Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bob Rae

GET UPDATES FROM Bob Rae
 

Why I'm Opposing Canada's Economic (In)Action Plan

Posted: 03/22/2013 9:51 am

Yesterday Finance Minister Jim Flaherty introduced his government's budget plan for Canada. My Liberal colleagues have rightly renamed it Canada's Economic (In)Action Plan. It is in reality a political smoke screen, replete with gimmicks designed to convince Canadians that the Conservatives, somehow, are in fact balancing the books. This could not be further from the truth.

We are facing many challenges, with high youth unemployment, hundreds of thousands of unfilled jobs placing a serious strain on economic growth. In yesterday's budget there was no new or increased funding for skills training, infrastructure projects or Aboriginal education, an area that is particularly important for Canada's future prosperity.

On job creation, despite asserting that fixing labour shortages is the most important issue facing the country, this Conservative government did nothing to address the issue. They simply repackaged existing programs under new names, as is the case with the "Jobs Grant." This program will not be up and running for another five years, and will require cash-strapped provinces to come up with funding they don't have to help pay for the program. At the same time, the budget freezes skills training funding at 2007 pre-recession levels, which when factoring in inflation, actually represents a 10% cut to training dollars for provinces and territories. The skills shortage is a real problem and the government needs to step up with a real investment.

Budget 2013 will hurt Canada's already weakened economy, and the EI premium hikes contained therein will cost Canadians. The job market still hasn't recovered from the recession, and with 220,000 more unemployed Canadians than before the recession hit, it's even more difficult for young Canadians to find a job. But all the government is offering up is a $19 million advertising campaign, an initiative that will translate into zero new jobs or improved skills for our youth.

Meanwhile, the Conservatives' much-touted infrastructure plan is, in fact, a reduction in current funding. New funding for the Building Canada Fund drops from $1.7 billion in 2013-14 to $210 million for each of the two following years. So ask yourself, does Canada actually have no real infrastructure needs over the next two years or is this just a cynical move designed to meet a politically imposed deficit elimination deadline? Canada's needs have clearly taken a back seat to the needs of the Conservative Party.

Story continues below slideshow

Loading Slideshow...
  • 2013 BUDGET HIGHLIGHTS

    Revenues for 2013-14 forecast at $263.9 billion, spending at $282.6 billion, deficit at $18.7 billion. Deficit projected to drop to $6.6 billion in 2014-15 and become an $800-million surplus in 2015-16. With files from Althia Raj and The Canadian Press.

  • Tackling The Skills Gap

    The Tories plan to create a Canada Job Grant that will provide $15,000 or more per person -- up to $5,000 provided by the federal government, the rest matched by the province/territory and the employer. Nearly 130,000 Canadians are expected to benefit when the new grant is fully implemented in 2017-2018. Essentially, this is the government saying it is taking training out of the hands of provincial governments because it hasn’t worked and placing it in the hands of individuals. The Canada Job Grant will replace the Labour Market Agreements the feds signed with the provinces, which expire in 2014.

  • Helping Manufacturers

    Manufacturing and small business get tax-credits introduced in past budgets extended to help spur investment and growth. There will be $1.4 billion in tax relief for manufacturers by extending the temporary accelerated capital cost allowance for new investment in machinery and equipment. And hundreds of millions for small business owners.

  • Infrastructure Spending

    The government has pledged more than $53 billion in infrastructure spending, including $47 billion in new funding over 10 years. This includes $32.2 billion over 10 years for a “Community Improvement Fund” to build roads and public transit as well as recreational facilities and other community infrastructure projects. The Fund will consist of an index Gas Tax Fund and the incremental GST Rebate for Municipalities.

  • Military Spending

    Military spending will be re-jigged that it is modeled on the ship building strategy and aimed at creating more jobs in Canada and key domestic capabilities with an eye towards exports.

  • Foreign Affairs - Aid Agency Cancelled

    The budget has cancelled the Canadian International Development Agency, the primary agency responsible for foreign aid. Its duties will be merged into the Department of Foreign Affairs.

  • Tax Evasion Snitch Line

    The government says it is aggressively going after tax avoiders/and closing tax loopholes. They are launching a “Stop International Tax Evasion Program” where the Canada Revenue Agency will pay individuals with knowledge of “major international tax non-compliance” a percentage of the tax collected as a result of information provided. The CRA will only pay a reward if the information results in total additional assessments exceeding $100,000 in federal tax.

  • Public Service Cuts

    Two departments -- Canada Revenue Agency and the Department of Fisheries and Oceans -- will see big cuts. Departments will see a 5 per cent cut in their travel budgets. The government also says in the budget it intends to work with the public sector unions to “further align overall compensation with other public and private sector employers.”

  • Border Security

    The federal budget says new projects related to Canada's perimeter security deal with the United States will go ahead as planned, despite budget woes south of the border. The federal budget has given the green light to almost a dozen information-sharing and infrastructure projects related to the Beyond the Border initiative between the two countries. The vaunted deal was announced with fanfare by Prime Minister Stephen Harper and U.S. President Barack Obama in December 2011 at the White House. The plan aims to speed the flow of goods and people across the 49th parallel while protecting the continent from a terrorist attack.

  • Tobacco Prices Going Up

    The government wants to reduce import tariffs on a number of goods including baby clothing, skis, snowboards and gold clubs. But it plans to offset the $76-million revenue loss from that by hiking excise taxes on chewing tobacco and other manufactured tobaccos, to bring them in line with cigarette taxes.

  • Affordable Housing

    Finance Minister Jim Flaherty's spring budget commits Ottawa to five more years of funding through the Investment in Affordable Housing program. The level of commitment is the same as in the past: $253 million a year over five years, which needs to be matched by the provinces and territories and can be spent on new construction, renovation, home ownership assistance, rent supplements, shelters and homes for battered spouses. But there's a new twist to the funding. Home construction in the program will support the use of apprentices so that newcomers to the construction trades can build up crucial experience. The budget also commits $100 million over two years to build 250 more units of affordable housing in Nunavut, where homes are so crowded that illness spreads easily and poverty abounds.

As I said last night, the rule in politics remains that when you have nothing to announce, you announce the number over ten years; Mr. Flaherty seems to have adopted this approach too enthusiastically in promoting his "new" infrastructure plan.

Finally, and of great importance, is the Conservatives' continued failure to support Aboriginal Peoples in Canada. The Aboriginal population is significantly younger when compared to the rest of the country , and represents the fastest growing demographic in the country. Unfortunately, in 2013, they continue to endure the worst education outcomes in Canada.

After promising to improve the education and skills of Aboriginal Canadians, Mr. Harper's budget provided not one new dollar for First Nations K-12 education, depriving the economy of a rapidly growing pool of talent, and denying Aboriginal Peoples a prosperous future.

For these glaring weaknesses, among others, the Liberal Party will be opposing this budget. We will be standing with all Canadians who demand a fairer, more sustainable and more prosperous Canada.

MORE ON THE FEDERAL BUDGET

 

Follow Bob Rae on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bobraeMP

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
Yesterday Finance Minister Jim Flaherty introduced his government's budget plan for Canada. My Liberal colleagues have rightly renamed it Canada's Economic (In)Action Plan. It is in reality a politica...
Yesterday Finance Minister Jim Flaherty introduced his government's budget plan for Canada. My Liberal colleagues have rightly renamed it Canada's Economic (In)Action Plan. It is in reality a politica...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 43
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:57 PM on 04/05/2013
RE: Imma Okay - "So your answer is just spend more, spend more, spend more."

My answer would be to spend less, spend less, spend less, on all the frivolous (wasteful) government purchases and or costs - Here are just a few examples:

$24M spent on MPs' temporary meeting rooms

$42M glass dome approved for Parliament

Harper's baseball trip hit taxpayers with $45,000 tab

At $1,450 a night (hotel room), Peter MacKay doing his part for Europe

Feds hire 'cuts' consultant at $90,000 a day

G8 spending included $1,650 to remove bed, $3,500 to move light fixtures

G8/G20 costs include $80M for food, lodging

Libya mission cost $50M, MacKay says

Prisoner increase to cost at least $2B

Royal visit cost Canada $2.57M

Temporary MP offices cost $72M

Libya mission's final costs reach $347M

Conservatives to revise $490B defence spending plan

Ministers defend $23K bill for Davos car rides

RCMP Racks Up $800M In Overtime In 5 Years

Canada Aid To Mali Increased By $13 Million After Donor Conference In Ethiopia

$1 Million Spent To Ship PM's Armoured Cars To India

Military supply ships $1.5B over budget, watchdog says

Contracting out at DND up by $500M despite promises to cut

Conservatives Push $108-Million London Embassy Plan

Not to mention the fake lake and gazebos - Estimates are starting to emerge that the entire 'cost' of 'G8/G20' may just reach the $2 Billion mark.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:58 AM on 04/05/2013
RE: "On job creation, despite asserting that fixing labour shortages is the most important issue facing the country, this Conservative government did nothing - They simply repackaged existing programs under new names..."

"The (2013) Economic Action Plan is Working for You"

The "EAP" has already created 950,000 jobs, lowered taxes and, paved the way for long-term prosperity.
Source: http://plandaction.gc.ca/en

Canada loses 54,500 jobs in March, unemployment rises to 7.2 per cent - the worst jobs performance in almost four years - an unexpectedly big drop that erased a gain in February.
Source: http://www.ctvnews.ca/business/canada-loses-54-500-jobs-in-march-unemployment-rises-to-7-2-per-cent-1.1225328

Canada loses 22,000 jobs in January (2013)
Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2013/02/08/canada-loses-22000-jobs-_n_2645816.html

Statistics Canada reported the country lost 139,000 full-time jobs in July., 2010
Source: http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/story/2010/08/06/canada-job-employment.html#socialcomments

Canadians' debt hits record $1.5 trillion
Source: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/story/2011/06/14/debt-load-trillion.html

Canada falling behind on poverty, inequality, says report
Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2013/02/04/canada-falling-behind-on-_n_2614078.html

Canada's richest 1% getting richer
Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2013/01/28/canadas-richest-1-getti_n_2566885.html

Who really, is 'their' EAP working for?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveCDN
A Progressive Moderate
12:41 PM on 03/26/2013
Thank You Bob Rae for your tireless efforts to shine a light on the (in)action of these Cons. This is a great read for anyone who is skeptical of the smoke & mirrors in 2013 budget.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:07 AM on 04/05/2013
And its just not political rhetoric either - the evidence is there for anyone who wishes to look at it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Imma Okay
01:59 AM on 03/23/2013
So your answer is just spend more, spend more, spend more.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Whistlejackett
Hey stop doing that
05:46 AM on 03/23/2013
And what does 40 billion for 65 un flyable jets mean to you? Or the tens of millions for ad campaigns and the 1812 war? Should I go on?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Imma Okay
01:26 PM on 03/23/2013
Are any of those part of the 2013 budget?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:09 AM on 04/05/2013
Well that is what most politicial/economist advocate - spend more and more on 'their' governmental offices, and its administrators, and less and less on social programs.
11:13 PM on 03/22/2013
Maybe in a few years, when you become the official opposition, more people will listen to you.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:10 AM on 04/05/2013
Many people are now hearing, but not necessarily listening.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stciappelletto
margaritas ante porcos
08:39 PM on 03/22/2013
All I see here is rhetoric.

The Conservatives have largely continued Jean Chretien's small "c" financial conservatism. The result so far is that Canada seems to be in the best shape of the major economies. They also loosened the purse strings somewhat to help the recovery.

So on the one hand I have results, on the other hand I have inflammatory rhetoric.

More could be done on this and that. Well of course, that's a truism. The government always could spend more money on one thing or another. Government can't fix all the world's problems though, so the issue is always where you draw the line even though you could do more.

Although I'm politically to the left of Rae I've found him frustrating in his criticism of the right. His communication style has too much bluster and I never feel like I've learned something new and important from the things he says.

Emotional overtures are not a substitute for disciplined analysis.
09:02 AM on 03/23/2013
How do you explain away the lack of vision and Financial incompetence of the (SIC) conservatives . The Liberals kept the social programs in good shape and balanced the budget . Cons have done neither
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:59 PM on 03/23/2013
Actually the liberals slashed transfer payments to the provinces and then cast the blame on them (see Mike Harris' reign as Ontario premier). I would never, ever vote for Bob Rae. His 4 years as premier where more than enough to demonstrate his leadership style.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stciappelletto
margaritas ante porcos
05:41 PM on 03/23/2013
Actually, the liberals dramatically reduced EI payments for instance, by billions of dollar per year and they did most of the heavy lifting there. 
The 2008 recession wasn't anybody's fault and would have hit the bottom line regardless of who was in power.  
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:11 AM on 04/05/2013
RE: "All I see here is rhetoric...."

Eyes wide shut?
05:21 PM on 03/22/2013
To the Conservatives, social policy is the continuation of p.r. by other means.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lloyd Lloyd
Harper, Canada's Romney - send him packing too..!
05:19 PM on 03/22/2013
Thank you for being an island of sanity Bob in these deceitful, lying times of the reformacons...

Next election they're gone, no matter how much of our money they advertise with...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:00 PM on 03/23/2013
Yes because massively increasing the budget (like what Bob did as Ontario premier) without any real way to pay for it is a fantastic idea. Lets increase welfare rolls 40% in four years like Bob did as premier of Ontario.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:29 AM on 04/05/2013
"Transportation Minister John Baird defended the federal government's plans to get $3 billion in stimulus spending out the door by April, saying unemployed Canadians shouldn't have to wait three months for the Conservatives to create jobs."
Read more: http://www.ctvnews.ca/baird-defends-3b-in-emergency-spending-1.375070

Perhaps 'BIRD' meant three years?

Federal deficit grows by $300M in January (2010)
Source: http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/story/2010/03/26/federal-deficit-january.html

Deficit predicted to hit $155.9B over next 5 years
Read more: http://www.ctvnews.ca/deficit-predicted-to-hit-155-9b-over-next-5-years-1.414776
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:12 AM on 04/05/2013
With you on those sentiments.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lloyd Lloyd
Harper, Canada's Romney - send him packing too..!
12:27 PM on 04/05/2013
I like your flag, lol
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mitch Wolfe
05:07 PM on 03/22/2013
I admire the writer personally, though I do not always agree with him. This is one of those occasions. Some municipal leaders are unhappy there is not more infrastructure funding to the cities in this new Federal budget. Other municipal leaders applaud what the Federal Conservatives are doing in terms of infrastructure funding. It is ironic that in Toronto, the people who will most benefit by expanded public transit are unwilling to pay additional taxes or fees to pay for such additional infrastructure. Yet they and leaders like Bob Rae want the federal government to go further into debt to pay for transit services and other municipal services that the Toronto users don't want to pay for themselves and be taxed on. It was the wishful thinking of Bob Rae when he was Ontario premier in the 90s, that is, borrow today and spend funds you don't have, and somehow, the future will take care of itself, that got Ontario up against the debt wall and nearly bankrupt like Greece is today. The baby boom generation has imposed enough debt on future generations of Canadians. It is time for the federal government and the provincial governments, to suck it up and seriously reduce their deficits and their collective debts. Otherwise, do you want our children and grandchildren to be living in our own Canadian form of bankrupt Greece or Cyprus? I don't.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DirkNeptune
I love raspberry pie, damn it.
11:55 AM on 03/23/2013
So let me get this straight...we don't want to end up like Greece or Cyprus. Great insight.

You must be very smart to be able to figure that out.

I'm tired of you already and this is the first post of yours I've read. Hard to believe they let you blog on here.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mitch Wolfe
08:46 PM on 03/23/2013
DirkNeptune: So we are in agreement. We do not want Canada to end up like Greece or Cyprus. Both these countries are in hock to their lenders. Both countries have such huge debts that their creditors are calling the shots. How did they get that way? By allowing their annual deficits to skyrocket. Bob Rae wants Canada to go further into debt and to be further dependent upon its international creditors. That is the slippery slope to Greece insolvency. Harper and Flaherty want us to avoid that eventuality. What is wrong with that?
04:23 PM on 03/22/2013
Well said. I wish the mainstream media outlets such as CBC, CTV, Global etc would give more air time to the opposition parties after these major announcements. Instead we get one sound bite from each rolled into the nightly coverage with the bulk of such coverage cow towing to the Con spin masters. I miss the days of Barbara Frum and those journalists who were not afraid to hold the feet of the politicians to the fire and either force them to answer a question or at least expose them nationally when they tried deflection instead. We used to get full television coverage of the opposition responses as well. Now all we get is the usual Harper Inc. puppets. I see the new Action Plan ads are all over here and other outlets today to spin the non budget.

As I have posted a few times, this is the Cons 2015 Election Action Campaign to be funded by taxpayers and not a real budget with the interests of the country in sight.

Mr. Rae, you sir, in my opinion may well be the best PM we never had a chance to see in office. I am from Ontario and don't buy the leftover Harris spin - in fact I delighted in reminding those that made fun of the so-called Rae days of how much better that policy was once they found themselves as unemployed public sector workers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Colin Speth
A Claymore for your thoughts
09:10 AM on 03/23/2013
Yeah more exposure to Bob Rae is just what Canadians and the Liberal party needs. Perfect plan. I agree wholeheartedly.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:37 AM on 04/05/2013
RE: " I wish the mainstream media outlets such as CBC, CTV, Global etc would give more air time to the opposition parties after these major announcements."

Stephen Harper vs. the media
Source: http://www2.macleans.ca/2011/03/31/stephen-harper-vs-the-media/
12:45 PM on 03/22/2013
Dear Mr. Rae;

I believe you but I have to say I see nothing new in what you say. When hasn't the Harper governmentTM) not lied, deceived and flim flammed as it has covered up everything from gazebos to the fact that even though our crime rate has dropped 27% it claims it needs three new jails or its statements that it was a real buy to get those fighter jets which wouldn't work in the north and which actually were mindboggling expensive. The list goes on Mr. rae. canadians have to vote out this government and that means the opposing parties need to unify. No matter how much you and Mr. Mulcair etc. disagree on a range of topics you do agree that Harper is destroying Canada and must go.
10:31 PM on 03/22/2013
I agree, there must be some sort of co-operation between the progressives, we can't afford any more harper madness.
photo
scottdee
critical thinking is good
12:28 PM on 03/22/2013
I still think Mr. Rae should have thrown his hat into the leadership race.
12:12 PM on 03/22/2013
Excellent rant.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Swing Left
Artist, Socialist and Cynic.
11:51 AM on 03/22/2013
Another smokescreen budget by the Cons, what Canada needs is investment in jobs and training. It needs investment in small businesses as they're the ones hiring. Big business is just scamming the country on taxes and cutting jobs.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
uneeda
Make Peace in Our Time
11:27 AM on 03/22/2013
It boggles the mind that this government could think that anybody would respect this so-called budget.