Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Cynthia Cheng Mintz

GET UPDATES FROM Cynthia Cheng Mintz
 

Why Don't Petite Girls Get Criticized

Posted: 03/02/2013 12:05 am

Watching the red carpet during the Oscars on February 24 made me cringe. This wasn't because of the many "misses" when it came to gowns (or the grungy chic look the men seem to be sporting by not shaving), but because of Kristin Chenoweth. That woman was seriously annoying and the ultimate stereotype of a petite. Note to Ms. Chenoweth: Just because you're short and small-framed, doesn't mean you have to act like a little girl.

Short women are expected to be cute and adorable, as long as they can pull it off. Once they age, they're still supposed to be "cute," but in more of a grandmotherly sort of way. There's no "regal mature" here. Instead, one is expected to be more like, say, Sophia from Golden Girls.

Rarely, do we hear body image activists and feminists, including Toronto model agent, Ben Barry, websites like Jezebel and organizations like Endangered Bodies criticize this "cuteness."

Instead, they seem to concentrate on the image that larger women (whether petite in height or not) and how THEY are portrayed while at the same time, promoting "body acceptance" and "size equality." Other times, said activists discuss how women are sexually victimized in ads and editorials. If those two topics are so often on their mandate, why is the "cuteness" factor so infrequently mentioned? Do people not realize that accepting this kind of behavior is saying that a woman, no matter her age, can't be a "real" woman, but a little girl, because she is tiny? Please note that Ms. Chenoweth is in her forties. If we as a society criticize sexuality and violence, why isn't infantilizing on the plate as well?

It really bothers me that mainstream body image activists tend to pick and choose their battles, focusing primarily on larger sizes and sexuality while ignoring the small. When being small is ever even mentioned, it's often lip service. At best, they acknowledge that it is an issue, and then never discuss it again unless someone else brings it up. Other times, it's entirely dismissed -- especially in fashion (but that's another story) being small isn't as bad as being fat -- it's considered a "compliment" when one is tiny and delicate, after all (it isn't when it's constantly in your face). This is part of the issue. In our society, small = can't be taken seriously, so no complaints. And the lack of complaints means that the topic won't be discussed.

I understand that the hyper/cute image is part of Ms. Chenoweth's "image," but is it any different from a Playboy Bunny and her overt sexuality in terms of how women are portrayed? Is being "cute" somehow okay for an adult in her forties? Or any adult, for that matter? Imagine how the media would have reacted if Ms. Chenoweth was not short and small-framed, but larger? Wouldn't people be up in arms, criticizing her annoying behaviour? Somehow, being 4'11" and around 90 to 95 pounds (or whatever her weight is) gives her a pass. Why? We can't have organizations that claim size and body diversity without acknowledging ALL SIDES.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Lena Dunham

    "I don't think a girl with tiny thighs would have received so much no-pants attention… Get used to it. I'm going to live until 105 and I'm going to show my thighs every day," <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/08/lena-dunham-new-yorker-festival-emily-nussbaum_n_1948596.html">the "Girls" creator said at the New Yorker Festival</a> in August 2012.

  • Beyoncé

    The curvy songstress recently <a href="http://www.teenvogue.com/beauty/celebrity-beauty/2011-03/beyonce-knowles-fragrance-interview/?slide=1" target="_blank">gave this advice to young readers at Teen Vogue</a>: "The best thing I can say to young ladies is accept the body you're in. If you have curves, love your curves. The thing to strive for is to have the best healthy body you can have. It's really not about being skinny or being curvy. What matters is that you love yourself and you are taking care of your health."

  • Crystal Renn

    "We're fighting a stigma: fat. People are really scared of fat. And I think we need to change people's minds and show that you can be bigger and you can be beautiful just as you are. It's about being and loving yourself and once I discovered that, life got much easier." on plus-size modeling, to <em>Interview</em>

  • Marilyn Monroe

    She is the first woman many people think of when they hear "legendary sex symbol". But some say that today, <a href="http://jezebel.com/5299793/for-the-last-time-what-size-was-marilyn-monroe" target="_blank">Monroe might wear a size 12 or a size 16</a>.

  • Sofia Vergara

    Vergara stepped onto the scene and proved that you can be very voluptuous and still be extremely sexy. She won't back down or slim down for anyone either: She told Self: "When I was 13, I got these ridiculous boobs. It's hard to dress. No matter what I wear, I look like a stripper. That said, I'm grateful I have them, and honestly, they've helped me a lot in my career. And I've always felt sexy."

  • Robyn Lawley

    "...that heroin-chic look isn’t my cup of tea. It isn’t for a lot of people out of the fashion world. That starvation look isn’t for everybody, why not have someone who is a little bit bigger?" <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/17/robyn-lawley-weight-size-model-interview_n_1973208.html">in an interview with RadarOnline.com</a>

  • Tara Lynn

    "It was impossible not to look at magazines and look at my body and think, 'If only I was skinnier' or, 'If only my legs weren't so muscular.' Then, one day, I remember seeing this brunette, plus-sized model in a homecoming shoot. It was amazing. Seeing that one image during my adolescence was such a relief. I wish there had been more." <a href="http://www.guardian.co.uk/fashion/2012/mar/02/models-breaking-mould">to Emine Saner of <em>The Guardian</em></a>

  • Kate Upton

    "I don't really know what the appeal is about... boobs. But I do know that when I was in junior high, I used to be made fun of — for being flat-chested. Everyone would go, "She's not pretty! She doesn't have boobs!" So I always had boob envy. And when finally I went through my growth spurt, and they appeared, and I just... I loved them. So that's why I like boobs, because I didn't have them, and then I got 'em." <a href="http://www.esquire.com/features/qa/kate-upton-5931248">to <em>Esquire</em></a>

  • Jennifer Hudson

    On being overweight in America, <a href="http://www.goodhousekeeping.com/family/celebrity-interviews/jennifer-hudson-interview-2">to <em>Good Housekeeping</em></a>: "That was normal in Chicago. But then I'd go to another city, and it was real culture shock. I'm like, Huh? Wait a minute — I'm a big girl?"

  • Salma Hayek

    <a href="http://www.oprah.com/omagazine/Oprah-Interviews-Actress-and-Producer-Salma-Hayek/12"> in <em>O, The Oprah Magazine</em></a>: "I do have thighs and a butt. I have cellulite. I fight with it every day. I don't exercise, I eat pork, and I love my red wine. But, yes, I am beautiful and famous—and yet the things I like about myself have nothing to do with that, because I don't use wealth and beauty to define myself."

  • Jennifer Lawrence

    <a href="http://www.mirror.co.uk/3am/celebrity-news/silver-linings-playbook-actress-jennifer-1509653">To the <em>Mirror</em></a>: "I'd rather look chubby on screen and like a person in real life."

  • America Ferrera

    <a href="http://www.contactmusic.com/interview/aferrera">To Contact Music</a>: "Whether you're skinny or not there's just way too much attention placed on the way we look. It overshadows more important things in life like loving yourself, loving who your are and finding yourself on the inside."

  • Gabourey Sidibe

    "People always ask me, 'You have so much confidence. Where did that come from?' It came from me. One day I decided that I was beautiful, and so I carried out my life as if I was a beautiful girl. I wear colors that I really like, I wear makeup that makes me feel pretty, and it really helps. It doesn't have anything to do with how the world perceives you. What matters is what you see. Your body is your temple, it's your home, and you must decorate it." <a href="http://www.harpersbazaar.com/fashion/fashion-articles/gabourey-sidibe-precious-interview-0210">to <em>Harper's Bazaar</em></a>

  • Gemma Ward

    <a href="http://www.mamamia.com.au/health-wellbeing/model-gemma-ward-shes-had-her-moment-its-over/">On her weight gain</a>: “I realize you can’t please everyone. Sometimes when people are constantly wanting the fantasy or the illusion, you have to break it to them that it’s not real.”

  • Kelly Clarkson

    "For seven years it's been happening. It's like, 'OK cool, the fat joke,'" the "American Idol" winner<a href="http://www.popeater.com/2009/06/05/kelly-clarkson-weight-issues/"> told Australia's Kyle and Jackie O Show</a> in 2009. "I love my body. I'm very much OK with it. I don't think artists are ever the ones who have the problem with their weight, it is other people."

  • Christina Hendricks

    "Back when I was modeling, the first time I went to Italy I was having cappuccinos every day, and I gained 15 pounds. And I felt gorgeous! I would take my clothes off in front of the mirror and be like, Oh, I look like a woman. And I felt beautiful, and I never tried to lose it, 'cause I loved it," <a href="http://www.health.com/health/article/0,,20429844_2,00.html">the "Mad Men" star told Health magazine</a>.

  • Jessica Simpson

    "Everybody fluctuates, but I'm open about my weight and I'm still confident. "I didn't cry about it too much," <a href="http://www.luckymag.com/magazine/2011/12/jessica-simpson#slide=1c">Jessica Simpson told Lucky magazine</a> in November 2011. "I got so much scrutiny for putting on extra pounds, but I think that the decision not to make myself anorexic was actually great for branding. Because when you're really, really skinny, not everybody can relate to you."

  • Lily Allen

    "When I was on tour earlier in the year, I’d be on stage for one-and-a-half hours a night, so since the tour finished in March, I’ve put on about half a stone. But I do Pilates three times a week. I am still body conscious, but I’m not so concerned with it; I don’t care as much," she told Elle UK.

  • Mischa Barton

    She once told Cosmo: "It’s possible to like the way you look. I wouldn’t change my body, and I couldn’t anyway. Surely there are more important issues than if someone has cellulite.”

  • Kim Kardashian

    "When I was criticised for it, I said, 'I have cellulite. So what!,'" <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/04/05/kim-kardashian-in-cosmopolitan_n_844943.html">the reality star told Cosmopolitan UK</a>. "I've never claimed to be perfect. It's crazy anyone should assume that just because you're in the spotlight, you're flawless. Sometimes I pig out and I still feel great, and think, 'That was so worth it!' That's how I feel a lot of the time. I think, 'See this little dimple of cellulite here? It was so worth it for that cookies 'n' cream ice cream!'"

  • Oprah Winfrey

    "I actually thought at the time that being thin made me better," <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/10/11/oprah-lifeclass-officiall_n_1004870.html">Oprah Winfrey said on network show "Lifeclass."</a> "You are not the shape of your body, you're not your status, you're not your position in life, you're not the car you drive no matter how fancy it is, you're not your house or your square footage."

  • Tiffani Thiessen

    "I think any time you are on a hit show as a young actor or actress, you feel [pressured]. Then as a woman, there’s some additional pressures you feel to look a certain way and be a certain size. I was not the girl that was a size 2 and didn’t work for it. I was never the waify model type," the former "Saved by the Bell" star <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/22/tiffani-thiessen-hot-photo_n_2526772.html?utm_hp_ref=celebrity">told the website Me In My Place.</a>

  • Kat Dennings

    "No matter what I do, they're there," the "2 Broke Girls" star said of her breasts on the red carpet at the 2012 Emmy Awards. "They're always the same size."

  • Khloe Kardashian

    "A few years ago I lost 30 pounds, and people still wanted to criticize. And honestly, I’m happy with myself if I’m a little heavier," <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/19/khloe-kardashians-body-image_n_2512336.html?ir=Celebrity">Khloe Kardashian told Glamour magazine</a>. "I realized: 'Why am I trying to conform to someone else’s idea of beauty?' I think I’m beautiful either way."

  • Adele

    "I'm never like, I'm plus-sized, I'm so much bigger than them other artists out there it's going to be a problem. I've never really thought about it at all. It only comes to my attention if I were to read something about it,"<a href="http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504803_162-57376080-10391709/adele-talks-about-her-body-image-and-weight/"> the Grammy winner told Anderson Cooper</a> on "60 MInutes" about her body image. "I think no matter what you look like, the key is to first of all be happy with yourself. And then you know if you want to try to improve things that you don't like about yourself, then do it after you appreciate yourself."

  • Lady Gaga

    "My weight/loss/gain since i was child has tormented me. No amount of help has ever healed my pain about it. But YOU have," <a href="http://www.forbes.com/sites/melaniehaiken/2012/09/26/lady-gaga-puts-bulimia-and-body-image-on-the-table-in-a-big-way/">Lady Gaga wrote on her website</a> in September 2012, when she launched the online discussion board "Body Revolution."

  • Rosie Huntington-Whiteley

    Despite being told to slim down as a young model, Rosie Huntington-Whiteley didn't oblige and as a result, ended up naturally losing the weight as she matured. She told Britain's ELLE magazine, "I can't remember a time where I really battled with my body, but I can remember being asked to lose weight and battling with the advice. It hurt me."

  • Adele

    "I've never wanted to look like the models on the cover of magazines. I represent the majority of women and I'm very proud of that," Adele told People magazine.

  • Rosario Dawson

    Rosario Dawson has often been told she needs to lose weight, but the actress attributes her weight to her "big boobs." “I would get told by my manager, ‘Rosario, you went into your audition with sweats today. If you want to wear a sweater, just make sure it’s tight.’ Because the casting directors would call her and say, ‘She’s great but the casting director needs to know if she’s slim.’ I’m like, ‘Dude, have you seen the photos I’ve done? You know what I look like.’”

  • Liv Tyler

    Liv Tyler has said: “I’ve been told that if I lose weight I’d have more work, but I refuse to submit myself to Hollywood standards. To the rest of the world I am slim and I like the way I am.”

  • Christina Aguilera

    "Actually, the challenge I've always had is being too thin, so I love that now I have a booty, and obviously I love showing my cleavage," Christina Aguilera told Lucky magazine.

  • Mo'Nique

    "Let's be healthy big people. Everybody can't be a size 0 or 45, but let's be healthy."

  • Cheryl Cole

    Cole has had body issues before. She once told Vogue that she would start crying once she got on the scale. But she seems to have come to peace with her image as of late. She had said, "Do you ever reach the point when you're happy with your body? I can look in the mirror in the morning and feel rubbish. But never change your look for a man. Never."

  • Cheryl Burke

    "There's a lot of pressure living this Hollywood life. People expect to see you at a certain weight and when you gain a few pounds then all of a sudden it's the talk of the week, I want kids or women out there to realize you don't have to be anorexic to be beautiful."

  • Tyra Banks

    "To all of you who have something nasty to say to me or to women built like me," Tyra Banks said on her talk show, "I have one thing to say to you: Kiss my fat a**!"

  • Jennifer Lopez

    Jennifer Lopez once fired a manager for ordering her to lose weight: “I was just so infuriated that somebody said you couldn’t have a little extra meat on you – because I was by no means fat! That was so mean and closed-minded. I was like: ‘No, this is who I am and this is the type of woman that I grew up with and it was beautiful and there’s no reason to be anybody but myself.’”

  • Kelly Clarkson

    "My happy weight changes. Sometimes I eat more; sometimes I play more. I'll be different sizes all the time. When people talk about my weight, I'm like, `You seem to have a problem with it; I don't. I'm fine! I've never felt uncomfortable on the red carpet or anything."

  • Queen Latifah

    "I just had to grow to love my body, I'm either going to love me or hate me. And I chose to love myself."

  • Jordin Sparks

    "I'm really comfortable in my own skin, learned that I'm not ever going to be a size 2. I would look so weird as a size 2. Somebody would blow and I would fall right over. It just wouldn't be healthy."

  • Tyra Banks on Body Image

    America's most famous African-American model dishes the dirt on her body worries.

 

Follow Cynthia Cheng Mintz on Twitter: www.twitter.com/delectablychic

FOLLOW CANADA STYLE
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
GrantS
I'm liberal through and through.
02:23 PM on 03/03/2013
If she looks healthy then she probably is. Overweight women can look healthy and that is good - many of them probably get hit upon.

Just as an overweight woman can look healthy, so can an anorexic - but the overweight visuals are less appealing.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Cynthia Cheng Mintz
02:48 PM on 03/03/2013
This isn't about what Ms. Chenoweth looks like, it's about how she interacted with other celebrities at the red carpet before the Oscars. I found it interesting that there weren't many (if any) comments about her and how "hyper" and "cute" she acted (which is, in my opinion, a little too "cute" - exactly how one expects short, small-framed women to be like).
09:48 AM on 03/04/2013
So you're upset that she didn't get criticized *enough*? I'm really not clear what your objective is with this article. If anything, should the focus be on reducing criticizing and tearing apart people, not finding new reasons to criticize even more people? If Ms. Chenoweth wants to present herself in a certain manner, that is her prerogative. Criticizing people for infantilizing *others* might make sense, but not this. I get the sense that what you're wanting to say here is that you don't like it when society infantilizes petite women - a valid point - but that's not the article you wrote.
12:45 PM on 03/03/2013
Smaller women are more attractive.
I can't speak for anyone else but they are more attractive because they must (because of their size) need someone to protect them. I don't think smaller women are more beautiful than average size women, they are just more delicate. Right or wrong that's why I am attracted to smaller women, just as you are probable attracted to a certain body type of men. Nature made us the way we are for a reason why try to improve on it. My daughter is petite and let me tell you, when she takes command everyone backs up, even her six foot six husband. Have you ever considered that others, like me, just find petite women attractive and therefore we have nothing to criticize. The only time a petite woman is not taken seriously is when she also has a small mind, and the rest of us would get criticized. If you feel that your size is a burden to you don't used to say to criticize what others do and take control of your own life. My old Grandpappy your shadow is just as long as anyone else's if you stand in the right spot in front of the lamp.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Cynthia Cheng Mintz
02:32 PM on 03/03/2013
But it's unfair that petite women (which, by the way, just means short, period, not necessarily short and small framed) can't openly talk about their body image issues, are told that their issues don't "matter" or worse, that they don't HAVE issues (see CNancy's comment below). This is basically what your comment is implying. It's like saying that many men prefer curvier bodies, yet curvier women (regardless of height) ARE allowed to openly discuss their "body problems" and say that such and such a celebrity is being stereotypical. In fact media will jump on it as soon as they see it.
06:39 PM on 03/03/2013
"...(which, by the way, just means short, period, not necessarily short and small framed) "

You had better look up the definition of the word 'petite' because you are wrong. And while you are at it look for an actual issue instead of whinging and sniping. You sound shrill yourself.
09:32 AM on 03/04/2013
First of all, to me petite means short and normal body, and it only stands to reason that a healthy short woman also has a small frame.
If a short woman has weight problems and is trying to discus it with a large overweight woman she is bound to get such a reply. The rest of those who dismiss you when you complain about your body size are probably telling it like it is, they don't think you have a problem. If your friends won't talk to you when you have any kind of problem you need new friends. I find it hard to believe that if you were to bring up to a friend the issues you have pertaining to problems with your body they would ignore you. Now if you are sincerely saying you believe you are over the weight you would like to be, you will have to deal with it the same way the rest of us do, diet and exercise. If your problem is that you believe you are under the weight, have another beer and plate of hot wings / -:) Good luck to you what ever you are dealing with, and take a good long look in the mirror and you will see why most others don't think you have enough of a problem to complain about.
10:56 AM on 03/03/2013
I don't understand how criticizing someone for their demeanour and demanding that celebrity figures take on the responsibility to act less cute is progressive for equality in any way. If you are not happy with the women that are on platforms, be different and form your own. Paying attention to their short falls isn't going to get everyone else moving forward. Focus on what is progressive and good. If women focused more on themselves and less on everyone around them, we'd get ahead faster.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Cynthia Cheng Mintz
11:57 AM on 03/04/2013
I don't think people are getting it. The issue here is that when it comes to body image discussion, only larger sizes need apply. Smaller women, regardless of whether it's about one's personality, how one looks or size in general, aren't worth discussing. If we are going to be equal, we must open the discussion to issues regarding smaller people as well. Do you know how often "petite issue" comments are openly dismissed or only given lip service by people who are for size equality?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:09 PM on 03/02/2013
It is very simple, Tiny women make your penis look huge by contrast.
03:54 PM on 03/02/2013
What did Kristin Chenoweth say or do that was so annoying? From what I have seen of her work she is a comedian. Tiny, cute and sexy is her professional persona. Given her stature I doubt she has much opportunity for serious roles.

Generally speaking yes, small women being taken less seriously is a problem. But as an individual small woman I don't think Kristin is doing anything wrong in playing to her strengths professionally.

The roles I have seen her in have not made smaller women look less mature than other people in the same production.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Cynthia Cheng Mintz
10:02 AM on 03/03/2013
It's not the roles she's played per se, but her cute and adorable personality when she is hosting or when she appears on talk shows. It's the ultimate stereotype of what petite women under, say, 50 or 60 should be like. And yes, it's interesting how the media have not criticized that, while they would do so if she were not small-framed.
11:44 AM on 03/03/2013
But maybe that's just...who she is? If you don't like her, that's fine. But I think you are going a bit far.
09:52 AM on 03/04/2013
And if that's just who she is, doesn't she have the freedom to be that? Or do you believe she has a responsibility to represent all petite women everywhere?
01:36 PM on 03/02/2013
Another issue I have is the way in which plus size women are often referred to as "real women". Does being petite because of my genetic background and healthy lifestyle make me any less real?
10:38 AM on 03/02/2013
My wife is tiny (5' tall and approx 98 lbs) and is often the target of other women's vitriol. At work as well as in social settings, the "accept your body" crew hypocritically criticize her for "buying into" the "thin is in" mentality. The thing is, we are very healthy eaters and my wife just happens to have a certain genetic propensity for "smallness". We have been married for eleven years (together for 14) and I have NEVER seen her "diet". It seems that it is socially unacceptable to criticize someone for being overweight (even though there are serious health consequences to obesity) but sniping at someone who is smaller is fair game. This is hypocrisy plain and simple.
12:33 AM on 03/03/2013
I know this all too well...being a small women I'm not allowed to comment on food, clothing sizes, hating my body image at all, etc. because it pisses off other women even if that's the topic of the hour. Should I really have to apologize for your insecurities? I have my own, you certainly aren't helping them along!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Boinko
09:50 AM on 03/02/2013
Alright, I'm totally on board with this. Lets add petite women to the list of body types we don't like. They've been getting a free pass for too long.
Next up, tall men. Time to take them down a peg or two as well.
photo
AcunningDisguise
magnus gigas caput
06:23 AM on 03/02/2013
They write entire songs about small people...
01:15 AM on 03/02/2013
Interesting but I dont completely understand what you mean... And have never heard of the celeb you mention. (can't picture her) if you gave examples of the criticism other women get that would help me understand
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Cynthia Cheng Mintz
01:48 PM on 03/02/2013
Hi katialuu:

What I was trying to discuss was how media are up in arms when "larger" women are portrayed a certain way or act a certain way in public, while no one bothers to say anything when one is short and small-framed. In fact, we aren't even taken all that seriously if we even say that it is an issue. As for the celebrity I mentioned in the article, Kristin is the person who interviews Adele in the fifth video:

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/02/24/best-2013-oscar-moments-red-carpet-anne-hathaway-more-video.html
(she's not that bad in terms of being "giddy" there)

and here she is on Ellen: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GuVWAPDZrAE
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dolly Lama
I think too much
12:51 AM on 03/02/2013
As a very small person all I can say is that no one ever takes us seriously! It is like we are harmless pets or something. I am a small person with a large personality, believe me when I say it never goes over well! My guess is we are expected to be demure and cute and that is all!
12:55 PM on 03/03/2013
Dolly, the next time someone doesn't take you seriously, kick then in the shin, and if they ignore you, make more noise. You don't have to have a small personality just because you have a small body. Take advantage of the fact that men are attracted to you, but remember a man likes a woman to also be firery. My daughter is petite and when being ignored in a group she just talks louder, and if that doesn't work she will climb somebody's frame. That seems to work.