Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Avi Benlolo

GET UPDATES FROM Avi Benlolo
 

Karen Klein Is the Rosa Parks of Bullying

Posted: 06/23/2012 9:46 am

Bravo to Torontonian Max Sidorov for standing up to the bus bullies of Greece, New York and for not being a bystander, despite the distance and the ease of looking the other way. As has been widely reported in the past 24 hours, 68-year-old bus monitor Karen Klein suffered a malicious verbal attack by a group of grade seven students on a school bus, experiencing the sort of fear and shame that many of us have gone through at some point in our lives. Because of Sidorov, the response to her victimization has been overwhelmingly compassionate.

Although Sidorov was simply hoping to raise a few thousand dollars to send Klein on a special vacation following her ordeal, his campaign raised more than $500,000 (and counting) in just two days, exceeding all expectations and demonstrating that people are profoundly tired of the intolerance and disrespect so prevalent in society today. There seems to be an increasing level of contempt for older adults and much of that is due to the breakdown of values and lack of education about compassion, caring, empathy and simple respect for one another.

As the saying goes, "kids will be kids," but the level of animosity, degradation, harassment and the length of time the bullying persisted was simply outrageous. As a human rights organization that teaches thousands of students every year about the consequences of bullying and hatred, we often talk about perpetrators and bystanders. What is significant in this episode is the lack of intervention from anyone else on the bus, as well as the apparent lack of concern evidenced by the student perpetrators regarding the taping and posting of the incident.

It is important to point out that this was not merely a matter of bullying. We should clearly understand this event for what it was -- a matter of age discrimination laced with sexual profanities -- and an episode that has raised the profile of the discrimination faced by many older adults and the elderly in societies across North America.

We think that the decision by the victim to not press charges is commendable. However, more than apologies are needed to change an environment in which children believe bullying behaviour is acceptable; Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Center's educational programs are based on the premise that the solution to hate and disrespectful behaviour is continuous education that advocates against bullying and indignity, and teaches empathy and compassion for others. To achieve those educational goals we have designed the Tour for Humanity, a mobile, bus-based Tolerance Center that will visit schools and institutions to focus on the issues of bullying and hate.

Buses seem to be a focus for these sorts of episodes; perhaps because they bring people from different backgrounds closely together they can sometimes be a flashpoint of both disrespect and intimidation, or of more positive interactions, including simple courtesies like people giving up their seats to strangers.

Klein's refusal to interact with the bullies may yet become a wake-up call for society -- in much the same way Rosa Parks' refusal to move to the back of the bus was at the dawn of the civil rights movement -- to mobilize around the issue, not just of bullying, but of the need to respect one another and to treat each other with kindness and dignity.

 

Follow Avi Benlolo on Twitter: www.twitter.com/avibenlolo

FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 27
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:52 PM on 06/24/2012
Being assaulted on a bus, and then having that incident made public does not make Karen Klein synonymous with Rosa Parks. I like Karen, and I like that she's getting a vacation and some money. BUT....

You have overshot Avi.

You shouldn't re-appropriate pivotal civil rights figures and moments because of vague similarities.

Rosa Parks was a hero, and a part of an organized civil rights movement that sought to fight against racism within a society and the laws of that society. She was fighting against systemic and overt racism.

Karen Klein was a victim who was bullied by terrible children... She was not a part of an organized (or even spontaneous) social movement, and she was not being targeted by unjust laws or a flagrant denial of rights.

Only Karen saw justice as a result of the media attention her incident has received. Rosa Parks worked hard to gain rights and acceptance for a disenfranchised group of people.

There are enough differences here that should lead you to avoid any false equivalencies between both individuals and their individual plights and incidents.
12:02 PM on 06/24/2012
I would say there's no comparison between Rosa Parks and this woman. I'm baffled that she would sit there and take this abuse, given that she was in a position of power and was there to do what she didn't - monitor the kids' behavior and report misbehavior. Was there no other adult who could control this situation on the bus? If she's uncomfortable speaking up in this kind of situation, then why was she there in the first place? This is not to say the kids weren't monsters, they were, but her taking this abuse does not make her a hero like Rosa Parks who stood up to bullies in a much more difficult situation.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
YankeeCanuck
dog
10:46 PM on 06/23/2012
Comparing her to Rosa Parks is one large stretch. It's especially ludicrous considering Mr. Benlolo's last column which praised Canada for standing with one of the biggest perpetrators of bullying in the world.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:25 PM on 06/23/2012
Coming it a bit high don't you think Avi? Nice try on the bandwagon jumping though.
Lame.
08:03 PM on 06/23/2012
Klein ≠ Parks

Benlolo = Schmuck
photo
thereisonlyoneparty
more amazing than you
07:33 PM on 06/23/2012
This article is awful.

Rosa Parks was not someone who was unable to do her job. She was not a big load that took a beating because she was someone who was placed in a situation that she should not have been in.

Worse, this is all falsely presenting Ms. Parks as someone who was in the wrong place at the wrong time. She was not. She was actively involved in a form of resistance against discriminatory policies that she found abhorrent. She was trained. She used that training when needed.

This bus monitor was the opposite of Rosa Parks. She had training, but decided to sit there and take it instead of standing up for herself and utilizing her training. She is not a hero for taking a beating.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
YankeeCanuck
dog
10:51 PM on 06/23/2012
I have to agree with your critique of the article. IMHO, the bus monitor was acting on one principle of nonviolence training and that is not to escalate an abusive situation. Sometimes asserting oneself verbally under those circumstances can cause escalation. Laying a hand on any of those kids was absolutely out of the question.
THe weird thing about it is the ordinariness of Greece NY, a quiet middle class suburb of Rochester,NY. If this can happen there, it can and does happen in communities al over the country.
12:07 PM on 06/24/2012
How would school ever work if adults didn't speak up when challenged by students? This isn't about non-violence training leading to this situation. It's about kids being allowed to be unsupervised at a time when the school was responsible for maintaining order.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:06 PM on 06/23/2012
Females of all ages are still the worst bullies. There is a case of this going on in my workplace currently. The bullies range in age 23, 38 and 45 yrs. respectively. There is bullying everywhere not just in schools. People can wear pink and hold protests and marches all they want - it's never going to stop because we are still uncivilized. War is a form of bullying and so it the abuse of animals. I am glad this woman is getting support.
01:27 PM on 06/23/2012
bit much comparing it to Rosa but even if she pressed no charges the state should have pressed charges to send a message about its standards and the expected behaviour of those who live in or visit that state. if she gets all the money great and good for her but 500 000 is enough any extra should go to a charity or organisation supporting others who have faced things like this.
01:23 PM on 06/23/2012
Here we go....another media type looking for some recognition by suggesting this women should be compared to Rosa Parks. Not only an epic fail but an insult to Rosa Parks and everything she stood for.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
01:15 PM on 06/23/2012
All these kids are doing is mimicing the behaviour of the liberal media.
They bully people they don't agree with all the time, look how they treated Sarah Palin or Joe the Plumber, not to mention Carrie Prejean.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
see-ellen2001
11:18 AM on 06/23/2012
She is NOT a Rosa Parks. Having a whole legal, governmental and social system enforcing the oppression of a group of people is hardly comparable.
10:17 AM on 06/23/2012
Oh for God's sakes...

What happened to this woman is unfortunate and yes she deserves a nice vacation.

But she doesn't deserve $500,000 and she sure as hell doesn't deserve to be compared to Rosa Parks.
11:21 AM on 06/23/2012
Why the heck doesn't she deserve the kindness of strangers, no matter the price tag. Would it please you if it was only ten dollars? You sound jealous of the attention and the money.
01:21 PM on 06/23/2012
No, he's not jealous, he's merely pointed out how ridiculous the whole thing is. What happened to this woman happens thousands of times a day to various people and because her situation is broadcast on the internet, she should get 500k? How does that make any sense?
02:08 PM on 06/24/2012
Wow, so the bully speaks. I hope the previous posters are content to know they are in good company.