Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Anne Theriault


Are You Man Enough for This Dare, David Gilmour?

Posted: 09/25/2013 5:31 pm

Dear David Gilmour,

As a woman writer I'd like to say "thank you."

No, honestly, thank you.

Thank you for being privileged enough, culturally tone-deaf enough, and even just plain stupid enough to say that you don't love women writers enough to teach their works in your class. Thank you for saying what so many other male professors think but are afraid to admit. Thank you for opening up this huge can of worms that most people were happy enough to pretend doesn't exist.

Thank you for reminding me that, as a writer who happens to be female, I will always be a woman first and a writer second.

Oh and thank you especially for throwing in that little racial comment about how you also don't love Chinese writers, because you might as well shit all the beds while you're at it, right?

But thank you. Thank you for proving how very unequal the world is when it comes to female writers and queer writers and trans writers and any writer whose skin isn't lily-white. Thank you for pulling back the curtain and showing the dark, misogynist, racist underbelly of academia. Because when people like you pull shit like this, everyone is finally forced to pull their collective heads out of the sand and accept how very biased the academic world is.

Look, I'm not here to tell you what literature you should love or not love. None of us can help which writers resonate with us while others, though we can admit that they are technically proficient, brilliant with language and certainly not without talent, fail to move us. We like who we like. I get that.

What I don't get is how very little self-reflection there seems to be in your discussion of which writers you love and why. Have you ever wondered why you might possess such a bias against female writers, Canadian writers, and (apparently) Chinese writers? Have you considered how your own professors and their prejudices have warped your perspective and taste? Have you thought about the fact that your own relative privilege means that without serious thought and introspection it's going to be a real challenge for you to understand the context and nuance of writers who don't fit the mold of cis-gender white male?

And maybe what I really want to know is if you were ever up for that challenge, and if yes, when you got so literarily lazy that you could no longer stretch yourself enough to inhabit a skin that didn't resemble your own. Because that's what the best literature does, right? It takes us completely outside of ourselves and forces us to view the world from a completely different perspective. If done well enough, that experience changes us. Hopefully it makes us better people. I don't understand how you could ever become a better person if you only ever read books with protagonists whose take on the world is, ultimately, not so very different from your own.

I also want to tell you that as a professor, your first responsibility is to your students, not yourself. Like a good book, a good professor should change a student. The best teachers that I've had in my life have been the ones who've taken me out of myself and made me see the world in an entirely different way. Passion for what you teach is, of course, incredibly important and can't be discounted, but so, too, is the ability to extend yourself beyond your own petty likes and dislikes in order to give your students a well-rounded view of literature.

How can you possibly be doing that when every year you devote all of your time to re-hashing all of your favourite books? How can you open someone else's eyes when you refuse to do anything but perpetuate your own biases? And honestly, if you can't challenge yourself when it comes to how and what you read, how can you ever challenge anyone else?

Finally, I want to ask you how, as someone who is a writer and who also happens to be female, I am supposed to process this. When you say that you "teach only the best," what should I take away from that? Am I supposed to just sadly shake my head and assume that my vagina* prevents me from ever writing anything interesting or good? Am I supposed to laugh in a world-weary way and say, "well, that's just one man's opinion," as if your opinion isn't symptomatic of a much larger problem within academia? Or am I supposed to think that you are somehow trying to throw down the gauntlet, as if you could maybe bully women into writing something that you love?

Because the thing is, I've got my own gauntlet to throw down.

I've got a dare for you, David Gilmour. I dare you to spend six months reading nothing but writers who aren't white cis males. Read female writers. Read Chinese writers. Read queer and trans and disabled writers. Read something that's difficult for you to love, then take a deep breath and try harder to love it. Immerse yourself in worlds and thoughts and perspectives that are incredibly different from your own. Find a book that can change you and then let yourself be changed.

I'll even put together a top-notch reading list, if you like.

In return, I will let you teach me to love one of the books on your curriculum. I live in Toronto; I can easily audit one of your classes. Prove to me that you're a decent professor, and that the books that you teach can, in fact, change me the way that the best literature can and should.

I'm totally up for this if you are.


Anne Thériault

Loading Slideshow...
  • 'Are You There God, It's Me Margaret' By Judy Blume

    Yearling | $6.99 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Are-You-There-God-Margaret/dp/0440404193" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "It tackles religion, the awkwardness of adolescence, and the weird contraptions that women used to use when they first got their periods. (References to the "belt" definitely confused me as a kid.)" -Kathleen Massara, Editor, Huffington Post Arts

  • 'The Handmaid's Tale' By Margaret Atwood

    Anchor | $10.20 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Handmaids-Tale-Margaret-Atwood/dp/038549081X" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "In the near future, the United States is overthrown by a group called the Sons of Jacob. The bank accounts of women and other undesirables are frozen, and a group known as Handmaids become the hosts for the future children of the ruling class. This book will haunt you, and is a reminder of how easy it is for extremists to take over... Once they do, the target is often women. (No thanks, Santorum!)" -Kathleen Massara, Editor, Huffington Post Arts

  • 'A Room Of One's Own' By Virginia Woolf

    Mariner Books | $10.40 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Room-Ones-Own-Virginia-Woolf/dp/0156787334" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Zoë Triska, Associate Editor, Huffington Post Books

  • 'Diving Into The Wreck' By Adrienne Rich

    Norton | $10.55 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Diving-Into-The-Wreck-1971-1972/dp/0393311635" target="_hplink">Amazon</a>

  • 'The Wife Of Bath' By Geoffrey Chaucer

    Bedford/St. Martin's | $12.32 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Wife-Bath-Studies-Contemporary-Criticism/dp/0312111282" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Zoë Triska, Associate Editor, Huffington Post Books

  • 'As You Like It' By William Shakespeare

    Simon & Schuster | $5.99 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/You-Like-Folger-Shakespeare-Library/dp/074348486X" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> "I feel like he always includes extremely strong female characters, especially for the time period." -Zoë Triska, Associate Editor, Huffington Post Books

  • 'Madame Bovary' By Gustave Flaubert

    Bantam Classics | $5.95 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Madame-Bovary-Classics-Gustave-Flaubert/dp/0553213415" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> -Zoë Triska, Associate Editor, Huffington Post Books

  • 'The Virgin Suicides' By Jeffrey Eugenides

    Picador | $10.99 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Virgin-Suicides-A-Novel/dp/0312428812/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1332869067&sr=1-1" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "A much better pick for women than Middlesex...for some reason, he is REALLY able to capture what it is like to be a teenage girl in that book." -Zoë Triska, Associate Editor, Huffington Post Books

  • 'Deenie' By Judy Blume

    Delacorte Books for Young Readers | $8.99 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Deenie-Judy-Blume/dp/0385739850" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Zoë Triska, Associate Editor, Huffington Post Books

  • 'Little Women' By Louisa May Alcott

    Signet Classics | $3.95 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Little-Signet-Classics-Louisa-Alcott/dp/0451529308" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Zoë Triska, Associate Editor, Huffington Post Books

  • 'Seventh Heaven' By Alice Hoffman

    Putnam Adult | $11.28 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Seventh-Heaven-Alice-Hoffman/dp/0399135359" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> "A coming of age novel for those who came of age in the 1960s. Beautifully written story about a brassy divorcee (yes, that's what they were called) moving into a Long Island subdivision (think Levittown) in the 1950s that busts the myth of life behind the white picket fences." -Ann Brenoff, Senior Writer, Huffington Post L.A.

  • 'The Women's Room' By Marilyn French

    Summit | $12.00 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Marilyn-French-The-Womens-Room/dp/B000O9M2G2/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1332874504&sr=1-2" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "The best novel of the women's liberation movement" -Ann Brenoff, Senior Writer, Huffington Post L.A.

  • 'Fear Of Flying' By Erica Jong

    NAL Trade | $10.88 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Fear-Flying-Erica-Jong/dp/0451209435/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1332874875&sr=1-1" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "This one rocked my world! It was ground-breaking -- uninhibited story of Isadora Wing." -Ann Brenoff, Senior Writer, Huffington Post L.A.

  • 'Hateship, Friendship, Courtship, Loveship, Marriage' By Alice Munro

    Vintage | $10.20 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/dp/0375727434/ref=rdr_ext_tmb" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> " -Meredith Melnick, Editor, The Huffington Post Nutrition and Fitness

  • 'Housekeeping' By Marilynne Robinson

    Picador | $10.20 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Housekeeping-A-Novel-Marilynne-Robinson/dp/0312424094" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> -Zoë Triska, Associate Editor, Huffington Post Books

  • 'Frida: A Biography Of Frida Kahlo' By Hayden Herrera

    Harper Perennial | $16.49 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Frida-A-Biography-Kahlo/dp/0060085894" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Kimberly Brooks, Founding Editor, Huffington Post Arts and Editor, Huffington Post Science

  • 'The Twilight Series' By Stephenie Meyer

    Little, Brown and Co. | $11.08 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Twilight-Book-1-Stephenie-Meyer/dp/0316160172" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> "Just to know what 500 Million girls got so excited about!" -Kimberly Brooks, Founding Editor, Huffington Post Arts and Editor, Huffington Post Science

  • 'The Awakening' By Kate Chopin

    Avon | $4.99 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Awakening-Kate-Chopin/dp/0380002450" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> -Lori Leibovich, Executive Lifestyle Editor, Huffington Post

  • 'The Bell Jar' By Sylvia Plath

    Harper Perennial Modern Classics | $10.04 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Bell-Jar-Sylvia-Plath/dp/0061148512" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> -Lori Leibovich, Executive Lifestyle Editor, Huffington Post

  • 'Bossypants' By Tina Fey

    Reagan Arthur Books | $16.19 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Bossypants-Tina-Fey/dp/0316056863" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Lori Leibovich, Executive Lifestyle Editor, Huffington Post

  • 'Franny And Zooey' By J.D. Salinger

    Little, Brown and Company | $6.99 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Franny-Zooey-J-D-Salinger/dp/0316769495" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Farah Miller, Managing Editor, Huffington Post Parents

  • 'The Lovely Bones' By Alice Sebold

    Little Brown | $14.10 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Lovely-Bones-A-Novel/dp/0316666343" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Ann Brenoff, Senior Writer, Huffington Post L.A.

  • 'When Everything Changed' By Gail Collins

    Little, Brown and Company | $18.47 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/When-Everything-Changed-Amazing-American/dp/0316059544" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Meredith Melnick, Editor, The Huffington Post Nutrition and Fitness

  • 'Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit' By Jeanette Winterson

    Grove Press | $10.17 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Oranges-Are-Not-Only-Fruit/dp/0802135161" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> "An insanely ambitious novel which is really a memoir and doesn't apologize for that." Margaret Wheeler Johnson, Editor, Huffington Post Women

  • 'The Girls Of Slender Means' By Muriel Spark

    New Directions | $9.44 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Girls-Slender-Means-Directions-Classic/dp/081121379X" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> "A women's boarding house novel is almost as great as a girls boarding school novel, especially if a bomb and a Schiaparelli dress are involved." -Margaret Wheeler Johnson, Editor, Huffington Post Women

  • 'The Liars Club' By Mary Karr

    Penguin | $8.47 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Liars-Club-A-Memoir/dp/0143035746" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> "My mother drove me across the Sabine bridge ten or twenty times in my childhood, and I never knew our safe passage could be a testament to her sanity until I read Karr's account of being charioted across it by her own mother who was in the middle of a psychotic break. Also a really fine portrait of flawed fatherhood. Karr is the master of revealing her (real) characters' dignity and crazy in equal turns." -Margaret Wheeler Johnson, Editor, Huffington Post Women

  • 'Get To Work: . . . And Get A Life, Before It's Too Late' By Linda R. Hirshman

    Penguin | $12.00 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Get-Work-Life-Before-Late/dp/014303894X/ref=ntt_at_ep_dpt_2" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "Her strategic plan for women: "don't study art," "never quit a job until you have another one" -Emily Peck, Managing Editor, Huffington Post Business

  • 'Nickel And Dimed: On (Not) Getting By In America' By Barbara Ehrenreich

    Holt Paperbacks | $1.99 |<a href="√" target="_hplink"> Amazon.com</a> -Meredith Melnick, Editor, The Huffington Post Nutrition and Fitness

  • 'The Beauty Myth: How Images Of Beauty Are Used Against Women' By Naomi Wolf

    Harper Perennial | $10.19 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Beauty-Myth-Images-Against/dp/0060512180" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Laura Schocker, Associate Editor, Huffinton Post Healthy Living

  • 'Women's Bodies, Women's Wisdom' By Christiane Northrup

    Bantam | $12.20 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Womens-Bodies-Wisdom-Revised-Edition/dp/0553386735" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "It's the body bible for every woman" -Alana B. Elias Kornfeld, Senior Editor, International Huffington Post Media Group,

  • 'Half The Sky: Turning Oppression Into Opportunity For Women Worldwide' By Nicholas D. Kristof

    Knopf | $19.11 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Half-Sky-Oppression-Opportunity-Worldwide/dp/0307267148" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> -Jessica Prois, Editor, Huffington Post Impact

  • 'The Woman At The Washington Zoo: Writings On Politics, Family, And Fate' By Marjorie Williams

    PublicAffairs | $ | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Woman-Washington-Zoo-Writings/dp/1586483633" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "Marjorie Williams has an incredible gift for profiles--the stories she writes about her subjects, from barbara bush to D.C. socialite, are so nuanced, so detailed and so intimate. The book also has a must-read collection of her columns about being a working woman and mother." -Bianca Bosker, Senior Editor, Huffington Post Tech

  • 'Last Night I Dreamed Of Peace: The Diary Of Dang Thuy Tram' By Dang Thuy Tram

    Broadway | $11.07 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Last-Night-Dreamed-Peace-Diary/dp/0307347389/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1332956242&sr=1-1" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "Not only is this book unique because it offers a Vietnamese perspective on the Vietnam War, but it also one of the few to offer a female point of view. Thuy Tram's diary offers an intimate look both into the war and into the life of a 20-something faced with becoming a woman in very challenging circumstances." -Michelle Persad, Intern, Huffington Post Women

  • 'The Feminine Mystique' By Betty Friedan

    Norton | 11.75 | <a href="http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/feminine-mystique-betty-friedan/1100622672?ean=9780393322576&itm=1&usri=feminine+mystique" target="_hplink">Barnesandnoble.com</a>

  • 'Backlash' By Susan Faludi

    Crown | $14.95 | <a href="http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/backlash-susan-faludi/1102808010?ean=9780307345424&itm=2&usri=susan+faludi" target="_hplink">Barnesandnoble.com</a>

  • 'Collected Poems' By Edna St. Vincent Millay

    HarperCollins | $17.57 | <a href="http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/collected-poems-edna-st-vincent-millay/1100151003?ean=9780062015273&itm=2&usri=edna+st.+vincent+millay" target="_hplink">Barnesandnoble.com</a>

  • 'Big Girls Don't Cry' By Rebecca Traister

    Free Press | $26 | <a href="http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/big-girls-dont-cry-rebecca-traister/1100630988" target="_hplink">Barnesandnoble.com</a>

  • 'Forever' By Judy Blume

    Simon Pulse | $8.99 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Forever-Judy-Blume/dp/1416934006/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1333041409&sr=1-1" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> "I read this book shortly before I became sexually active. This book, featuring Planned Parenthood, spared me from teenage pregnancy." Julia Jensen

  • 'The Help' By Kathryn Stockett

    Amy Einhorn Books/Putnam | $14.82 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Help-Kathryn-Stockett/dp/0399155341" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Sara Hadley

  • 'The Guernsey Literary And Potato Peel Pie Society' By Mary Ann Shaffer

    The Dial Press | $15.93 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Guernsey-Literary-Potato-Peel-Society/dp/0385340990" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Sara Hadley

  • 'The Night Circus' By Erin Morgenstern

    Doubleday | $17.79 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Night-Circus-Erin-Morgenstern/dp/0385534639" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Sara Hadley

  • 'The Lantern' By Deborah Lawrenson

    Harper | $13.55 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Lantern-Novel-Deborah-Lawrenson/dp/0062049690" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Sara Hadley

  • 'South Of Superior' By Ellen Airgood

    Riverhead Hardcover | $13.98 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/South-Superior-Ellen-Airgood/dp/1594487936" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Sara Hadley

  • 'The Language Of Trees' By Ilie Ruby

    William Morrow Paperbacks | $11.69 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Language-Trees-A-Novel/dp/0061898643" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Sara Hadley

  • 'The Penderwicks: A Summer Tale Of Four Sisters, Two Rabbits, And A Very Interesting Boy' By Jeanne Birdsall

    Knopf Books | $10.85 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Penderwicks-Sisters-Rabbits-Interesting/dp/0375831436" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Sara Hadley

  • 'Still Here: Embracing Aging, Changing, And Dying' By Ram Dass

    Riverhead Books | $10.09 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Still-Here-Embracing-Aging-Changing/dp/1573228710" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Rae Carson

  • 'Female Chauvinist Pigs' By Ariel Levy

    Free Press | $9.74 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Female-Chauvinist-Pigs-Raunch-Culture/dp/0743284283/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1333390202&sr=1-1" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Lauren Hedinger

  • 'The Paper Garden' By Molly Peacock

    Bloomsbury USA | $13.60 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/The-Paper-Garden-Artist-Begins/dp/1608196976/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1333406740&sr=1-1" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Shaunee Power

  • 'In The Land Of The Grasshopper Song' By Mary Ellicott Arnold

    Bison Books | $15.56 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/In-Land-Grasshopper-Song-Klamath/dp/0803236379" target="_hplink">Amazon.com</a> Submitted by HuffPost Women reader Shaunee Power

  • 'Their Eyes Were Watching God' By Zora Neale Hurston

    Harper Perennial Modern Classics | $10.87 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Their-Eyes-Were-Watching-God/dp/0061120065/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1333471784&sr=1-1" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> Submitted by Journalist/Author Rebecca Traister

  • 'A Tree Grows In Brooklyn' By Betty Smith

    Harper Perennial Modern Classics| $11.55 | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/A-Tree-Grows-Brooklyn-P-S/dp/0061120073/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1333472090&sr=1-1" target="_hplink">Amazon.com </a> Submitted by Journalist/Author Rebecca Traister


Follow Anne Theriault on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@anne_theriault