Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bruce Hyer

GET UPDATES FROM Bruce Hyer
 

Will MPs Show the Courage and Independence Needed to Stop Bill C-38?

Posted: 06/14/2012 8:26 am

A major showdown is happening on Parliament Hill. The Harper Government's omnibus budget bill, C-38, is being rammed through this week and next. With 12 seats short of the majority needed to vote down this flawed legislation, the opposition will be proposing hundreds of amendments and using procedural moves to delay and change the bill wherever possible.

I will be seconding and supporting many of these, and advocating amendments myself. Never before in our history has a check on excess government power been more important.

This mammoth, 452-page bill contains sweeping changes to a wide range of legislation, with serious social, environmental, economic and democratic consequences. It reduces what little oversight there is of the government. The Auditor General will have less authority to produce reports that may be a thorn in the government's side. The investigative budget of Elections Canada has also been slashed, and the Public Appointments Commission dissolved.

But it doesn't stop there: Changes will have an impact on jobs and workers. The government claims that this bill will get Canadians working, but there is little in the budget to actually encourage employment. Instead, more restrictions on Employment Insurance will put the Finance Minister's opinion that "there are no bad jobs" into practice, and make Canadians take low-paying jobs with no chance for advancement, farther away from where they live.

The bill also repeals the Fair Wages and Hours of Labour Act. And let's not forget that it raises Old Age Security from 65 to 67 years old, costing every Canadian under 54 an average of $12,000.

While these changes are troublesome, they pale in comparison to the chainsaw that has been taken to environmental protections. A full two-thirds of this "budget" bill is devoted to environmental changes. The watchdog ,National Roundtable on the Environment and the Economy, is abolished; habitat conservation in the Fisheries Act is gutted; environmental charities are targeted; the Navigable Waters Act is weakened; the Kyoto Protocol is repealed; Parks Canada loses personnel; funding to the Environmental Effects Monitoring Program is slashed. And this is just a small part of a very long list!

One program worth highlighting is the world-renowned Experimental Lakes Area (ELA) research program near Kenora, which will be axed under C-38. This is the only facility of its kind in the world, and has produced outstanding results on things like mercury contamination, and how detergents can cause lakes to turn green with algae ...leading to low-phosphate soaps.

This weekend I was invited to a Town Hall in Kenora on the ELA (Greg Rickford, the Conservative MP for Kenora declined to attend). People were incensed that such a relatively inexpensive facility would be closed to save just $2 million a year, and we heard from scientists from around the world shocked at the move. This shows it is more about ideology than it is about budget matters.

Parliament has never seen such an all-encompassing bill in its history. The government has shut down debate in Parliament and refuses to split the bill to allow for proper scrutiny. It is ironic that the MP from Calgary, a certain Stephen J. Harper, once argued strongly against this undemocratic practice when Liberals took baby steps with omnibus budget bills.

Sometimes history repeats itself: Many in Harper's Tory caucus are very unhappy about C-38. Before being whipped by his party, Conservative MP David Wilks told his constituents that he would vote the way his constituents want and against C-38 if there were 12 Conservative MPs joining him.

Ultimately, whether this terrible bill passes or not depends on the mettle of individual Conservative MPs. I hope that Greg Rickford, David Wilks, and their colleagues have the courage to stand for their constituents' interests and vote against their party. The choice is theirs: Do they want to make a difference as MPs, or go down in history as trained seals rubber stamping a party line?

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
12:17 PM on 06/15/2012
When the Liberals had Majority government this would never be a issue
12:15 PM on 06/15/2012
Will MPs Show the Courage and Independence Needed to Stop Bill C-38? Wait, wait, I know the answer to this one...
No. They will not.
I'll even tell you why not: because the majority of MPs work for the PMO. They depend on Stevie Harper for their political futures, and they will never cross him.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
drularter
Arrogance is confidence in someone you don't like.
10:26 AM on 06/15/2012
Sounds a lot like the Bush Administration in the States. Makes me a bit sick. The whole reason I ever came to Canada was my husband and stuff like this undemocratic crap didn't really happen. A sad day if this bill is passed. Scrutiny is needed. Con MPs need to stand up for what's right. Not for Harper's harping.
photo
Cantoffie
"My cup runeth over with blood and not wine"
12:28 PM on 06/15/2012
Regime Change my friend. Stephen Harper was very close to GW Bush and infiltrated the Conservative party to structure canadas politic like the US.

""You won't recognise Canada, when I'm done with it ..." ~PM SJH
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
contest d
10:10 AM on 06/15/2012
Just as Rob Ford's indirect attack on the middle-class and pathological attitude toward managing a city radicalized the mushy middle, Harper's individualistic moralism, masquerading as efficiency will deepen radical behaviour as increasing numbers of citizens are excluded socially, economically and left to fend for themselves after austerity rolls them over.

Here's hoping the senate is awakened next week and humiliates Harper as Toronto council has repeatedly done with Ford's self-serving pet projects that ultimately serve a minority of citizens, ie. the 20% of citizens who hold 70+% of the nation's wealth.

To paraphrase one analogy critical of economic expansionism: N. America is a cruise ship heading for an iceberg. The problem is that all the crew and passengers can do is argue about how to arrange the deck chairs.
09:16 AM on 06/15/2012
If this was a country more concentrated and not spread so thin we could have some proper demonstrations. If this was a more fiery population we could rise up and change this very quickly.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SeanMartin
Everything in moderation.
08:46 AM on 06/15/2012
Looks like the conservatives have learned well from their brothers south of the border.

I hope this turns the next election into the same rout that nearly eliminated the Conservative Party altogether in the 90s. For the CPC to act so cavalierly towards our environment, the true gem in the Canadian crown of riches, is beyond reprehensible.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patrickwwalker
09:15 AM on 06/15/2012
I shared a similar hope that Canadians would wake up in the aftermath of CRAP receiving the first ever contempt of parliament but I was mistaken. Instead of punishing the CRAP party at the polls, they gave him a majority.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
okgranny
Egalitarian by birth
11:36 AM on 06/15/2012
Maybe not. Election fraud anyone?
photo
Gnomish
ego doctus ignarus
04:14 AM on 06/15/2012
The snorting echoes still reverberate through the halls.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
baizhongtang
Reality has an anti-neoliberal agenda
06:45 PM on 06/14/2012
How far will this go before the Governor-General makes the necessary decision to dissolve this crazy government?????
photo
Cantoffie
"My cup runeth over with blood and not wine"
08:45 AM on 06/15/2012
He wont, cause he is a neo-con as well.
02:12 PM on 06/14/2012
Would there were more MPs with Mr. Heyer's principles. He disagreed with his party and left to sit as an Independent. Great roel model for some Red Tories? But I guess they are too whipped.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patrickwwalker
09:16 AM on 06/15/2012
Most of those in the backbench are from riding that need Federal support. Our last Liberal MP basically said as much that if he didn't vote the party line, equalization for the province could find itself the victim of cuts.
12:51 PM on 06/14/2012
I wonder what kinds of threats the Conservative MPs are working under.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patrickwwalker
09:16 AM on 06/15/2012
Threats of losing Federal money in their ridings, many of which are screaming in pain because of the crap economy.
photo
Liz Wilson 2
“a small group can change the world
11:30 AM on 06/15/2012
According the Inky Mark (yes that is his real name) ex-conservatfive the conservatie party of Canada controls all of the local riding data in their massive database. If the conservaitve candidate doesnt stay on the good side of Harper et al they are cut off from their own information. Sad and silly and scary all at the same time.

Two links for Inky Mark where he talks aobut his concern with the voter ID system and about the control the head office has on local riding data.

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/03/15/inky-mark-cims-robocalls-canada-voter-id-system_n_1348957.html
http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/canada/mark-ditched-tory-voter-bank-142900055.html
photo
The Canadian
Stop Harper
12:23 PM on 06/14/2012
Looks like the rubber stamps are winning. Was there any other outcome possible with the Conservative MPs, who join their leader in displaying breathtaking mendacity.

Mr Hyer, you are an MP, and you see the Conservative MPs every day, but one thing you'd better get over fast is waiting for them to show an ounce of courage or integrity. They are just cogs in the Harper machine, as this dark day in Canadian politics is showing. You've got to look these people right in the eye and tell them that as a non-Conservative, you are ready to resist them with every fiber in your body. Forget bi-partisanship, it is not going to happen under Harper's watch.

Please don't think I'm criticizing you - I wish their were more MPs like you. And in fact, there are, it's just that they won't be in the Conservative Party.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DirkNeptune
I love raspberry pie, damn it.
12:18 PM on 06/14/2012
The Conservatives are proving themselves to be a party of trained seals. They always put their party before their country.

It's disgusting. The Canada we all grew up in will be distant memory after Harper is through with us.
11:29 AM on 06/14/2012
"It is ironic that ... a certain Stephen J. Harper, once argued strongly against this undemocratic practice." It is much more than ironic. It is profoundly telling of the character and integrity of that certain Stephen J. Harper, and what he secretly from the very beginning was planning to really do when he got his hands on what he really wanted -- pure power to make all the decisions. And it is also profoundly telling of the character and integrity of those who still blindly and obediently follow wherever he leads.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cityprole
old,sly, crafty,arty, leftie
11:20 AM on 06/14/2012
I have been wondering why on MPs with a Con-science in Parliament are willing to stand up to Emperor Steve and cross the floor..there must be some reps who are not pathologically inclined to destroy this country, as Harper so obviously is...where are they?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
arkymorgan
Nobody knows the trouble I've been...
03:34 PM on 06/14/2012
A combination of fear and greed apparently trumps anything smacking of integrity, I guess.

Actually, part of the problem is that political hopefuls who join parties with strong chances to actually form government are generally those hopefuls with the least in the way of scruples, principles or values. It's why they run on tickets they don't agree with: because power and money matter far more to them.
10:43 AM on 06/14/2012
Harper's Republican handlers have schooled him well.