Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Craig and Marc Kielburger

GET UPDATES FROM Craig and Marc Kielburger
 

Rioters Are Rebels Without Responsibility

Posted: 07/06/11 10:20 AM ET

Neighbours cowered in their homes while the "animals" -- more than 100 teens -- "went wild" and spray painted graffiti all over a west Toronto house slated for demolition. The inside was trashed and strewn with empty beer bottles.

There was no worthy explanation.

It was sort of like a mini riot. Fun. Wild. Alcohol-fueled. It happened a month before Vancouver's riot and received minor coverage in the Toronto press.

When young people join together in an act of destructive abandon, what most often gets destroyed isn't a downtown street lined with expensive handbag shops but suburban homes, owned by moms or dads -- the very people they are supposed to love the most.

It's a point worth noting as Vancouverites question why the mostly young rioters destroyed the city that they are supposed to love. It has little to do with love and a lot to do with responsibility, or the lack thereof.

We learned this from summers spent among the Maasai Warriors of Kenya, where boys become men through a series of ritualized steps. Learning responsibility is crucial to their community's survival.

In Vancouver, the rioters weren't anarchists. There was the former UBC rower caught on video leaving a store with two pairs of size 42 men's dress pants. A professional mountain biker photographed sticking his tongue out à la Gene Simmons after helping flip a car. And the Olympic water polo hopeful who was recorded ignominiously stuffing a rag in the gas tank of a police car.

Stricken parents must have wondered how could so much parental care and calculation, not to mention chauffeuring, lead there, to that?

Let's face it, 30 is the new 15. Young people don't need to take responsibility for much of anything. Someone else -- parents, teachers, coaches, the police, and janitors -- will clean up their mess, drive them here, there and everywhere, bail them out, fork over the cash. They might lose their computer privileges due to bad behaviour, but most parents ensure their kids get to sport and music practice. After all, their children have to make something of themselves.

But at what age are they required to help build the community that they live in?

During our many summers running leadership camps and development projects in Kenya, we have witnessed the Maasai usher their young into adulthood in rituals far different than what we have in North America.

One teenager we came to know, Naabala, was tested repeatedly with new responsibilities. He herded cows and then built a hut to live in after his initiation. He was attacked by fire ants and then endured ritual circumcision. Each trial was to show he could endure pain without crying out, an act that might scare away nearby game -- the village's food source -- or alert an enemy.

Finally, he was exiled to kill a lion. It was only upon his return, clutching a lion's tail, that he was judged a man responsible enough to defend, build and lead his community. And it was only then that parents and community leaders could rest easy, knowing they had done their job.

Naabala's journey from boyhood to adulthood took months, not 15 years. We're obviously not advocating you send your teen to Kenya to endure ritual circumcision, yet his story offers valuable lessons.

In North America, a sweet 16 bash, getting a driver's license, or earning a high school diploma defines the transformation to adulthood. Pretty mundane and uninspiring. Without formalized rites of passage, it's no wonder children create their own in order to prove they can take on the world. The struggle for self-definition leads some kids to rebel against parents and their communities, to shoplift for kicks, engage in early sex, joy rides, gang activity. And maybe even get swept up in the mob mentality that leads to house-wrecking parties, even riots.

We're doing our teens no favours. They crave responsibility but are treated like adults-in-waiting -- too young for challenges or to fight for their beliefs. Such kids are on the receiving end of everything -- homework from teachers, orders from parents, pressure from peers.

When you're responsible for nothing, you care little about the consequences of your actions.

Adolescence should be about doing, not being done for. How else can our young people learn to take responsibility for their actions, good and bad?

In Vancouver, we've seen them name and shame. Now we need to encourage them to "claim" responsibility for their community.

 

Follow Craig and Marc Kielburger on Twitter: www.twitter.com/craigkielburger

Neighbours cowered in their homes while the "animals" -- more than 100 teens -- "went wild" and spray painted graffiti all over a west Toronto house slated for demolition. The inside was trashed and s...
Neighbours cowered in their homes while the "animals" -- more than 100 teens -- "went wild" and spray painted graffiti all over a west Toronto house slated for demolition. The inside was trashed and s...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 3
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:59 PM on 09/01/2011
I have a lot of respect for the author, but in this case the analogy is trite and the commentary superficial at best. Sure, formalized coming of age social structures can be a positive formative agent and developmental tool. But even in those cultures within our society (Jewish canadians with their bar- and bat-mitsvas for example), the development of the child is still primarily a product of the individual, their parental guidance, and their social environment at school and at home. The root causes of this type of behavior are a failing of parents and our culture to instill maturity and responsibility. Responsibility is developed through an understanding of the consequences of one's actions. The cultural constructs of the Maasai may impart this more effectively, but then again, they may not. Perhaps the consequences in such a society are simply much higher, with those rejected from the group (for vandalizing a hut or stealing food for example) likely to die. Put the same consequences on Canadian teenagers and see how many riot next time. Bottom line: parents need to raise their children better and we all need to work to better our society.
12:58 PM on 07/06/2011
I think it is a bit naive to try and compare the 21st century world with the timeless existence of the Maasai. It also lacks a certain subtlety calling 30 the new fifteen. Stephen Harper is off the hook when he does all that he can to destroy the Liberal Party, a founding member of this great democracy? When he thumbs his nose at the contempt of Parliament ruling? When he spends untold billions on jets and prisons we don't need as much as clean drinking water for our native communities? Is this not acting out? Is this not a teenager who finally gets access to their bloated trust fund?

Did you miss the G20? Innocent civilians exercising their right to peaceful protest because that is the only way perhaps to get their message across. Our police forces are trained for years to learn to exercise authority. Do you honestly believe that the actions of "protectors" was measured and justified? These highly trained and disciplined men and women are under the control of experienced leaders, what we got was a bunch of armed and well padded "teenagers" acting out and beating the crap out people, some of whom were just trying to get home.

How is this behavior from our best contributing to our society? Kids quickly learn how their parents react to adversity and frustration. Not many have had the supportive and educational upbringing of the Kielburgers.

Ask questions but please do not preach simplistic solutions to complex problems.
photo
john frodo
armchair expert
09:33 AM on 07/06/2011
Likely the elders of the African village also take responsibility. In Canada and US we see people destroying companies, democracy and taking no responsibility. This abdication of responsibility trickles down in unforeseen ways.
http://thinkingaboot.blogspot.com/2011/06/new-nihilism-becomes-meme.html