Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Brandon Hay

GET UPDATES FROM Brandon Hay
 

When a Black Man Is Murdered, Don't Call Him a Deadbeat

Posted: 02/20/2013 12:34 pm

Recently a brother in Toronto's West End was murdered. What was so significant about this brother's death was the amount of people affected (I am also one of those people indirectly affected). The brother was a father of two, a community leader, a dancer and someone who positively influenced a lot of young people.

My story begins at my day job as Men's Workshop Co-ordinator at Urban Alliance on Race Relations (U.A.R.R.). We did a workshop series called "Making Noise Media Project" that focused on gender violence. One of the agencies that we partnered with was the For Youth Initiative (FYI).

2013-02-20-leonardfullertonakacurlz.jpg

Gone Too Soon: Leonard Fullerton (aka 'Curlz')

It was there that I first met Leonard Fullerton, also known as "Curlz." What stood out to me about this brother was his optimism and positivity about the work that he was doing. He had a great attitude that the young men with whom he worked appreciated. A staff member at FYI and workshop co-facilitator introduced me to Curlz. Both Curlz and I are fathers committed to providing for our family. In short order, we entered into a spirited conversation about the state of funding in this city's public sector.

Our city's funding challenge:

Working in this sector is challenging on various levels. Some of us don't have the requisite training to do this work well. Conversely, one could argue that post-secondary institutions don't necessarily prepare one fully to do this work well. The fact is that there are numerous people doing social work in this city who didn't go to school for social work. Many of us simply fell into it (so to speak) and learned "on the job."

The obvious question arises: why don't these people go to school? Well, that is a complex and loaded question, which can give you an equally loaded answer. I am one of those individuals who didn't go to school for social work but I work in the social sector.

I went to school for something totally different, and when I think about going back to school as a father of three, I dismiss the thought because of the fact that I need to make money now and to be that provider that I, as a responsible father, am supposed to be. However, that doesn't change the fact that there are moments when I feel insecure about the work that I am doing or the advice that I am giving to participants.

What is it like working in this sector?

I went to a conference recently and they mentioned the idea that a lot of frontline workers see themselves as "ghetto superstars." The reality of working on the frontline is that the pay is rarely sufficient, so that means that you may have to work multiple jobs to get by.

But if you don't have the skill-set or educational level that is required, you may have to find other ways of supplementing your finances. And some of those choices may not be legal. The other challenge is that agencies are only hiring part-time up to 20 hours per week, which means that one is not eligible for health coverage or benefits.

What that could mean is that for me to obtain my prescriptions or adequate health care, I must use the same services that I refer my clients to. This can be a double-edged sword, because when you use some of these services you come to realize that they are not as effective as they are cracked up to be. As a result, I may not want to refer people to these services, but then that leaves a client feeling that you don't care.

Curlz mentioned that he lived in the community and that he served as a social worker in training. One of the difficulties faced by those who live and work in these marginalized communities is that they are affected by the same issues that plague the people they are serving, such as violence, marginalization, poverty, etc.

What does that mean if you have children working in this sector?

It means that you are working endless hours and not seeing your kids, and they end up falling through the cracks and end up going through the same stuff as the clients that you serve.

******

So now, this brother is dead. The sun will come up tomorrow, football will still play on Sunday. And people will go about their lives as usual.

What are our children to do?

And what happens to his children now? What are they supposed to do? Are they are now a statistic (and I say that with great hesitation, out of respect to the mother/s of these children)? Curlz worked hard to provide for and spend quality time with his children. However, the fact that he was murdered leaves his children a part of a very tragic class of children of murdered fathers.

And I know that class very well. I, too, am a child of a murdered father.

Curlz didn't want his children to become statistics and was an engaged father. But what happens to his children?

A reality in this sector:

We had to cut our six- part series short, due to funding cuts and FYI had to suspend some of their regular programming and lay off some frontline staff. I remember when the young men who were in the space found out that the two male staff whom they trusted and looked up to as big brothers were included in those layoffs. They were disgusted and asked a very important question:

"With this after school drop-in closed, what am I supposed to do now? Who am I to speak to when I am going through a hard time or need advice?"

Who, indeed.

The police report said:

"Fullerton was carrying marijuana, crack cocaine and money with him when he was killed, but it's unclear if these items were related to the shooting. Fullerton was also known to police and had affiliations with gangs but was not a 'card-carrying' member."

I have so many questions based on the report the police put out: how much drugs and money did he have on him? Was it for distribution or was it for personal use? What does a card-carrying member of a gang really mean?

The police also mentioned that no arrest has been made as yet, and I wonder sometimes if police mention drugs and other such information to cause the public to be less sympathetic and to lessen the pressure on themselves to find Curlz' killer. By no means am I saying that the police do not want to catch the murderer; however, what I am saying is that the police should be more responsible for what they do say to the public.

When I read the Toronto Star article, I immediately felt that they were making the victim seem guilty. My thoughts went to his children and the possibility that, one day, they might read the same article and wonder what kind of man their father was.

My challenge is that the information that the police do offer doesn't provide a complete picture of Curlz. Now, I understand that their job is to solve crime and create safer communities and that they are not in the business of public relations or image consulting. But as a card-carrying member of the black community living in Toronto, I find it very tiresome that these subtle messages of black men being no-good criminals are being repeated again and again.

What is the picture being painted of black men and black bodies in Toronto? Are we pawns to be shuffled and sacrificed on society's chessboard? Is there anything sacred about our existence? Are we only good for selling newspapers? Are our deaths to be used to get more funding for the police system?

I will say this: I refuse to play the position of the pimp, the drug dealer and/ or the deadbeat dad that you have laid out for me as choices. I must and will resist.

Curlz tried to resist, as many of your young men do; however, many of us quickly realize like with many marginalized communities there are a plethora of oppressive intersectionalities that don't make resistance easy.

What did this chain of events inspire me to do? Well, it confirmed that I will be pursuing post-secondary -- not only to serve my community better, but also to be a better father to my children (in hopes of having the flexibility to be more present). It's one thing to fight the battles with the system on the frontlines but it's quite another thing to fight from within the system itself.

We have to have policy change that will work to counteract the status quo. And in order to bring that into existence, we must fight.

I conclude with the prophetic words of martyred revolutionary, Thomas sankara: "What we need are (black) women and men who will fight because they know that without a fight the old order will not be destroyed and no new order will be built. We are not looking to organize what exists but to definitively destroy and replace it."

May you forever rest in peace, Brother Leonard Fullerton, aka Curlz.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Shyanne Charles, 14, was killed in the shooting on Scarborough's Danzig Street.

  • Police interview neighbours on Tuesday July 17, 2012 near the scene of a shooting on Danzig Street where 19 people were injured and 2 confirmed dead at an outdoor barbecue that took place on Monday July 16, 2012.

  • Neighbours watch on as police walk by on Tuesday July 17, 2012 near the scene of a shooting on Danzig Street where 19 people were injured and 2 confirmed dead at an outdoor barbecue that took place on Monday July 16, 2012 .

  • Mayor Rob Ford speaks to media after visiting the scene of Monday night's shooting on Danzig St. in Toronto on Tuesday July 17, 2012. Toronto police are calling for witnesses to come forward following a deadly shooting at an outdoor neighbourhood party that left two people dead and sent 21 others to hospital, including an infant, in what police are calling the worst incident of gun violence in the city's recent history.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Aaron Vincent Elkaim

  • Mayor Rob Ford (right) visits the scene of Monday night's shooting on Danzig St. in Toronto on Tuesday July 17, 2012. Toronto police are calling for witnesses to come forward following a deadly shooting at an outdoor neighbourhood party that left two people dead and sent 21 others to hospital, including an infant, in what police are calling the worst incident of gun violence in the city's recent history.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Aaron Vincent Elkaim

  • Shyanne Charles, 14, was killed in the shooting on Scarborough's Danzig Street.

  • Joshua Yasay, 23, was killed in the shooting.

  • Shyanne Charles, 14, was killed in the shooting on Scarborough's Danzig Street.

  • Police interview neighbors near the scene of a shooting in Toronto, on Tuesday, July 17, 2012. Two people are dead and 19 were injured as gunfire broke out late Monday night as more than 200 people attended an outdoor community barbecue. Police described the shootout, which involved multiple guns, as an "unprecedented" episode of violence. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press,Aaron Vincent Elkaim )

  • Toronto Police Chief Bill Blair arrives for a news conference on Monday night's fatal shooting at a street party in Scarborough, in Toronto, Tuesday, July 17, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ian Willms

  • Police interview neighbors near the scene of a shooting in Toronto, on Tuesday, July 17, 2012. Two people are dead and 19 were injured as gunfire broke out late Monday night as more than 200 people attended an outdoor community barbecue. Police described the shootout, which involved multiple guns, as an "unprecedented" episode of violence. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press,Aaron Vincent Elkaim )

  • Shannon Longshaw;

  • Police stand on guard on Tuesday July 17, 2012 on Danzig Street near the scene of a shooting where 19 people were injured and 2 confirmed dead at an outdoor barbecue that took place on Monday July 16, 2012 . THE CANADIAN PRESS/Aaron Vincent Elkaim

  • A police officer places a marker on Danzig Street in Toronto on Tuesday, July 17, 2012 near the scene of Monday night's shooting. Toronto police are calling for witnesses to come forward following a deadly shooting at an outdoor neighbourhood party that left two people dead and sent 21 others to hospital, including an infant, in what police are calling the worst incident of gun violence in the city's recent history. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Aaron Vincent Elkaim

  • Pedestrians look on near the scene of a shooting in Toronto early Tuesday, July 17, 2012, that left 19 people injured and two dead at a house party late Monday July 16. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Aaron Vincent Elkaim

  • Toronto Police Chief Bill Blair speaks to the media in Toronto early Tuesday, July 17, 2012, near the scene of a shooting that left 19 people injured and two dead at a house party late Monday, July 16. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Aaron Vincent Elkaim

  • Toronto Police Chief Bill Blair walks down Morningside Ave in Toronto early Tuesday, July 17, 2012, following a shooting that left 19 people injured and two dead at a house party late Monday, July 16. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Aaron Vincent Elkaim

  • Police stand on guard on Morningside Ave. in Toronto early Tuesday, July 17, 2012, near the scene of a shooting where 19 people were injured and two dead at a house party late Monday, July 16. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Aaron Vincent Elkaim

  • Toronto Police Chief Bill Blair speaks to media in Toronto early Tuesday, July 17, 2012, near the scene of a shooting where 19 people were injured and two were left dead at a house party late Monday July 16. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Aaron Vincent Elkaim

  • A man is attended to on the scene and loaded onto a gurney for transport following a shooting that left 19 injured and two dead in Toronto late Monday, July 16, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Toronto Star - Rick Madonik

  • ETF officers stand guard following a shooting that left 19 injured and two dead in Toronto late Monday, July 16, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Toronto Star - Rick Madonik

 
FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 42
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carol Hoousendove
08:04 AM on 02/21/2013
WOW.
10:22 PM on 02/20/2013
to writer- u may like us to believe that all these shootings r random. but that is asking us believe in fairies and elves
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveCDN
A Progressive Moderate
08:30 PM on 02/20/2013
Great piece. It's sad that stereotyping still exists to this degree.
06:25 PM on 02/20/2013
What a lot of the commenters here who are criticizing Hay's piece fail to recognize is the larger context and humanity that the writer feels is missing out from the stories crafted by the media.

By focussing on the details of preliminary police reports, too many of the articles amplify the convenient and the superficial. While these bits of information may have some value, they don't present a complete picture by a long shot. They are just one dimension among many, but all that screams out to us when we read the newspaper are the parts of someone being black, drugs and guns.

My takeaway from this insightful and personal piece is that we must look beyond the sensational narratives. We need to confront the truths about how families get affected when programs in inner-city neighbourhoods get cut. We have to look at the issues of young, single parents, and how we must come together to create sustainable, sensible, effective and empowering solutions for communities that are too often defined by these tragedies.

That means the news reporters have to do a better job of story-telling. And we, as readers, need to have a bigger capacity for empathy and analysis.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samuel Getachew
05:25 PM on 02/20/2013
Brilliant piece!
06:46 AM on 02/21/2013
"Brilliant" ? - This is a piece of a second generation Canadian, every immigrant group goes through these stages, First generation invilved in crime and tragedy, second generation, some escape some don't.
03:13 AM on 02/22/2013
1) Violence follows poverty; not immigration (as this story demonstrates). "Black" is not an “immigrant group” that can be described as "first generation".

2) The number of generations that the author's family has been in Canada is irrelevant to Canada's social prejudices, or the effects of those prejudices.

If you want to justify apathy, make a coherent fact based argument for it.
04:28 PM on 02/20/2013
Thank you for offering insight into a young man who loved his kids and contributed to society, despite society's willingness (or preference) to write him off.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Johnny LaRue
political correctness is just incorrect
04:14 PM on 02/20/2013
Mr Hay's article is exactly the problem. Too many in some "communities" blame others for their poor and sometimes deadly decisions. As for deadbeat fathers some "communites" have a very high percentage of single parents(50%),80% headed by woman. Where then are these involved fathers?
Sorry Mr Hay but by not taking responsibility and whinning the rest of the world sooner or later tunes you out.
05:25 PM on 02/20/2013
Despite being exactly as likely as their white counterparts to occasionally break the law:

They are disproportionately ejected from schools, disproportionately rejected for employment, disproportionately imprisoned and disproportionately dead.

Just like every other "community" that is subjected to institutionalized racism.
07:12 PM on 02/20/2013
Where is your proof that they are "being exactly as likely as their white counterparts to occasionally break the law"?

There is a reason that they are "disproportionately imprisoned" and it is guilty as charged!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DebbyM
07:13 AM on 02/21/2013
People aren't 'ejected' from school, they sit there in those desks and make a choice as to whether they will be involved, do the work, get the grades. The result of their 'leaving school' is problems getting a job, etc.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newcomer chess
04:13 PM on 02/20/2013
The only question I have is where do you come up with these ideas?

I mean, seriously, you are not helping anyone.

The only time you would help, in fact the most useful thing you could have done is if you told your friend - when he was alive - to stay away of drugs, guns and gangs. Because you knew it then and you did nothing.

None of what you wrote makes any sense and it will never pass common sense review. It won’t sell so you should stop selling it. I actually feel bad for someone who reads this column and takes in your advice.
09:02 PM on 02/21/2013
As the mother of one of his child I think the article was beneficial to show A: the type of man he was and father B: speak to the community C: show him in a better light...

As for you comment about "told your friend - when he was alive - to stay away of drugs, guns and gangs. Because you knew it then and you did nothing"

You can only say so much to a person everyone makes mistake and we are entitle to make them as human-beings. For you to make that statement is inappropriate and frankly shows how empathetic you are to the whole situation.
03:21 AM on 02/22/2013
My deepest condolences to you and your family.

Thank you for saying your piece despite the hostile atmosphere that some of these comments have created.
04:07 PM on 02/20/2013
"Was it for distribution or was it for personal use?"

Neither outcome is good, so why use this as an argument? What would his kids rather know? That he was dealing drugs or using drugs when he was killed? It doesn't make me less sympathetic to the fact that his kids have now lost their father.

For this to be reported by the media doesn't make this man's murder any less tragic.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
quax
05:30 PM on 02/20/2013
If the assumption is valid that gang related killings or murders of drug addicts/dealers are investigated with less vigor, then it'll be perfectly reasonable for the killer to slip drugs into his victim's pockets.
08:08 PM on 02/20/2013
I'd agree with you if the victim wasn't already known to the police.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:04 PM on 02/20/2013
That's the stupidest thing I have ever heard. You just caught a body, your running the other way. Stop watching CSI.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Ike Awgu
03:38 PM on 02/20/2013
Nonsense.
04:29 PM on 02/20/2013
Nonsense.
03:22 PM on 02/20/2013
"I will say this: I refuse to play the position of the pimp, the drug dealer and/ or the deadbeat dad that you have laid out for me as choices. I must and will resist. " Can you please elaborate on who laid these choices out for you?
02:45 AM on 02/21/2013
You, in part.

When one race is perceived as less valuable, some members of that race get squeezed right out of mainstream society. You cultivate that perception when you denigrate a race as having a “thug culture” and you further that perception when you parrot apathetic platitudes like, “take ownership of your own life.”

Defending unequal conditions while whining, "Stop blaming whites," makes a joke of us all, which brings me to the following: You don’t know me. That’s something that you should know, but your earlier personal attack demonstrated an inability to distinguish between reality and your presumptions.

Someone who can’t distinguish between reality and his own presumptions shouldn’t beak off about lives that he (intentionally) knows nothing about.
03:11 PM on 02/20/2013
So, your issue is with how he was portrayed in the media? I would figure the issues would be with the community in which he lived. And how to prevent young men/woman from engaging in illegal activity and stop killing each other over nothing. The fact he had drugs on him, provides potential motive, as does being know to affiliate with gangs. Did he deserve to lose his life, of course not. But you can't expect everyone to feel sorry for someone who choose to live a lifestyle that and in this case got him killed.
02:56 PM on 02/20/2013
Thank you for being a strong (black) man and a role model in the community. While I do not share your race, I share your neighbourhood and a deep concern for these young people as they struggle to find a path for themselves. The victim blaming that is inflicted on these cases, most often by law enforcement and media, is cruel and harmful to the victim's family and the community as a whole. It is not our position to judge, it is our position to care. That is the only way Toronto can move forward as a society.
02:19 PM on 02/20/2013
"But as a card-carrying member of the black community living in Toronto, I find it very tiresome that these subtle messages of black men being no-good criminals are being repeated again and again."

In this case, the shoe fits. "Fullerton was carrying marijuana, crack cocaine and money with him when he was killed, but it's unclear if these items were related to the shooting. Fullerton was also known to police and had affiliations with gangs but was not a 'card-carrying' member."

If your friend was a responsible father he wouldn't have been selling or using drugs ... especially to other people's children. You are no better than the company you keep, and the sad reality is that's why your friend ended up where he did.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
05:20 PM on 02/20/2013
I think what the author is trying to say is that as an unsupported youth worker, Fullerton was left with 'choiceless choices'...he was trying to lift himself and his family out of the same poverty, social insecurity and lack of options that plagued his clients. The world needs to understand that 'black/white' dichotomies (pun intended) do not exist in real life. In the real world there are shades of grey and this is where Fullerton and his contemporaries live. Police know that and they know a real criminal from a petty thief. I think Brandon's message for the police to put identities into context and share the full story of a person's character is a reasonable request.
07:28 PM on 02/20/2013
"I think Brandon's message for the police to put identities into context and share the full story of a person's character is a reasonable request"

I have to disagree. The measure of someone's charater is a matter of personal opinion and is therefore subjective. The police should just report that the Facts!
02:17 PM on 02/20/2013
Does it matter if he was carrying crack for himself to use, a friend or to sell to some addict? The police typically release those details so people don't panic and think random normal people are being targeted.
He made his bed, now he has to sleep in it. Don't associate yourself with the drug trade and you'll most likely stay out of trouble.. Fall in with ghetto / thug culture mentality and you're most likely going to end up dead or in jail.

Stop playing the blame game.