and they wear it proudly on their sleeves. Hate, fear, greed, jealousy, and bigotry is their message and they chant it relentlessly. Capitalism uber alles is their quest and they bank it unceasingly..........at the expense of the planet and everyone on it.

It will take a lot before we get our country back, but step one is to join in the fight:

www.getmoneyout.com
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
12:00 AM on 10/07/2011
Thats's rich!
Blaming Europe's socialist problems on America.

Sociailst greed destroyed Greece, and it will destroy Europe.